7.1 Land and water rights

Land and water rights are central to Indigenous struggles for self-determination and cultural survival. These rights clash with European concepts of private property, leading to centuries of conflict and dispossession. Indigenous peoples view land as sacred, with communal ownership and deep spiritual connections.

Legal frameworks like treaties and land claim settlements attempt to address Indigenous rights, but implementation is often lacking. Indigenous communities continue to fight for recognition through protests, occupations, and court challenges. Water rights are equally critical, with Indigenous access threatened by resource extraction and environmental degradation.

Indigenous perspectives on land ownership

• Indigenous worldviews often emphasize a deep spiritual connection to the land, viewing it as a sacred gift and responsibility rather than a commodity to be owned or exploited
• Land is seen as the source of life, culture, and identity, with a reciprocal relationship between people and the environment
• Indigenous land tenure systems are typically communal, with rights and responsibilities shared among the community rather than held by individuals

European concepts of land rights

• European colonizers brought with them a concept of land as private property that could be bought, sold, and exploited for personal gain
• This view was rooted in ideas of individual ownership, exclusive use, and the right to develop or dispose of land as the owner saw fit
• European legal systems codified these concepts through instruments such as land titles, deeds, and surveys, which were used to assert control over Indigenous territories

Conflicts over land and resources

• The clash between Indigenous and European perspectives on land ownership has led to centuries of conflict and dispossession as colonizers sought to impose their systems and exploit Indigenous lands and resources
• Indigenous peoples have faced displacement from their traditional territories, destruction of sacred sites, and disruption of traditional practices as a result of these conflicts

Displacement from traditional territories

Top images from around the web for Displacement from traditional territories

• 

  File:Frederick William Woodhouse - The first settlers discover Buckley, 1861.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Distribution of Indigenous Peoples in the Americas.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Frederick William Woodhouse - The first settlers discover Buckley, 1861.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Displacement from traditional territories

• 

  File:Frederick William Woodhouse - The first settlers discover Buckley, 1861.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Distribution of Indigenous Peoples in the Americas.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Frederick William Woodhouse - The first settlers discover Buckley, 1861.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Colonial policies such as the Indian Removal Act in the United States and the reserve system in Canada forcibly removed Indigenous peoples from their ancestral lands to make way for European settlement and resource extraction
• This displacement severed Indigenous connections to the land and disrupted traditional ways of life, causing immense social, cultural, and economic harm

Destruction of sacred sites

• Many Indigenous cultures have sacred sites and landscapes that are essential to their spiritual practices and cultural identity, such as burial grounds, ceremonial places, and natural features like mountains or rivers
• European colonization and development often targeted these sites for destruction or desecration, as in the case of the Black Hills (sacred to the Lakota) or Mauna Kea (sacred to Native Hawaiians)

Disruption of traditional practices

• Displacement and destruction of Indigenous lands also disrupted traditional practices such as hunting, gathering, fishing, and agriculture that were essential to Indigenous economies and cultures
• The loss of access to traditional territories and resources made it difficult or impossible for Indigenous peoples to maintain these practices and pass them on to future generations

Legal frameworks for land rights

• Over time, various legal frameworks have been developed to address Indigenous land rights, though these have often been inadequate or ignored in practice
• Historic treaties and agreements between Indigenous nations and colonial powers set out some land rights and obligations, while modern land claim settlements have sought to resolve outstanding issues and provide a basis for Indigenous self-determination

Historic treaties and agreements

• Many Indigenous nations entered into treaties with European powers that recognized their inherent rights to their traditional territories and established nation-to-nation relationships
• However, these treaties were often violated or ignored by colonial governments seeking to expand their control over Indigenous lands (Treaty of Waitangi in New Zealand, Royal Proclamation of 1763 in Canada)

Modern land claim settlements

• In the 20th and 21st centuries, some Indigenous peoples have successfully negotiated land claim settlements with national governments to resolve outstanding issues and establish a new legal basis for their land rights
• These settlements typically involve the return of some traditional territories, financial compensation, and recognition of Indigenous rights to manage and benefit from their lands (Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, Nunavut Land Claims Agreement)

