5.2 Maximum parsimony

Maximum parsimony is a key principle in computational molecular biology for inferring evolutionary relationships. It applies simplicity to reconstruct phylogenetic trees, minimizing the number of evolutionary changes needed to explain observed differences among species or sequences.

This method builds on Occam's razor, favoring simpler explanations. In phylogenetics, it assumes the evolutionary path with the fewest changes is most probable. Various algorithms and approaches are used to find the most parsimonious tree topology, balancing data explanation and evolutionary scenario simplicity.

Concept of maximum parsimony

• Maximum parsimony serves as a fundamental principle in computational molecular biology for inferring evolutionary relationships
• Applies the concept of simplicity to reconstruct phylogenetic trees based on observed genetic or morphological data
• Minimizes the number of evolutionary changes required to explain the observed differences among species or sequences

Principle of Occam's razor

Top images from around the web for Principle of Occam's razor

• 

  Tree of life (biology) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Determining Evolutionary Relationships | OpenStax Biology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction to Phylogenetic Trees | Biology for Non-Majors I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tree of life (biology) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Determining Evolutionary Relationships | OpenStax Biology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Principle of Occam's razor

• 

  Tree of life (biology) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Determining Evolutionary Relationships | OpenStax Biology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction to Phylogenetic Trees | Biology for Non-Majors I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tree of life (biology) - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Determining Evolutionary Relationships | OpenStax Biology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• States that the simplest explanation is often the most likely to be correct
• Applied to phylogenetics by favoring trees with fewer evolutionary changes
• Helps reduce complexity in biological models and hypotheses

Parsimony in phylogenetics

• Assumes the evolutionary path with the fewest changes is the most probable
• Evaluates different tree topologies to find the one requiring the least number of character state changes
• Utilizes character-based methods to analyze discrete traits or nucleotide sequences

Evolutionary change minimization

• Seeks to minimize the total number of evolutionary events across all characters
• Considers various types of changes (substitutions, insertions, deletions) in molecular sequences
• Balances between explaining observed data and avoiding unnecessary complexity in evolutionary scenarios

Parsimony-based tree construction

• Involves building phylogenetic trees that minimize the total number of evolutionary changes
• Utilizes various algorithms to search for the most parsimonious tree topology
• Plays a crucial role in understanding evolutionary relationships among species or genes

Character-based methods

• Analyze discrete characters (morphological traits or nucleotide positions) individually
• Assign character states to internal nodes of the tree to minimize changes
• Include popular approaches like Fitch's algorithm and Sankoff's algorithm

Step-counting methods

• Calculate the minimum number of steps (changes) required for each possible tree topology
• Compare different trees based on their total parsimony score
• Often used in exhaustive searches for small datasets or as part of heuristic approaches

Branch-and-bound algorithm

• Employs a systematic search strategy to find the most parsimonious tree
• Prunes branches of the search tree that cannot lead to optimal solutions
• Guarantees finding the best tree while potentially reducing computational time

Fitch's algorithm

• Represents a fundamental method for calculating parsimony scores in phylogenetics
• Efficiently computes the minimum number of changes required for a given tree topology
• Forms the basis for many advanced parsimony-based tree reconstruction methods

Algorithm steps

• Perform a bottom-up pass to assign possible character states to internal nodes
• Conduct a top-down pass to determine the final ancestral states
• Calculate the parsimony score by counting the number of changes along the branches

Ancestral state reconstruction

• Infers the most likely character states at internal nodes of the phylogenetic tree
• Uses set operations to determine possible states during the bottom-up pass
• Resolves ambiguities during the top-down pass based on ancestral node states

Parsimony score calculation

• Sums up the number of character state changes across all branches of the tree
• Considers each character independently and aggregates their individual scores
• Provides a measure of the tree's overall parsimony, with lower scores indicating better trees

Sankoff's algorithm

• Extends Fitch's algorithm to handle more complex evolutionary models
• Allows for different costs associated with various types of character state changes
• Provides a flexible framework for incorporating biological knowledge into parsimony analysis

Generalized parsimony

• Accommodates different evolutionary rates or probabilities for various character state transitions
• Enables more realistic modeling of biological processes (transitions vs transversions in DNA)
• Improves the accuracy of phylogenetic reconstruction in cases with known evolutionary biases

Cost matrix implementation

• Utilizes a matrix to specify the cost of changing from one character state to another
• Allows for asymmetric costs, reflecting biological realities (easier to gain a trait than to lose it)
• Integrates seamlessly with dynamic programming approaches for efficient computation

