2.2 Deciding Whether and How to Enforce a Patent

Patent enforcement strategies are crucial for protecting intellectual property rights. These strategies encompass licensing, selling, litigation, and alternative dispute resolution methods. Each approach offers unique benefits and challenges for patent holders seeking to maximize the value of their inventions.

Enforcing patents involves weighing costs and potential rewards. Time and financial considerations play a significant role in decision-making. Strategic planning is essential, aligning enforcement efforts with business goals and available resources. Effective patent management and strategy are key to successful enforcement.

Patent Enforcement Strategies

Options for patent enforcement

Top images from around the web for Options for patent enforcement

• 

  Courts and Legal Research | Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Licensing - Essential skills for reproducible research computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federal Trade Commission nears final step in launching Patent Assertion Entities study ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Courts and Legal Research | Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Licensing - Essential skills for reproducible research computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Options for patent enforcement

• 

  Courts and Legal Research | Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Licensing - Essential skills for reproducible research computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federal Trade Commission nears final step in launching Patent Assertion Entities study ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Courts and Legal Research | Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Licensing - Essential skills for reproducible research computing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Licensing the patent grants rights to another party to use the invention
  • Exclusive license gives the licensee sole rights to use the patent (Polaroid's instant camera technology)
  • Non-exclusive license allows multiple licensees to use the patent (MP3 audio coding format)
  • Cross-licensing involves two or more parties licensing patents to each other (Microsoft and Samsung's smartphone patent cross-licensing)
• Selling the patent transfers ownership rights to another party (Kodak's digital imaging patents sold to a consortium)
• Litigation involves legal action against alleged infringers
  • Filing a patent infringement lawsuit in federal court asserts the patent owner's rights (Apple v. Samsung smartphone patent battles)
  • Seeking an injunction to stop infringing activities prevents the alleged infringer from continuing to make, use, or sell the patented invention
  • Pursuing damages for past infringement compensates the patent owner for losses due to the infringement (reasonable royalties or lost profits)
• Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) provides options outside of court
  • Mediation involves a neutral third party facilitating a settlement (WIPO Mediation and Arbitration Center)
  • Arbitration is a private, binding process where a neutral third party makes a decision (International Chamber of Commerce arbitration)
• International Trade Commission (ITC) proceedings address unfair practices in import trade
  • Section 337 investigations can lead to exclusion orders barring infringing products from entry into the US (Segway's ITC complaint against hoverboard importers)
• Patent assertion entities (PAEs) or non-practicing entities (NPEs) acquire and enforce patents without practicing the invention themselves (Intellectual Ventures, a prominent NPE)

Costs and rewards of enforcement

• Time considerations impact the decision to enforce a patent
  • Length of litigation process can be extensive
    1. Discovery phase involves exchanging information and evidence
    2. Trial phase presents arguments and evidence before a judge or jury
    3. Appeal process allows parties to challenge the trial outcome
  • Time-to-market for the patented product may be limited, making swift enforcement crucial
  • Remaining patent term affects the value of enforcement (20 years from filing date)
• Cost considerations include significant expenses
  • Legal fees for attorneys and experts specializing in patent law and technical fields
  • Court costs and filing fees add to the financial burden
  • Opportunity costs of focusing on litigation instead of business operations
• Potential rewards of successful enforcement
  • Monetary damages compensate for losses
    • Reasonable royalties based on hypothetical licensing negotiations
    • Lost profits demonstrate the patent owner's financial harm
  • Injunctions to stop infringing activities prevent further losses
  • Licensing revenue generates income from the patented invention
  • Increased market share and competitive advantage result from eliminating infringers
  • Deterrence of future infringement sends a strong message to potential infringers

Strategic planning for enforcement

• Identify objectives aligned with business goals
  • Protecting market share maintains the patent owner's position
  • Generating licensing revenue provides a return on R&D investments
  • Preventing competition preserves the patent owner's exclusivity
  • Establishing a reputation for enforcing IP rights deters potential infringers
• Assess resources available for enforcement efforts
  • Financial resources for legal costs determine the scope of enforcement
  • Human resources for managing enforcement efforts ensure proper oversight
  • Strength and breadth of the patent portfolio affect the value and defensibility of the patents
• Prioritize enforcement targets based on impact and likelihood of success
  • Focus on key competitors or markets that pose the greatest threat
  • Target high-value infringers whose products or services closely match the patented invention
• Choose appropriate enforcement methods based on objectives and resources
  • Consider likelihood of success and potential rewards when selecting enforcement options
  • Balance aggressive litigation with more cooperative licensing efforts to manage costs and relationships
• Develop a timeline and budget for enforcement activities
  • Allocate resources over the expected duration of enforcement efforts
  • Monitor and adjust the plan based on results and changing circumstances
• Consider public relations and reputational impact of enforcement actions
  • Communicate enforcement actions to stakeholders to maintain transparency
  • Manage potential backlash from aggressive enforcement tactics that may be perceived as anti-competitive or stifling innovation

Patent Management and Strategy

• Patent portfolio management involves strategically developing and maintaining a collection of patents to support business objectives
• Patent valuation assesses the economic worth of patents to inform decision-making on enforcement, licensing, or sales
• Patent strategy aligns IP protection with overall business goals, considering factors such as market position and competitive landscape
• Patent due diligence involves thorough investigation of patent assets in transactions or enforcement actions
• Patent prosecution refers to the process of obtaining patent protection, including drafting and negotiating with patent offices