Struggles for land rights recognition

• Despite legal frameworks, Indigenous peoples have often had to fight for recognition and enforcement of their land rights through various forms of resistance and advocacy
• This has included protests and occupations to assert control over traditional territories, as well as court challenges and rulings to establish legal precedents for Indigenous land rights

Protests and occupations

• Indigenous communities have used direct action tactics like protests, blockades, and occupations to physically assert their presence on and control over their traditional territories
• Examples include the Oka Crisis in Quebec, the Standing Rock protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline, and the Unist'ot'en Camp in British Columbia

Court challenges and rulings

• Indigenous peoples have also used legal channels to challenge violations of their land rights and establish legal precedents for their recognition
• Landmark rulings like the Calder case in Canada, the Mabo decision in Australia, and the Awas Tingni case in Nicaragua have affirmed Indigenous land rights under national and international law

Water rights and access

• Water is a critical resource for Indigenous peoples, with deep cultural and spiritual significance as well as practical importance for sustaining life and traditional practices
• However, Indigenous water rights and access have often been threatened by colonial policies, resource extraction, and environmental degradation

Importance of water in Indigenous cultures

• Many Indigenous cultures view water as a sacred element, with spiritual powers and connections to creation stories, ceremonies, and healing practices (Mni Wiconi/"Water is Life" for the Standing Rock Sioux)
• Water also plays a central role in traditional subsistence practices like fishing, agriculture, and gathering of aquatic plants and medicines

Threats to water resources

• Indigenous water resources have been threatened by a range of factors, including:
  • Damming and diversion of rivers for hydroelectric power, irrigation, and flood control
  • Pollution from mining, oil and gas extraction, and industrial development
  • Overuse and depletion of aquifers and groundwater
  • Climate change impacts like drought, flooding, and warming water temperatures

Legal recognition of water rights

• Indigenous peoples have sought legal recognition of their inherent rights to water as part of their traditional territories and as necessary for their cultural and physical survival
• In some cases, these rights have been affirmed through treaties, court rulings, or modern agreements (Winters Doctrine in the US, Aboriginal water rights in Australia)
• However, the implementation and enforcement of these rights has often been lacking, leading to ongoing conflicts and challenges

Contemporary land use conflicts

• Despite some progress in recognizing Indigenous land rights, conflicts continue to arise over how Indigenous lands and resources are used and managed
• These conflicts often pit Indigenous interests in protecting their territories and practicing their traditional ways of life against pressures for resource extraction and economic development

Resource extraction projects

• Indigenous lands are often targeted for resource extraction projects like mining, logging, and oil and gas development, which can have devastating impacts on the environment and Indigenous communities
• Examples include the Tar Sands in Alberta, the Pebble Mine in Alaska, and illegal logging in the Amazon rainforest
• Indigenous peoples have resisted these projects through legal challenges, protests, and direct action to protect their lands and assert their rights

Environmental conservation efforts

• In some cases, Indigenous peoples have also come into conflict with environmental conservation efforts that seek to protect lands and resources without respecting Indigenous rights and interests
• This can include the creation of protected areas that restrict Indigenous access and use, or conservation policies that prioritize wilderness preservation over Indigenous land management practices
• Indigenous peoples have advocated for a more inclusive and collaborative approach to conservation that recognizes their role as stewards of their traditional territories

Indigenous land management practices

• Indigenous peoples have developed sophisticated land management practices over thousands of years that sustain both human communities and the natural environment
• These practices are rooted in deep knowledge of local ecosystems and a holistic understanding of the interconnections between people, plants, animals, and the land

Traditional ecological knowledge

• Indigenous land management is guided by traditional ecological knowledge (TEK), which encompasses the accumulated wisdom, practices, and beliefs of Indigenous peoples about their environment
• TEK includes detailed knowledge of plants, animals, weather patterns, and ecological processes, as well as cultural values and protocols for sustainable use and stewardship of resources
• This knowledge is passed down through generations and adapted over time to changing conditions, providing a valuable source of resilience and innovation

