9.1 Economic Sanctions as a Tool of Foreign Policy

Economic sanctions are a powerful tool in foreign policy, used to pressure countries into changing their behavior. From targeted measures against individuals to comprehensive sanctions affecting entire economies, these penalties can have far-reaching consequences.

Sanctions can be imposed unilaterally or multilaterally, with varying degrees of effectiveness. While they can signal international disapproval and impose economic costs, sanctions often raise concerns about humanitarian impact and unintended consequences on global trade and diplomacy.

Types of Economic Sanctions

Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions

Top images from around the web for Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions

• 

  US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Targeted vs. Comprehensive Sanctions

• 

  US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  US Sanctions Are Designed to Kill | Op-Eds & Columns | CEPR View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Economic Sanctions | All About World Politics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Economic sanctions are penalties imposed by countries or international organizations against a target country, entity, or individual to coerce a change in behavior
• Smart sanctions (targeted sanctions) focus on specific individuals, organizations, or sectors to minimize the impact on the general population (freezing assets, travel bans, arms embargoes)
• Comprehensive sanctions broadly target an entire country's economy, including trade restrictions, financial sanctions, and investment prohibitions (U.S. sanctions against Iran, Cuba)
• Comprehensive sanctions often lead to significant humanitarian consequences for the civilian population (food and medicine shortages, economic hardship)

Unilateral vs. Multilateral Sanctions

• Unilateral sanctions are imposed by a single country against a target state without the cooperation or support of other nations (U.S. sanctions against North Korea)
• Multilateral sanctions involve the coordination and participation of multiple countries, increasing the pressure on the target state to comply
• United Nations sanctions are a form of multilateral sanctions imposed by the UN Security Council, binding all UN member states to enforce them (sanctions against Iraq, Libya, North Korea)
• Multilateral sanctions are generally considered more effective than unilateral measures due to the collective pressure and international legitimacy

Actors in Economic Sanctions

Sender and Target States

• The target state is the country, entity, or individual against whom the sanctions are imposed, with the goal of changing their behavior or policies
• The sender state is the country or group of countries imposing the sanctions, often in response to violations of international norms or threats to peace and security
• Sender states aim to inflict economic costs on the target state to pressure them into compliance with specific demands (ending human rights abuses, halting nuclear proliferation)
• Target states may seek to evade or counteract sanctions through various means (smuggling, alternative trade routes, domestic production)

Impact and Consequences of Sanctions

Effectiveness and Humanitarian Concerns

• The effectiveness of sanctions in achieving their intended goals is often debated, with success rates varying depending on the specific case and context
• Sanctions can be effective in signaling international disapproval, isolating the target state, and imposing economic costs, but may not always lead to the desired policy changes
• Humanitarian impact is a major concern with comprehensive sanctions, as they can lead to shortages of essential goods, reduced access to healthcare and education, and increased poverty
• Critics argue that sanctions often disproportionately affect vulnerable populations while failing to change the behavior of the targeted regime or individuals

Secondary Sanctions and Global Impact

• Secondary sanctions are penalties imposed on third-party countries, entities, or individuals for engaging in transactions with the primary target of sanctions (U.S. secondary sanctions related to Iran)
• Secondary sanctions aim to deter other actors from undermining the effectiveness of the primary sanctions by threatening them with penalties for non-compliance
• The use of secondary sanctions can lead to tensions between the sender state and its allies or trading partners, as they may view them as an extraterritorial application of domestic law
• The global impact of sanctions can be significant, disrupting international trade, financial flows, and diplomatic relations, with potential spillover effects on regional stability and global economic growth