9.3 Abortion Methods and Legal Considerations

Abortion methods and legal considerations are crucial aspects of reproductive healthcare. Medical abortions use medications, while surgical procedures physically remove pregnancy tissue. The choice depends on factors like gestational age and individual circumstances.

Legal frameworks for abortion have evolved significantly. From Roe v. Wade to the recent Dobbs decision, regulations now vary widely by state. Key issues include gestational limits, consent requirements, and provider regulations, all impacting access to abortion services.

Abortion Procedures

Medical and Surgical Abortion Methods

Top images from around the web for Medical and Surgical Abortion Methods

• 

  Comparison of sublingual versus vaginal misoprostol in the management of missed abortions ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Post-abortion care with misoprostol – equally effective, safe and accepted when administered by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Vacuum aspiration for induced abortion could be safely and legally performed by nurses and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparison of sublingual versus vaginal misoprostol in the management of missed abortions ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Post-abortion care with misoprostol – equally effective, safe and accepted when administered by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Medical and Surgical Abortion Methods

• 

  Comparison of sublingual versus vaginal misoprostol in the management of missed abortions ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Post-abortion care with misoprostol – equally effective, safe and accepted when administered by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Vacuum aspiration for induced abortion could be safely and legally performed by nurses and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Comparison of sublingual versus vaginal misoprostol in the management of missed abortions ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Post-abortion care with misoprostol – equally effective, safe and accepted when administered by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Medical abortion uses medications to terminate pregnancy without surgery
  • Typically involves two drugs: mifepristone and misoprostol
  • Mifepristone blocks progesterone, causing the uterine lining to break down
  • Misoprostol induces uterine contractions to expel the pregnancy
• Medical abortion effective up to 10 weeks gestation
  • Success rate of 95-98% when used as directed
  • Can be done at home after initial doctor visit
• Surgical abortion removes the pregnancy through a medical procedure
  • Vacuum aspiration most common method in first trimester
    • Gentle suction removes pregnancy tissue from uterus
  • Dilation and evacuation (D&E) used in second trimester
    • Cervix dilated and pregnancy removed with medical instruments

Trimester-Specific Procedures

• First trimester procedures (up to 13 weeks)
  • Manual vacuum aspiration for very early pregnancies
    • Hand-held syringe creates suction to remove tissue
  • Electric vacuum aspiration more common after 6 weeks
    • Electric pump provides suction through a thin tube
  • Both take 5-10 minutes and can be done with local anesthesia
• Second trimester procedures (13-24 weeks)
  • Dilation and evacuation (D&E) standard method
    • Cervix dilated over 1-2 days prior to procedure
    • Combination of suction and surgical instruments remove pregnancy
  • Induction abortion less common alternative
    • Medications induce labor to deliver fetus
    • Takes place in hospital over 1-2 days

Legal Considerations

Landmark Court Decisions

• Roe v. Wade established constitutional right to abortion in 1973
  • Struck down state laws banning abortion
  • Ruled right to privacy under 14th Amendment includes abortion
  • Set up trimester framework for regulating abortion
• Planned Parenthood v. Casey upheld core of Roe in 1992
  • Replaced trimester framework with undue burden test
  • Allowed more state regulations in first trimester
  • Reaffirmed right to abortion before viability
• Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization overturned Roe in 2022
  • Eliminated federal constitutional right to abortion
  • Returned abortion regulation to individual states

Key Legal Concepts

• Viability refers to potential for fetus to survive outside the womb
  • Generally considered to be around 24 weeks gestation
  • Exact point can vary based on medical technology and individual cases
  • Pre-viability abortions had stronger legal protections under Roe
• Gestational limits restrict abortions after specified point in pregnancy
  • Vary widely by state, from 6 weeks to no limit
  • Most common limit 20-24 weeks, based on viability
  • Some states allow later abortions for health reasons or fatal fetal conditions

Abortion Regulations

Consent and Waiting Period Requirements

• Parental consent laws apply to minors seeking abortions
  • 37 states require parental involvement in a minor's abortion decision
  • Usually mandate either parental consent or notification
  • Judicial bypass allows minors to get court approval instead
  • Aim to involve parents in medical decisions for minors
• Waiting periods mandate time between counseling and procedure
  • 25 states require waiting periods, typically 24-72 hours
  • Intended to allow time for consideration of decision
  • Critics argue they create logistical barriers, especially for low-income women
• Informed consent laws require specific information be provided
  • May include details on fetal development, risks, and alternatives
  • Some states mandate ultrasounds be offered or performed
  • Controversial when information seen as biased or medically unnecessary

Provider and Facility Regulations

• Provider qualification requirements vary by state
  • Some states restrict provision to licensed physicians only
  • Others allow advanced practice clinicians (nurse practitioners, physician assistants) to provide
• Facility regulations set standards for abortion clinics
  • May include requirements for hallway width, room size, proximity to hospital
  • Critics argue some regulations are medically unnecessary and designed to close clinics
• Telemedicine restrictions in some states
  • Prohibit prescribing abortion medication via telehealth
  • Limit access in rural areas or during public health emergencies (COVID-19 pandemic)
• Insurance coverage and public funding restrictions
  • Hyde Amendment prohibits federal Medicaid funding for most abortions
  • Some states restrict private insurance coverage of abortion
  • Creates financial barriers for low-income individuals seeking abortions