13.3 Marxist and New Historicist approaches

Marxist and New Historicist approaches analyze literature through the lens of social, economic, and historical contexts. These methods view texts as products of their time, reflecting power structures, class struggles, and ideologies.

These critical approaches examine how literature both mirrors and shapes society. They explore the relationship between texts and their cultural contexts, considering how literature can reinforce or challenge dominant power structures and ideologies.

Literature and Its Context

Marxist Criticism Views Literature as a Reflection of Social and Economic Realities

Top images from around the web for Marxist Criticism Views Literature as a Reflection of Social and Economic Realities

• 

  The Revolutionary Theory of Karl Marx – Revolutions: Theorists, Theory and Practice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Groups And Social Control - The Collaboratory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Conflict Theory and Society – Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Revolutionary Theory of Karl Marx – Revolutions: Theorists, Theory and Practice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Groups And Social Control - The Collaboratory View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Marxist Criticism Views Literature as a Reflection of Social and Economic Realities

• 

  The Revolutionary Theory of Karl Marx – Revolutions: Theorists, Theory and Practice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Groups And Social Control - The Collaboratory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Conflict Theory and Society – Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Revolutionary Theory of Karl Marx – Revolutions: Theorists, Theory and Practice View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Groups And Social Control - The Collaboratory View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Marxist literary criticism examines literature as a product of its historical, social, and economic context rather than as an isolated work of art
• Literature reflects the social institutions and economic realities from which it originates (class structure, means of production, distribution of wealth and resources)
• Marxist critics analyze how literature reflects the ideologies and power dynamics of its historical context
  • Focus on issues of class struggle, exploitation, and social inequality (proletariat vs. bourgeoisie)
• The relationship between the economic base (means of production) and the superstructure (culture, politics, law) is a key concern in Marxist criticism
  • Literature is seen as part of the superstructure that both reflects and reinforces the economic base
  • Example: A novel set in a factory town during the Industrial Revolution may reflect the harsh working conditions and class inequalities of that time period

Marxist Criticism Examines the Production, Distribution, and Consumption of Literature

• Marxist critics consider how literature is produced, distributed, and consumed within a specific historical and economic context
  • Factors such as patronage, publishing, and audience reception are analyzed
• The commodification of literature under capitalism is a key concern
  • How literature is marketed and sold as a product, and how this influences its content and reception
• The role of literature in shaping public opinion and reinforcing dominant ideologies is examined
  • Example: A bestselling novel that promotes individualism and free-market capitalism may be seen as reinforcing the dominant ideology of its time

Class, Power, and Ideology in Literature

Representation of Class Structure and Power Dynamics

• Marxist critics investigate how literature represents and reflects the class structure of its society
  • Focus on the experiences and struggles of the working class or the proletariat
• Power dynamics between different social classes are examined in literary works
  • Bourgeoisie (owners of the means of production) vs. proletariat (working class)
  • How these dynamics are maintained or challenged
• The concept of hegemony, or the cultural and ideological dominance of the ruling class, is investigated in literary works
  • How literature can serve to maintain or challenge this dominance
  • Example: A novel that portrays the lives of factory workers may highlight the power imbalance between workers and owners, and the ways in which this imbalance is maintained through ideology and cultural norms

Ideology and Class Consciousness in Literature

• Ideology, or the dominant ideas and beliefs that serve the interests of the ruling class, is analyzed in literature
  • How literary works reinforce, question, or subvert prevailing ideologies
• Marxist criticism examines how characters, themes, and conflicts in literature are shaped by class relations and the unequal distribution of power and resources in society
  • Example: A play that depicts a working-class protagonist struggling against the constraints of their social position may be seen as challenging dominant ideologies of meritocracy and social mobility
• The role of literature in the formation of class consciousness is investigated by Marxist critics
  • Class consciousness refers to the awareness of one's position within the class structure and the shared interests of one's class
  • How literature can contribute to the development of class consciousness and inspire resistance to oppression

Literature and Cultural Values

Literature Reflects and Influences Cultural Values and Beliefs

• Marxist critics analyze how literature both mirrors and influences the values, beliefs, and norms of its society
  • Recognizes the dialectical relationship between literature and culture
• Literature is seen as a product of its cultural context, reflecting the dominant ideas, attitudes, and assumptions of its time
  • Often from the perspective of the ruling class
  • Example: A Victorian novel that emphasizes the importance of marriage and domesticity may reflect the dominant cultural values of that era
• At the same time, literature can also shape and challenge cultural values and beliefs
  • Presents alternative perspectives, critiques social norms, or imagines new possibilities for social organization
  • Example: A feminist novel that challenges traditional gender roles and advocates for women's rights may contribute to shifting cultural attitudes and values

Literature as a Tool for Social Change

• Marxist criticism examines how literature can serve as a tool for social change
  • Raises awareness of social inequalities, inspires resistance to oppression, or envisions a more just and equitable society
• The role of literature in shaping public discourse and influencing social movements is analyzed
  • Example: A novel that exposes the injustices of racial segregation may contribute to the growth of the civil rights movement
• The potential for literature to contribute to the development of revolutionary consciousness is investigated
  • How literature can inspire readers to question and resist oppressive social structures
  • Example: A play that depicts a successful workers' revolt may encourage readers to challenge the capitalist system and advocate for socialist alternatives

Literature and Power Structures

Reinforcing or Challenging Dominant Power Structures

• Marxist criticism assesses whether literary works reinforce or challenge the dominant power structures of their society
  • Such as the capitalist system, patriarchy, or white supremacy
• Literature that reinforces dominant power structures may do so by:
  • Naturalizing or legitimizing social inequalities
  • Presenting the status quo as inevitable or desirable
  • Marginalizing the experiences and perspectives of oppressed groups
  • Example: A novel that portrays colonialism as a civilizing mission may reinforce dominant power structures of white supremacy and imperialism
• Literature that challenges dominant power structures may do so by:
  • Exposing and critiquing social injustices
  • Giving voice to the experiences of marginalized groups
  • Imagining alternative forms of social organization
  • Example: A poem that celebrates the resistance of indigenous peoples against colonial oppression may challenge dominant power structures of racism and imperialism

Political Implications and Reification in Literature

• Marxist critics evaluate the political implications of literary works
  • How they may serve the interests of the ruling class or contribute to the emancipation of oppressed groups
• The concept of reification, or the treatment of human beings as objects or commodities, is examined in literature
  • How literary works may reinforce or challenge this dehumanizing aspect of capitalist society
  • Example: A novel that portrays workers as interchangeable cogs in a machine may reinforce the reification of human beings under capitalism
• Marxist criticism investigates the potential for literature to contribute to the development of revolutionary consciousness
  • Inspiring readers to question and resist oppressive social structures
  • Example: A manifesto that calls for the overthrow of the bourgeoisie and the establishment of a classless society may contribute to the development of revolutionary consciousness among readers