10.5 Intertemporal choice and hyperbolic discounting

Intertemporal choice examines how we make decisions involving costs and benefits at different times. It's key to understanding saving, spending, and investing behaviors, with time preferences and discount rates playing crucial roles in shaping our choices.

Hyperbolic discounting challenges traditional economic models by showing we value immediate rewards more strongly than future ones. This explains behaviors like procrastination and impulsive spending, and has important implications for personal finance and policy-making.

Intertemporal Choice in Economics

Time-Based Decision Making

Top images from around the web for Time-Based Decision Making

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Time-Based Decision Making

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Intertemporal choice involves tradeoffs between costs and benefits occurring at different points in time
• Fundamental to understanding individual decisions about saving, spending, and investing across various time horizons
• Time preferences reflect how individuals value present versus future consumption
• Discount rate represents the rate at which future values are discounted to present values in intertemporal choice models
• Applies to various economic behaviors (retirement planning, education investments, long-term financial decisions)
• Closely related to rational choice theory and utility maximization over time

Key Components of Intertemporal Choice

• Present value calculates the current worth of a future sum of money given a specified rate of return
• Future value determines the value of a current asset at a specified date in the future based on an assumed growth rate
• Opportunity cost considers the potential returns foregone by choosing one option over another
• Risk and uncertainty factor into decisions involving future outcomes
• Liquidity preference influences the willingness to hold cash versus other assets
• Time horizon affects the weight given to short-term versus long-term consequences

Hyperbolic vs Exponential Discounting

Characteristics of Hyperbolic Discounting

• Time-inconsistent model where discount rate decreases over time
• Stronger preference for immediate payoffs when choosing between near-term options compared to long-term options
• Discount function characterized by steep initial decline followed by gradual decrease
• Can lead to preference reversals as time to decision approaches
• Better explains observed human behavior in various economic contexts (procrastination, self-control problems)
• Challenges assumption of time consistency in traditional economic models

Comparison with Exponential Discounting

• Exponential discounting assumes constant discount rate over time
• Hyperbolic discounting results in higher discount rates for near-term periods compared to exponential discounting
• Exponential discounting maintains time consistency, while hyperbolic allows for changing preferences
• Hyperbolic model often provides better fit to empirical data on intertemporal choice
• Exponential discounting aligns with rational choice theory, while hyperbolic incorporates behavioral insights
• Mathematical representations differ: hyperbolic uses hyperbolic functions, exponential uses exponential functions

Implications of Hyperbolic Discounting

Financial Decision Making

• Can lead to undersaving due to undervaluing future benefits relative to present consumption
• Explains difficulty in sticking to long-term financial plans (retirement savings, debt repayment)
• May result in preference for short-term gains over potentially larger long-term returns in investments
• Affects consumption patterns, leading to impulsive spending or choosing smaller immediate rewards
• Contributes to time-inconsistent preferences, causing conflicts between short-term desires and long-term goals
• Explains effectiveness of commitment devices (automatic savings plans, self-imposed penalties) in promoting long-term financial well-being

Behavioral Consequences

• Helps understand procrastination in tasks with future benefits but immediate costs (studying, exercise)
• Explains addiction and behaviors involving immediate gratification at expense of future well-being
• Can lead to cyclical behavior patterns (dieting followed by overeating)
• Influences career choices, potentially favoring jobs with immediate rewards over long-term growth potential
• Affects decision-making in healthcare (preventive care, medication adherence)
• Impacts environmental choices, potentially undervaluing long-term sustainability for short-term convenience

Policy Implications of Intertemporal Choice

Retirement and Financial Planning

• Supports policies encouraging early and consistent retirement savings (automatic enrollment in pension plans)
• Justifies design of commitment devices in public policy (locked savings accounts, cooling-off periods for major financial decisions)
• Informs development of financial literacy programs incorporating insights from hyperbolic discounting research
• Suggests need for policies addressing undersaving (matching contributions, tax incentives)
• Supports implementation of default options favoring long-term financial health in retirement plans
• Encourages development of apps and tools leveraging behavioral insights to promote better financial planning

Environmental and Public Health Policies

• Environmental conservation policies may need to account for undervaluing of future benefits
• Justifies stronger present-day regulations or incentives for environmental protection
• Informs design of public health campaigns, particularly for reducing behaviors with long-term negative consequences
• Climate change policies may need to emphasize short-term co-benefits to overcome discounting of long-term impacts
• Supports implementation of immediate rewards for environmentally friendly behaviors (tax rebates for electric vehicles)
• Suggests framing of public health messages to highlight near-term benefits of healthy behaviors