Co-management arrangements

• In some cases, Indigenous peoples have entered into co-management arrangements with governments or other stakeholders to share responsibility for managing lands and resources
• These arrangements can take various forms, such as joint decision-making bodies, collaborative planning processes, or Indigenous-led management with government support
• Successful co-management requires respect for Indigenous knowledge and authority, as well as a commitment to building trust and mutual understanding between partners

Economic development and land rights

• Land rights are essential for Indigenous peoples to pursue sustainable economic development and build thriving communities on their own terms
• However, the relationship between land rights and economic development is complex, with both opportunities and challenges for Indigenous peoples

Indigenous-owned businesses

• Secure land rights can provide a foundation for Indigenous-owned businesses that create jobs, generate income, and reinvest in local communities
• Examples include Indigenous-owned forestry companies, ecotourism ventures, and renewable energy projects that align with cultural values and environmental stewardship
• However, Indigenous entrepreneurs often face barriers to accessing capital, markets, and business support services that limit their growth and success

Balancing development and conservation

• Indigenous peoples also face difficult choices in balancing economic development opportunities with the need to protect their lands, resources, and cultural heritage
• Some development projects, such as mining or oil and gas extraction, may offer short-term economic benefits but cause long-term harm to the environment and Indigenous ways of life
• Indigenous communities have sought to navigate these trade-offs by developing their own protocols and criteria for assessing development proposals and ensuring that benefits are shared equitably

Cultural significance of land

• For Indigenous peoples, land is not just a source of material sustenance but a fundamental part of their cultural identity, spirituality, and social relations
• The cultural significance of land is deeply rooted in Indigenous languages, knowledge systems, and practices that have evolved in relationship with specific territories over thousands of years

Connection to ancestral territories

• Indigenous peoples have a deep connection to their ancestral territories, which are often described as "homelands" or "Country" that sustain both physical and spiritual well-being
• This connection is maintained through regular visits, ceremonies, and cultural practices that renew the bond between people and place across generations
• Displacement from ancestral territories can cause profound cultural disruption and loss, as well as feelings of homesickness, grief, and disconnection

Land-based language and knowledge

• Indigenous languages and knowledge systems are intimately tied to the lands where they have developed, with place names, stories, and ecological knowledge encoded in the language and passed down through oral traditions
• The loss of Indigenous languages and the erosion of land-based knowledge systems are closely linked, as both are threatened by displacement, assimilation policies, and environmental changes
• Efforts to revitalize Indigenous languages and knowledge often involve reconnecting with traditional territories and practices, such as land-based education programs and cultural camps

Land rights and self-determination

• For Indigenous peoples, land rights are not just about ownership and access to resources, but a fundamental aspect of their right to self-determination as distinct peoples with their own cultures, identities, and ways of life
• Securing land rights is seen as essential for Indigenous peoples to regain control over their own destinies and build sustainable futures on their own terms

Control over resources and development

• Land rights give Indigenous peoples the power to make decisions about how their lands and resources are used and developed, rather than being subject to the whims of colonial governments or outside interests
• This includes the right to give or withhold consent for development projects, to negotiate benefit-sharing agreements, and to pursue their own visions for sustainable resource management
• Indigenous control over resources is also key for addressing historic injustices and ensuring that the benefits of development flow to Indigenous communities rather than being extracted by others

Strengthening Indigenous governance

• Land rights also provide a foundation for strengthening Indigenous governance systems, which have often been undermined or suppressed by colonial policies and institutions
• With secure land bases and resource rights, Indigenous peoples can rebuild their own institutions for decision-making, dispute resolution, and community development based on their own cultural values and protocols
• This can include revitalizing traditional leadership and governance structures, developing new forms of Indigenous-led organizations and enterprises, and asserting jurisdiction over key areas like education, health, and social services
• Ultimately, land rights and self-determination are seen as mutually reinforcing, with strong Indigenous governance enabling the effective exercise of land rights, and land rights providing the resources and legitimacy for Indigenous self-government