10.2 Metafiction and intertextuality: Barth, Calvino, and Auster

Postmodernism shook up literature with mind-bending tricks. Writers like Barth, Calvino, and Auster used metafiction and intertextuality to mess with reality and fiction. They made readers question everything they thought they knew about stories.

These authors played with narrative structure, blurred genres, and referenced other texts. Their goal? To challenge ideas about authorship, originality, and what's real. They wanted readers to think harder about how stories work and what they mean.

Metafiction and Intertextuality

Defining Metafiction and Intertextuality

Top images from around the web for Defining Metafiction and Intertextuality

• 

  Chapter 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Analyze Visual Media | Writing 102 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Teaching Literary Analysis | www.edutopia.org/blog/reaching-… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Analyze Visual Media | Writing 102 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Metafiction and Intertextuality

• 

  Chapter 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Analyze Visual Media | Writing 102 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Teaching Literary Analysis | www.edutopia.org/blog/reaching-… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Analyze Visual Media | Writing 102 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Metafiction is a type of fiction that self-consciously draws attention to its own fictional nature
  • Often comments on the process of writing or the conventions of narrative
  • Examples: A novel in which the narrator directly addresses the reader about the challenges of crafting the story, or a character who is aware of their fictional status
• Intertextuality refers to the way in which texts interact with and refer to other texts
  • Creates a network of literary allusions and references
  • Texts build upon, respond to, or subvert elements from other works
  • Examples: A novel that reimagines a classic fairy tale, or a poem that alludes to a famous line from Shakespeare

Role in Postmodern Literature

• In postmodern literature, metafiction and intertextuality are used to challenge traditional notions
  • Questions ideas of authorship, originality, and the boundaries between reality and fiction
  • Highlights the constructed nature of literary traditions and meanings
• Metafictional techniques are employed to question the nature of reality and the role of literature in representing it
  • Self-reflexive narration blurs the lines between the story and the act of storytelling
  • Blurring of fact and fiction destabilizes the reader's understanding of what is real
• Intertextuality in postmodern works often involves playful appropriation and subversion of canonical texts
  • Reinterprets or rewrites classic stories, challenging their established meanings
  • Draws attention to the ways in which literature is always in dialogue with other texts

Self-Reflexivity in Postmodern Literature

John Barth's "Lost in the Funhouse"

• Collection of short stories that explore the nature of storytelling
  • Narrator often directly addresses the reader, commenting on the writing process
  • Stories draw attention to their own fictional status and the conventions of narrative
  • Example: In the title story, the narrator repeatedly interrupts the plot to discuss the challenges of writing a compelling narrative
• Barth's self-reflexive techniques foreground the artificiality of narrative
  • Highlights the role of language in constructing reality
  • Challenges readers to question their assumptions about the relationship between fiction and truth

Italo Calvino's "If on a winter's night a traveler"

• Narrative is constantly interrupted by reflections on the act of reading
  • Explores the relationship between the reader, the author, and the text
  • Chapters alternate between the story of the reader trying to read a book and the various novel beginnings they encounter
• Calvino's novel is a metafictional exploration of the reading process
  • Draws attention to the ways in which readers participate in the creation of meaning
  • Challenges traditional notions of authorship and the stability of the text
  • Example: The novel's structure mirrors the fragmented nature of the reading experience, as the reader's expectations are repeatedly subverted

Paul Auster's "New York Trilogy"

• Trilogy consists of "City of Glass," "Ghosts," and "The Locked Room"
  • Blurs the lines between detective fiction and metafiction
  • Features characters who are writers, often working on the very story in which they appear
• Auster's novels explore the porous boundaries between fiction and reality
  • Characters' identities are unstable, often merging or splitting in unexpected ways
  • The role of the author is questioned, as characters struggle to control their own narratives
  • Example: In "City of Glass," the protagonist assumes the identity of a detective novelist, blurring the lines between the fictional world and the real one

Challenging Narrative Structures

Subverting Conventional Plot Structures

• Barth, Calvino, and Auster often subvert conventional plot structures
  • Reject linear progression of events or clear resolution of conflicts
  • Favor fragmented, open-ended narratives that resist easy interpretation
  • Example: In Barth's "Chimera," the three novellas are interconnected but lack a clear overarching plot, challenging the reader to find meaning in the fragments

Incorporating and Deconstructing Genres

• These authors frequently incorporate elements of other genres, such as detective fiction or fairy tales
  • Deconstruct and reconfigure these genres in unexpected ways
  • Use familiar tropes to subvert reader expectations and highlight the artificiality of narrative conventions
  • Example: Auster's "New York Trilogy" uses elements of detective fiction, but the mysteries are never fully resolved, and the detectives often become lost in their own investigations

Engaging with Literary History

• Barth, Calvino, and Auster engage with literary history through allusion and reimagining
  • Rewrite or adapt canonical works, often in playful or subversive ways
  • Highlight the intertextual nature of all literature, challenging the notion of originality
  • Example: Calvino's "If on a winter's night a traveler" contains numerous references to classic authors and genres, recontextualizing them within a postmodern framework
• By situating their works within a larger literary tradition, these authors:
  • Question the authority of the author and the stability of meaning
  • Suggest that literature is always open to multiple interpretations and rewritings
  • Encourage readers to actively participate in the creation of meaning

Effectiveness of Postmodern Techniques

Exploring Postmodern Concerns

• Metafiction and intertextuality are powerful tools for exploring postmodern concerns
  • Fragmentation of identity, instability of meaning, blurring of boundaries between high and low culture
  • Challenge readers to question their assumptions about literature and the world
  • Foster a more active and critical engagement with the text, as readers participate in meaning-making
  • Example: By drawing attention to the constructed nature of narrative and the role of language in shaping reality, these techniques encourage readers to interrogate their own beliefs and perceptions

Potential Limitations

• The effectiveness of metafiction and intertextuality can vary depending on the skill of the author and the receptiveness of the reader
  • Some critics argue that these techniques can become self-indulgent or alienating if overused
  • May prioritize formal experimentation over engaging storytelling or thematic depth
  • Example: A novel that is so preoccupied with its own cleverness that it fails to connect with readers on an emotional or intellectual level
• The success of metafiction and intertextuality in conveying postmodern ideas depends on balance
  • Authors must balance formal experimentation with accessible narrative and meaningful themes
  • Readers must be willing to engage with the challenges and ambiguities posed by these texts

Lasting Impact

• Despite potential limitations, metafiction and intertextuality have had a significant impact on contemporary literature
  • Expanded the possibilities of narrative form and challenged traditional notions of what literature can do
  • Encouraged readers to approach texts with a more critical and engaged mindset
  • Example: The influence of Barth, Calvino, and Auster can be seen in the works of numerous contemporary authors who continue to experiment with metafictional techniques and explore postmodern themes
• Metafiction and intertextuality remain vital tools for interrogating the complexities of the postmodern world
  • Offer a means of navigating the increasingly blurred boundaries between fiction and reality, self and other, and past and present
  • Challenge readers to actively participate in the construction of meaning and to question the very nature of storytelling itself