4.4 Shield laws and source protection

Shield laws protect journalists from revealing confidential sources, ensuring a free flow of information and press integrity. These laws vary across jurisdictions, with some offering strong protections and others providing limited safeguards. Ethical considerations and the digital age present new challenges.

Journalists have a strong ethical duty to protect source confidentiality, but this can be outweighed in extreme circumstances. The rise of digital communication and surveillance has created new hurdles for shield laws, requiring journalists to adapt their practices to safeguard sources in the modern era.

Shield Laws and Source Protection

Purpose of shield laws

Top images from around the web for Purpose of shield laws

• 

  Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students | Just another Craig Newmark Graduate ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : Protecting Journalism Sources in the Digital Age - A new publication from UNESCO View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Who gets a press pass? Media credentialing practices in the United States - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students | Just another Craig Newmark Graduate ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : Protecting Journalism Sources in the Digital Age - A new publication from UNESCO View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Purpose of shield laws

• 

  Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students | Just another Craig Newmark Graduate ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : Protecting Journalism Sources in the Digital Age - A new publication from UNESCO View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Who gets a press pass? Media credentialing practices in the United States - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Education Resources for Graduate Journalism Students | Just another Craig Newmark Graduate ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : Protecting Journalism Sources in the Digital Age - A new publication from UNESCO View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Provide legal protections for journalists to maintain confidentiality of sources
  • Safeguard journalists from being compelled to reveal sources in court or to law enforcement (subpoenas, testimony)
• Ensure free flow of information and maintain integrity of the press
  • Encourage whistleblowers and others to come forward with important information without fear of retaliation (job loss, legal consequences)
  • Allow journalists to investigate and report on matters of public interest, holding those in power accountable (government corruption, corporate wrongdoing)

Shield law variations across jurisdictions

• Protections vary significantly across different jurisdictions, both within the United States and internationally
  • Some states have strong shield laws that provide broad protections for journalists (California, New York)
  • Other states have weaker or no shield laws, leaving journalists more vulnerable to legal challenges (Wyoming, Hawaii)
• Federal shield law protections in the United States are limited
  • No federal statute protecting journalists' sources, although some courts have recognized a qualified privilege based on the First Amendment (Branzburg v. Hayes)
• International jurisdictions have different approaches to shield laws
  • Some countries have strong legal protections for journalists and their sources (Sweden, Austria)
  • Others have more limited protections and have seen high-profile cases of journalists being compelled to reveal sources (United Kingdom, Australia)

Ethics of source confidentiality

• Journalists have strong ethical obligation to protect confidentiality of sources when promised
  • Based on principle that journalists should keep their word and maintain trust with sources
  • Revealing a source's identity can put them at risk of retaliation, damaging their livelihood or even putting them in physical danger (whistleblowers, government leakers)
• Circumstances where ethical obligation to protect sources may be outweighed by other considerations
  • If a source provides false or misleading information, journalists may need to consider revealing their identity to set the record straight
  • In extreme cases, such as when a source reveals information about an imminent threat to public safety, journalists may have an ethical duty to come forward (terrorist plot, natural disaster warning)

Shield laws in digital age

• Rise of digital communication and surveillance has created new challenges for shield laws and source protection
  • Electronic communication can leave a trail that makes it easier to identify sources, even if journalists take precautions (metadata, IP addresses)
  • Government surveillance programs and hacking can undermine confidentiality of journalist-source communications (NSA wiretapping, Pegasus spyware)
• Shield laws may not always keep pace with technological changes, leaving gaps in protection
  • Laws designed for traditional media may not adequately address issues raised by online journalism and digital communication (bloggers, citizen journalists)
• Journalists and news organizations need to adapt practices to protect sources in digital age
  • Use encrypted communication tools, secure drop boxes, and other technological measures to maintain confidentiality (Signal, SecureDrop)
  • However, even with these precautions, absolute source protection may not always be possible in the face of determined efforts to uncover a source's identity (government pressure, court orders)