11.3 Ethical Considerations in Persuasion

Persuasion can be a powerful tool, but it comes with ethical responsibilities. This section explores the fine line between ethical persuasion and manipulation, highlighting the importance of respecting audience autonomy and providing truthful information.

Ethical persuaders must consider their impact on individuals and society. We'll examine key principles like truthfulness, fairness, and social responsibility, as well as specific guidelines for different contexts like advertising, politics, and education.

Ethical Implications of Persuasion

Persuasion and Ethics

Top images from around the web for Persuasion and Ethics

• 

  Logos, Ethos, Pathos | Introduction to College Composition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Communicating Ethically | Communication for Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Become a Rhetorically Effective Speaker – Starr Sumner – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Logos, Ethos, Pathos | Introduction to College Composition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Communicating Ethically | Communication for Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Persuasion and Ethics

• 

  Logos, Ethos, Pathos | Introduction to College Composition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Communicating Ethically | Communication for Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Become a Rhetorically Effective Speaker – Starr Sumner – Medium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Logos, Ethos, Pathos | Introduction to College Composition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Communicating Ethically | Communication for Professionals View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Persuasion involves using communication to influence attitudes, beliefs, values, or behaviors of others
• Ethics of persuasion are concerned with moral principles and values guiding persuasive communication
• Ethical persuasion respects audience autonomy and free choice (allows individuals to make their own decisions)
• Unethical persuasion may manipulate or deceive audience into accepting a view or taking an action (misleading advertising)

Ethical Considerations in Persuasive Techniques

• Using emotional appeals (fear or guilt) can be ethically questionable if used to manipulate feelings rather than provide relevant information for decision-making
  • Example: Using fear of terrorism to promote support for a political candidate without providing factual evidence of their policies
• Persuasive techniques relying on logical fallacies (ad hominem attacks or false dichotomies) are ethically problematic by misleading the audience and undermining rational discourse
  • Example: Attacking an opponent's character instead of addressing their arguments in a debate
• Ethical persuasion requires transparency about persuader's intentions, sources of information, and potential biases or conflicts of interest
  • Example: Disclosing financial sponsorship of a study promoting a particular product
• Ethical persuasion should be based on truthful, accurate, and relevant information, rather than deception or omission of important facts
  • Example: Providing complete data on a medication's side effects, not just its benefits

Manipulation vs. Persuasion

Defining Manipulation and Deception

• Manipulation uses persuasive techniques to control or influence others to serve persuader's interests rather than audience's well-being
  • Example: A salesperson pressuring a customer to make an immediate purchase decision without allowing time for consideration
• Deception uses false, misleading, or incomplete information to influence audience's beliefs or actions
  • Example: A political ad that takes an opponent's quote out of context to misrepresent their position

Tactics of Manipulative and Deceptive Persuasion

• Manipulative messages exploit audience vulnerabilities (fears, insecurities, lack of knowledge) to promote persuader's agenda
  • Example: An ad that preys on elderly people's fear of being burdensome to their families to sell an expensive life insurance policy
• Deceptive persuasion may use false or misleading claims (exaggerating benefits while minimizing risks or limitations)
  • Example: A weight loss supplement that promises dramatic results without disclosing potential health risks
• Manipulative and deceptive persuasion often relies on emotional appeals that distract from logical merits of argument or credibility of information
  • Example: A charity solicitation that uses heart-wrenching images of suffering children without providing evidence of how donations are used
• Subliminal messages designed to influence audience's subconscious mind without their awareness are a form of manipulative persuasion raising ethical concerns
  • Example: Brief flashes of a product image inserted into a movie scene to subconsciously encourage purchase
• Persuasive messages targeting vulnerable populations (children, elderly) may be prone to manipulation and deception due to lack of critical thinking skills or experience to evaluate claims
  • Example: Advertising junk food directly to young children who may not understand its nutritional value

Responsibilities of Persuaders

General Responsibilities

• Persuaders have responsibility to use communication skills and resources honestly, transparently, and respectfully of audience's autonomy and well-being
• Persuaders in positions of authority or influence (leaders, experts) have heightened responsibility to use power ethically and avoid abusing credibility or trust
  • Example: A doctor recommending a treatment based on scientific evidence rather than personal financial gain

Context-Specific Responsibilities

• In advertising and marketing, persuaders must provide truthful and accurate product or service information and avoid false or misleading claims
  • Example: Clearly disclosing all fees and interest rates associated with a credit card offer
• In political campaigns, persuaders should engage in fair, substantive debates on issues and policies, rather than personal attacks or emotional appeals
  • Example: Focusing campaign messages on a candidate's policy proposals and qualifications instead of attacking an opponent's personal life
• In public health campaigns, persuaders should provide evidence-based information and recommendations prioritizing population health and safety
  • Example: Basing anti-smoking messages on peer-reviewed research about tobacco's health risks
• In educational settings, persuaders should present multiple perspectives on controversial issues and encourage critical thinking and independent judgment among students
  • Example: A teacher facilitating a classroom debate where students argue different viewpoints based on factual evidence

Ethical Guidelines for Persuasion

Key Ethical Principles

• Truthfulness requires providing accurate, honest, complete information and avoiding deception or misleading claims
  • Example: A journalist verifying facts from multiple sources before publishing a news story
• Respect for autonomy requires acknowledging audience's right to make decisions based on their own values and preferences and avoiding coercive or manipulative tactics
  • Example: A doctor explaining all treatment options and allowing a patient to make an informed choice
• Fairness requires treating all audience members equally and avoiding discrimination or bias based on race, gender, age, socioeconomic status, etc.
  • Example: A company considering job applicants based solely on their qualifications and not their demographic characteristics
• Social responsibility requires considering broader social and ethical implications of messages and avoiding promotion of harmful attitudes or behaviors
  • Example: An advertiser refusing to promote tobacco products to avoid contributing to public health risks

Professional Standards and Ongoing Dialogue

• Professional codes of ethics (Public Relations Society of America, American Advertising Federation) provide specific guidelines for ethical conduct in persuasive communication within industries or fields
  • Example: PRSA Code of Ethics requiring members to "protect and advance the free flow of accurate and truthful information" and "avoid deceptive practices"
• Ethical persuasion requires ongoing reflection and dialogue among persuaders, audiences, and stakeholders to align practices with evolving moral standards and social values
  • Example: A company seeking input from consumer advocates and ethical experts when developing a new advertising campaign