11.1 Historical Perspectives on Government

Ancient philosophers pondered the ideal government and citizen roles. Aristotle emphasized virtue in politics, arguing the state should promote citizens' happiness through moral development. He believed the virtuous should rule, with citizens actively participating.

Greek, Chinese, and Islamic traditions offer diverse governance ideals. Plato favored philosopher-kings, Confucianism stressed virtuous rulers, and Islamic thought emphasized upholding Quranic principles. Education played a crucial role in shaping just societies across these perspectives.

Ancient Perspectives on Government and Citizenship

Aristotle's virtue in political systems

Top images from around the web for Aristotle's virtue in political systems

• 

  Ancient Greek philosophy - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotelian Virtue Ethics – Ethics and Society View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek philosophy - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Aristotle's virtue in political systems

• 

  Ancient Greek philosophy - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotelian Virtue Ethics – Ethics and Society View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek philosophy - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Aristotle believed the state's purpose is promoting citizens' good life and happiness
  • Achieved through cultivating virtue
• Virtues are character traits enabling individuals to fulfill their proper function
  • Intellectual virtues encompass wisdom, understanding, good judgment
  • Moral virtues include courage, temperance, justice
• Aristotle argued the ideal political system should be based on rule of the virtuous
  • Those with practical wisdom and moral virtue should govern
• Citizenship in Aristotle's view is a moral responsibility, not merely a legal status
  • Citizens should actively participate in the political process
  • Strive to develop virtues and contribute to the common good
• Different political systems promote different virtues and conceptions of citizenship
  • Aristocracy involves rule by the virtuous few possessing wisdom and moral excellence
  • Polity entails rule by a large middle class of virtuous citizens
  • Democracy means rule by the many, potentially leading to pursuing individual over common interests

Greek, Chinese, and Islamic governance ideals

• Ancient Greek perspective:
  • Plato's ideal state is ruled by wise and virtuous philosopher-kings
  • Aristotle favors a mixed constitution combining aristocracy, polity, democracy
• Ancient Chinese perspective:
  • Confucianism emphasizes virtuous rulers and harmonious social order
    • The ideal "sage-king" governs with benevolence, righteousness, wisdom (Mencius)
  • Legalism advocates strict laws, punishments, rewards for order and stability (Han Feizi)
• Islamic perspective:
  • The ideal Islamic state upholds Quranic principles and Prophet Muhammad's example
    • The ruler should be a pious Muslim upholding Sharia law and consulting the community
  • "Shura" (consultation) is important in Islamic political thought
    • The ruler should seek advice from the knowledgeable and consider community interests

Education's role in just societies

• Education and moral development are essential for creating and maintaining just societies
• Plato's theory of education in the ideal state:
  • Emphasizes moral and intellectual training for the ruling class
  • Aims to cultivate wisdom, courage, temperance, justice in guardians (Republic)
• Confucian view on education and moral cultivation:
  • Education should focus on moral/ethical development, not just knowledge acquisition
  • The goal is cultivating virtuous individuals contributing to a harmonious society (Analects)
• Islamic perspective on education and moral development:
  • Education should be based on Islamic principles and values
  • Aims to create knowledgeable, righteous moral exemplars (hadith)
• Aristotle's view on moral education:
  • Moral virtues are developed through habit and practice
  • The state should provide an environment conducive to moral development with proper laws and institutions (Nicomachean Ethics)

Foundations of Modern Political Thought

• Social contract theory: explains the origin and purpose of government as an agreement among individuals
• Natural rights: the idea that individuals possess inherent rights that should be protected by the government
• Rule of law: the principle that all individuals and institutions are subject to and accountable to law
• Separation of powers: division of governmental authority to prevent abuse and protect individual liberties
• Sovereignty: the supreme power or authority within a state
• Civil society: the realm of social activity outside of government control
• Legitimacy: the acceptance of a government's authority by the people it governs