8.5 Resistance, Revolution, and Social Movements

Social movements and resistance shape societies worldwide. From the Arab Spring to Indigenous land protection efforts, these collective actions challenge power structures and push for change. Understanding their goals, tactics, and outcomes is crucial for grasping political dynamics.

Anthropologists study resistance through fieldwork, historical analysis, and cross-cultural comparisons. They examine how movements mobilize, use different tactics, and navigate challenges. This research reveals the complexities of social change and the diverse ways people fight for justice and representation.

Social Movements and Resistance

Social movements vs political parties

Top images from around the web for Social movements vs political parties

• 

  Political Parties: What are they and how do they function? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Collective Action and Interest Group Formation – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Political Parties: What are they and how do they function? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Collective Action and Interest Group Formation – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Social movements vs political parties

• 

  Political Parties: What are they and how do they function? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Collective Action and Interest Group Formation – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Political Parties: What are they and how do they function? | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Collective Action and Interest Group Formation – Introduction to American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Social movements organize collective action to promote or resist social change, often focusing on specific issues (civil rights, environmentalism, women's suffrage) and operating outside established political channels
• Political parties are organized groups seeking to influence government policy through electoral politics, typically with broad platforms addressing multiple issues, operating within the political system to gain power through elections (Democratic Party, Republican Party, Green Party)

Goals and outcomes of Arab Spring

• Goals: Overthrow authoritarian regimes, establish democratic governments, address corruption, unemployment, lack of political freedom
• Outcomes varied:
  1. Success in some countries establishing democratic governments (Tunisia)
  2. Ongoing civil wars in others (Syria, Libya)
  3. Little change or authoritarian regimes reasserting control (Egypt, Bahrain)
• Lessons: Revolution doesn't always lead to desired outcomes, establishing stable democratic institutions is a long-term process, external factors like foreign intervention can significantly impact outcomes

Limitations of democratic representation

• Majority-rule systems can marginalize minority groups lacking numbers to elect representatives prioritizing their interests, with majority groups passing laws disproportionately harming minorities
• Barriers to political participation include voter suppression tactics (strict voter ID laws, limited polling locations) disproportionately impacting marginalized groups and lack of resources (time, money) limiting their ability to engage in political activism
• Lack of diversity in political leadership means elected officials may not reflect population diversity, leading to policies failing to address needs of marginalized groups
• Civil society organizations play a crucial role in advocating for marginalized groups and holding governments accountable

Anthropological Perspectives on Resistance

Anthropological study of resistance

• Ethnographic fieldwork involves participant observation and interviews with social movement members to understand motivations, strategies, experiences of activists
• Historical analysis examines social, political, economic contexts giving rise to resistance and social movements, tracing their evolution and societal impact over time
• Comparative analysis compares resistance and social movements across cultures and historical periods to identify common patterns and unique features

Indigenous movements for land protection

• Indigenous groups have formed movements to resist colonization, dispossession, forced relocation, land seizures, cultural assimilation (American Indian Movement, Idle No More, Zapatista uprising)
• Movements assert Indigenous sovereignty, protect traditional ways of life, demand land rights, language preservation, control over natural resources (Kayapo resistance to Amazon deforestation, Maori sovereignty movement in New Zealand)
• Grassroots organizing is often central to these movements, building community support and leadership from the ground up

Forms and effectiveness of resistance

• Nonviolent resistance tactics (protests, boycotts, civil disobedience) can garner public support and pressure authorities to change (Indian independence movement, US civil rights movement)
• Violent resistance tactics (armed struggle, sabotage, terrorism) may be seen as a last resort when nonviolent methods fail, but can escalate conflict and lose public support (Irish Republican Army, Palestinian Liberation Organization)
• Effectiveness factors include level of public support and participation, ability to disrupt normal societal functioning, authority response (concessions vs repression), external support from other movements or nations

Mobilization and Social Justice

• Collective action is crucial for social movements to achieve their goals, often requiring coordination of diverse groups and resources
• Social justice serves as a motivating force and end goal for many resistance movements, addressing systemic inequalities and discrimination
• Protest tactics vary widely, from peaceful demonstrations to more confrontational approaches, and their choice can significantly impact a movement's public perception and success
• Effective mobilization often involves building coalitions, raising awareness, and developing strategies to overcome obstacles to participation