Dynamic programming approach

• Breaks down the problem into smaller subproblems and stores intermediate results
• Efficiently computes optimal solutions by avoiding redundant calculations
• Enables the algorithm to handle large datasets and complex cost matrices

Parsimony informative sites

• Represent specific positions in molecular sequences that contribute to distinguishing between different tree topologies
• Play a crucial role in determining the most parsimonious phylogenetic tree
• Influence the resolution and reliability of the reconstructed evolutionary relationships

Definition and identification

• Require at least two different character states, each present in at least two taxa
• Exclude invariant sites and singleton mutations from consideration
• Can be easily identified by examining the distribution of character states across taxa

Impact on tree topology

• Directly influence the branching patterns and relationships inferred in the phylogenetic tree
• Provide the primary source of information for resolving evolutionary relationships
• Increase in number generally leads to more robust and well-supported tree topologies

Vs uninformative sites

• Contrast with sites that do not contribute to distinguishing between tree topologies
• Include invariant sites (same state in all taxa) and autapomorphies (unique to one taxon)
• May still be important for other analyses but do not affect the parsimony-based tree reconstruction

Limitations of maximum parsimony

• Represent important considerations when applying parsimony methods in molecular biology
• Can lead to incorrect tree topologies or biased results in certain scenarios
• Necessitate the use of complementary approaches or more complex evolutionary models

Long branch attraction

• Occurs when rapidly evolving lineages are incorrectly grouped together
• Results from convergent evolution or parallel changes along long branches
• Can be mitigated by including additional taxa or using model-based methods

Homoplasy issues

• Arise from independent evolution of similar traits in different lineages
• Include convergent evolution, parallel evolution, and character reversals
• Can lead to underestimation of evolutionary changes and incorrect tree topologies

Vs maximum likelihood methods

• Parsimony does not explicitly incorporate probabilistic models of evolution
• Maximum likelihood can account for different rates of evolution among sites
• Likelihood methods often perform better with large datasets or complex evolutionary scenarios

Computational complexity

• Represents a significant challenge in applying parsimony methods to large datasets
• Influences the choice of algorithms and search strategies in phylogenetic analysis
• Drives the development of heuristic approaches and efficient software implementations

NP-hard problem classification

• Finding the most parsimonious tree is computationally intractable for large numbers of taxa
• Belongs to a class of problems for which no polynomial-time algorithm is known
• Necessitates the use of approximation algorithms or heuristic searches for large datasets

Heuristic approaches

• Employ intelligent search strategies to find near-optimal solutions
• Include methods like nearest-neighbor interchange (NNI) and subtree pruning and regrafting (SPR)
• Trade off guaranteed optimality for computational feasibility in large-scale analyses

Exhaustive search limitations

• Become impractical for datasets with more than about 10-12 taxa
• Grow exponentially with the number of taxa, leading to astronomical search spaces
• Motivate the development of more efficient algorithms and parallel computing approaches

Software tools for parsimony analysis

• Provide researchers with powerful platforms for conducting phylogenetic analyses
• Implement various algorithms and heuristics for efficient tree searching
• Often include additional features for data manipulation, visualization, and statistical testing

PAUP* features

• Offers a comprehensive suite of phylogenetic methods, including parsimony
• Provides flexible options for character weighting and tree search strategies
• Includes tools for consensus tree building and bootstrap analysis

TNT implementation

• Specializes in fast and efficient parsimony analysis of large datasets
• Implements advanced search algorithms and memory-saving techniques
• Allows for scripting and automation of complex phylogenetic analyses

R packages for parsimony

• Integrate parsimony methods into the R statistical computing environment
• Include packages like 'phangorn' for phylogenetic reconstruction and analysis
• Enable seamless integration with other bioinformatics and statistical tools in R

Applications in molecular biology

• Demonstrate the practical utility of parsimony methods in various research areas
• Contribute to our understanding of evolutionary processes and relationships
• Often complement other analytical approaches in computational molecular biology

Sequence alignment refinement

• Uses parsimony to improve multiple sequence alignments
• Optimizes gap placement to minimize the number of inferred insertions and deletions
• Enhances the accuracy of subsequent phylogenetic analyses and comparative studies

Gene family evolution

• Applies parsimony to reconstruct the history of gene duplication and loss events
• Helps identify orthologous and paralogous relationships among genes
• Provides insights into the functional diversification of gene families over time

Horizontal gene transfer detection

• Utilizes parsimony to identify incongruences between gene trees and species trees
• Helps distinguish vertical inheritance from horizontal transfer events
• Contributes to our understanding of microbial evolution and genome dynamics