11.3 Greek Historiography: Herodotus and Thucydides

Greek historiography emerged as a distinct genre in the 5th century BCE. Herodotus and Thucydides, considered the "fathers of history," established the foundations of historical inquiry, moving beyond mere chronicling to critical analysis and interpretation.

Their works aimed to preserve significant events, explain historical developments, and offer lessons. This coincided with the rise of rational thought and growing interest in understanding human experience, setting the stage for future Western historical writing.

Historiography in Ancient Greece

Emergence and Significance of Historiography

Top images from around the web for Emergence and Significance of Historiography

• 

  Thucydides - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tucídides, el historiador total View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Herodotus’ Histories — ancient-greek.net View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thucydides - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tucídides, el historiador total View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Emergence and Significance of Historiography

• 

  Thucydides - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tucídides, el historiador total View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Herodotus’ Histories — ancient-greek.net View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thucydides - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tucídides, el historiador total View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Historiography emerged as a distinct genre of literature in ancient Greece during the 5th century BCE
• Early Greek historians, known as logographers, compiled oral traditions, myths, and genealogies of notable families and cities laying the groundwork for later historical writing
• Herodotus and Thucydides, considered the "fathers of history," established the foundations of historical inquiry moving beyond mere chronicling of events to critical analysis and interpretation
• Greek historiography aimed to preserve the memory of significant events, provide explanations for the causes and consequences of historical developments, and offer lessons for the present and future (Peloponnesian War, Persian Wars)
• The development of historiography in ancient Greece coincided with the rise of rational thought, intellectual curiosity, and a growing interest in understanding the human experience and the natural world

Impact on Western Historiography

• Greek historiography set the stage for future historical writing in the Western world influencing the works of later historians (Polybius, Livy, Tacitus)
• The critical analysis, interpretation, and search for causality in historical events became central features of Western historiography
• The emphasis on eyewitness accounts, official documents, and rational reasoning in Thucydides' work laid the foundation for modern historical methodology
• The inclusion of speeches, dialogues, and character assessments in Greek historical writing influenced the development of literary techniques in historiography
• The works of Herodotus and Thucydides served as models for the writing of national histories, military campaigns, and political conflicts in subsequent centuries

Herodotus and Thucydides: Methods and Themes

Herodotus' Approach and Themes

• Herodotus employed a wide-ranging, anecdotal style in his work "The Histories" incorporating folklore, legends, and personal accounts alongside historical events
• He focused on the theme of the conflict between the Greek city-states and the Persian Empire exploring the reasons behind the Persian Wars and the triumph of the Greeks (Battle of Marathon, Battle of Thermopylae)
• Herodotus emphasized the role of fate, divine intervention, and the cyclical nature of human affairs in shaping historical events attributing outcomes to the will of the gods and the hubris of men
• His work is characterized by a strong sense of cultural relativism, presenting the customs and beliefs of different peoples without judgment and highlighting the diversity of human experiences (Egyptians, Scythians, Persians)
• Herodotus' digressions and anecdotes, while sometimes criticized for their lack of relevance, provide valuable insights into the social, cultural, and intellectual context of the ancient world

Thucydides' Approach and Themes

• Thucydides adopted a more analytical and impartial approach in his "History of the Peloponnesian War" relying on eyewitness accounts, official documents, and critical reasoning
• He concentrated on the political, military, and social aspects of the war between Athens and Sparta providing detailed descriptions of battles, speeches, and diplomatic negotiations (Siege of Plataea, Melian Dialogue)
• Thucydides sought to identify the underlying causes of the war, such as the growth of Athenian power and the fear it instilled in Sparta, and to draw general principles about human nature and behavior from specific events
• His work is marked by a focus on political realism, emphasizing the role of power, self-interest, and the balance of forces in shaping historical events
• Thucydides' inclusion of speeches, while not verbatim records, serves to illuminate the motives, arguments, and perspectives of key historical figures (Pericles' Funeral Oration)

Reliability and Bias in Ancient Greek History

Limitations and Criticisms of Herodotus

• Herodotus has been criticized for his inclusion of mythical elements, exaggerations, and unverified stories in his work leading some to question the reliability of his accounts (giant ants, gold-digging griffins)
• His reliance on oral traditions and secondhand accounts could be subject to distortion, selective memory, and personal agendas
• Herodotus' occasional lack of critical analysis and his acceptance of supernatural explanations for historical events have been seen as weaknesses in his approach
• The lack of standardized dating systems and the scarcity of written records in ancient times posed challenges to the accuracy and completeness of his historical accounts
• Despite these limitations, Herodotus' extensive travels and interviews with eyewitnesses provide valuable insights into the cultures, customs, and beliefs of various peoples in the ancient world

Limitations and Criticisms of Thucydides

• Thucydides, despite his more rigorous approach, was not entirely free from bias as he was an Athenian exile and a participant in the Peloponnesian War
• His focus on Athens and its perspective may have led to a less comprehensive portrayal of the conflict and the motivations of other city-states (Sparta, Thebes)
• Thucydides' reliance on eyewitness accounts and personal observations could be subject to the limitations of individual memory and perception
• The absence of written records from opposing sides and the destruction of evidence during the war may have affected the completeness and balance of his account
• Thucydides' emphasis on political and military affairs sometimes led to the neglect of social, economic, and cultural factors that shaped the course of events
• Despite these limitations, Thucydides' critical analysis, impartiality, and attention to cause and effect have earned him a reputation as a pioneering figure in historical methodology

Herodotus vs Thucydides: Approaches to History

Scope and Focus

• Herodotus adopted a more expansive and inclusive approach covering a wide range of topics and geographical areas (Persian Wars, Egypt, Scythia)
• Thucydides focused narrowly on a single conflict, the Peloponnesian War, and its immediate context in the Greek world
• Herodotus' work is more anthropological in nature providing valuable insights into the customs, beliefs, and daily lives of various peoples
• Thucydides' account is more concerned with military, political, and diplomatic affairs offering a detailed analysis of the strategies, alliances, and power dynamics of the warring city-states

Sources and Evidence

• Herodotus relied heavily on oral traditions, folklore, and anecdotal evidence gathering information from a wide range of sources during his travels
• Thucydides prioritized eyewitness accounts, official documents, and rational analysis seeking to verify information and separate fact from rumor
• Herodotus' use of mythical elements and supernatural explanations reflects the intellectual climate of his time and the limitations of available evidence
• Thucydides' emphasis on critical reasoning and empirical evidence marks a significant shift towards a more modern approach to historical inquiry

Interpretation and Explanation

• Herodotus often attributed historical events to divine intervention and the workings of fate seeing history as a cycle of rise and fall determined by the will of the gods
• Thucydides sought to identify human motivations and natural causes behind historical developments emphasizing the role of power, self-interest, and political calculations
• Herodotus' writing style is more engaging and entertaining featuring colorful digressions and vivid descriptions that bring the past to life
• Thucydides' prose is more concise, analytical, and politically focused aiming to provide a clear and objective account of events and their causes

Legacy and Influence

• Herodotus' work inspired later historians to explore the diversity of human cultures and to view history as a source of moral and political lessons
• Thucydides' approach set the standard for critical analysis, impartiality, and the use of primary sources in historical writing
• The contrast between Herodotus' expansive, narrative style and Thucydides' focused, analytical approach reflects the ongoing tension between storytelling and scientific inquiry in historiography
• Despite their differences, both Herodotus and Thucydides shared a common goal of preserving the memory of significant events and offering explanations for the causes and consequences of historical developments