8.2 Structural and cultural factors in movement formation

Social movements emerge from a complex interplay of structural and cultural factors. Political openness, economic conditions, and social cleavages create opportunities or constraints for mobilization. These structural elements shape the landscape in which movements operate, influencing their goals and strategies.

Cultural factors like shared beliefs, identities, and symbols provide the glue that binds movements together. They help frame grievances, mobilize supporters, and legitimize claims. The interaction between structural and cultural elements ultimately determines a movement's trajectory and impact on society.

Structural Factors for Social Movements

Political, Economic, and Social Conditions

Top images from around the web for Political, Economic, and Social Conditions

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements | Boundless Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Social Movements Shape the Political Economy - LAOMS View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements | Boundless Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Political, Economic, and Social Conditions

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements | Boundless Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Social Movements Shape the Political Economy - LAOMS View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements | Boundless Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Political factors include the openness or closure of the political system, the presence or absence of political allies, and the level of state repression
  • Open political systems provide more opportunities for social movements to influence policy and gain access to decision-making processes (democratic societies)
  • Closed political systems, characterized by repression and limited political freedoms, pose significant challenges for social movements (authoritarian regimes)
  • Political allies, such as sympathetic politicians or political parties, can provide valuable support and resources for social movements
• Economic factors encompass issues such as income inequality, economic crises, and the distribution of resources within a society
  • High levels of income inequality can fuel social discontent and provide a basis for mobilizing disadvantaged groups (Occupy Wall Street movement)
  • Economic crises, such as recessions or depressions, can create a sense of urgency and motivate collective action to address economic grievances
  • The unequal distribution of resources, such as wealth, education, and healthcare, can generate feelings of injustice and inspire demands for social change
• Social conditions refer to the demographic composition of a society, the level of social cohesion or fragmentation, and the existence of social cleavages along lines of race, class, gender, or ethnicity
  • Demographic factors, such as population growth, urbanization, and migration patterns, can shape the social landscape and create new constituencies for social movements
  • Social cohesion, or the degree of unity and solidarity within a society, can influence the ability of social movements to mobilize broad-based support
  • Social cleavages, based on factors such as race, class, gender, or ethnicity, can provide a basis for collective identity and shared grievances (Civil Rights Movement, Women's Suffrage Movement)

Opportunities and Constraints

• The combination of these structural factors can create opportunities or constraints for social movements to emerge and mobilize support
  • Favorable political opportunities, such as the presence of allies or the opening of institutional channels, can provide social movements with avenues for influence and change
  • Economic crises or shifts in the distribution of resources can create a sense of urgency and mobilize people around shared economic interests
  • Demographic changes, such as the growth of a particular population segment or the emergence of new social cleavages, can provide a basis for collective action and identity formation
  • Repressive political conditions, entrenched economic inequalities, or deep social divisions can pose significant obstacles to social movement mobilization and success

Cultural Factors in Social Movements

Shared Beliefs, Values, and Identities

• Shared beliefs and values provide a common framework for interpreting social reality and defining collective goals, which can motivate individuals to participate in social movements
  • Religious beliefs, such as the commitment to social justice in liberation theology, can inspire and sustain social movement activism (Latin American social movements)
  • Political ideologies, such as socialism or feminism, can provide a coherent worldview and a set of principles that guide social movement actions and demands
  • Cultural values, such as the emphasis on individual rights or communal solidarity, can shape the priorities and tactics of social movements
• Collective identities, such as those based on race, class, gender, or sexuality, can foster a sense of solidarity and shared purpose among movement participants
  • Racial or ethnic identities can provide a powerful basis for mobilizing communities around shared experiences of discrimination or marginalization (Black Lives Matter movement)
  • Class identities, such as working-class solidarity, can unite individuals across other social differences in pursuit of common economic goals (labor movements)
  • Gender and sexual identities can inspire collective action to challenge patriarchal norms and demand equal rights and recognition (LGBTQ+ movements)

Symbols, Narratives, and Frames

• Cultural symbols, narratives, and frames help social movements communicate their message, mobilize support, and legitimize their claims
  • Symbols, such as the rainbow flag for the LGBTQ+ movement or the raised fist for the Black Power movement, can serve as powerful visual representations of a movement's identity and values
  • Narratives, such as stories of injustice or heroic struggle, can evoke emotional responses and create a sense of shared history and purpose among movement participants
  • Frames, or ways of presenting and interpreting issues, can help social movements connect their specific demands to broader cultural themes and values (framing environmental protection as a matter of intergenerational justice)
• The resonance of a movement's cultural elements with the broader cultural context can influence its ability to gain public support and maintain momentum over time
  • Movements that tap into widely held cultural values or beliefs, such as the idea of equal rights or the importance of family, may find it easier to generate public sympathy and support
  • Movements that challenge deeply entrenched cultural norms or beliefs may face greater resistance and require more extensive cultural work to shift public opinion and gain legitimacy

Interaction of Structural and Cultural Factors

Shaping Goals and Strategies

• Structural factors can shape the goals and strategies of social movements by defining the political and economic constraints and opportunities they face
  • The level of state repression or the availability of institutional channels for participation can influence whether movements adopt more confrontational or accommodating strategies
  • Economic conditions, such as the level of inequality or the state of the economy, can shape the specific demands and targets of social movements (anti-austerity protests during economic crises)
• Cultural factors, such as shared values and identities, can influence the framing of movement goals and the selection of tactics that align with the movement's cultural orientation
  • Movements rooted in religious or moral traditions may emphasize non-violent civil disobedience and appeal to higher principles (Mahatma Gandhi's philosophy of non-violence in the Indian independence movement)
  • Movements that prioritize individual autonomy and direct action may favor more decentralized and confrontational tactics (anarchist movements)

Variations in Movement Outcomes

• The interaction between structural and cultural factors can lead to variations in movement outcomes, such as the degree of policy change, cultural shift, or institutional reform achieved
  • Movements that successfully navigate political opportunities and constraints while resonating with broader cultural values may be more likely to achieve significant policy reforms or institutional changes (Civil Rights Movement leading to the passage of the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act)
  • Movements that primarily focus on cultural change and identity formation may have a more gradual and diffuse impact on social norms, values, and practices (LGBTQ+ movement leading to greater social acceptance and cultural visibility of diverse gender and sexual identities)
• The relative importance of structural and cultural factors may vary depending on the specific social movement context and the stage of the movement's development
  • In the early stages of a movement, cultural factors such as the creation of a collective identity and the articulation of shared grievances may be more critical for mobilizing initial support
  • As a movement grows and engages with the political system, structural factors such as access to institutional channels or the response of political elites may become more significant in shaping the movement's trajectory and outcomes

Structural vs Cultural Factors in Social Movements

Relative Importance in Different Contexts

• In some cases, structural factors may play a more significant role in shaping the emergence and trajectory of a social movement, particularly when political or economic conditions create a favorable opportunity structure
  • The collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War created new political opportunities for democratic movements in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet republics
  • The 2008 financial crisis and subsequent economic downturn fueled the rise of anti-austerity and Occupy movements in many countries
• In other instances, cultural factors may be more critical in sustaining a movement's momentum and mobilizing support, especially when the movement seeks to challenge deeply entrenched cultural norms or values
  • The women's suffrage movement in the early 20th century relied heavily on cultural work, such as public demonstrations, artistic performances, and the creation of new symbols and slogans, to challenge prevailing gender norms and argue for women's right to vote
  • The environmental movement has often emphasized the cultural values of sustainability, harmony with nature, and intergenerational responsibility to build broad-based support for its goals

Comparative Analysis

• The relative importance of structural and cultural factors may also shift over time as the movement evolves and the broader social and political context changes
  • The U.S. civil rights movement in the 1950s and 1960s benefited from a favorable political opportunity structure, including the support of liberal politicians and the federal government, but also relied on cultural factors such as the creation of a collective identity around the concept of black pride and the use of religious symbolism and rhetoric
  • As the movement faced increasing political opposition and repression in the late 1960s, cultural factors such as the rise of black nationalism and the emphasis on self-determination became more prominent in shaping the movement's direction
• Comparative analysis of different social movements can help illuminate the varying roles and interactions of structural and cultural factors in shaping movement dynamics and outcomes
  • Comparing the civil rights movement in the United States with the anti-apartheid movement in South Africa can highlight the different ways in which political opportunities, international pressure, and cultural mobilization interacted to produce social change
  • Analyzing the women's movement in different countries can reveal how variations in political systems, economic conditions, and cultural norms shape the goals, strategies, and outcomes of feminist activism