2.3 Comparative analysis of formalist and realist approaches

Formalist and realist film theories represent two distinct approaches to filmmaking. Formalists emphasize artistic manipulation through techniques like montage and mise-en-scène, while realists aim to capture reality with minimal intervention using long takes and non-professional actors.

These theories have shaped cinematic history, influencing major film movements and driving technological advancements. Formalist approaches enable creative expression but risk artificiality, while realist methods provide authenticity but may lack visual spectacle. Many filmmakers blend both approaches to create unique cinematic experiences.

Formalist and Realist Film Theories

Formalist vs realist film theories

Top images from around the web for Formalist vs realist film theories

• 

  Mise-en-scène - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Plan (cinéma) — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  20 Great Movies That Revolutionized Film Editing | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Mise-en-scène - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Plan (cinéma) — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Formalist vs realist film theories

• 

  Mise-en-scène - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Plan (cinéma) — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  20 Great Movies That Revolutionized Film Editing | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Mise-en-scène - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Plan (cinéma) — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Formalist approach emphasizes artistic manipulation of reality through film form and style
  • Montage theory juxtaposes shots to create meaning
  • Mise-en-scène carefully arranges visual elements within frame
• Realist approach captures reality as it unfolds with minimal intervention
  • Long takes and deep focus cinematography enhance sense of realism
  • Non-professional actors contribute to authenticity
• Theoretical foundations rooted in distinct philosophical traditions
  • Formalism draws from Russian Formalism and Structuralism
  • Realism influenced by André Bazin's theories and Italian Neorealism movement

Strengths and limitations of approaches

• Formalist strengths enable creative expression through visual techniques
  • Manipulates time and space to convey abstract concepts
  • Creates powerful emotional impact through editing and composition
• Formalist limitations risk distancing viewers from reality
  • Can appear artificial or contrived if overused
• Realist strengths provide authenticity and immediacy
  • Immersive viewer experience fosters connection to subject matter
  • Effective for social commentary and exploring human condition
• Realist limitations constrain control over narrative elements
  • May lack visual spectacle or dynamic pacing
  • Potential for monotony in extended scenes

Application and Impact

Impact on film's artistic development

• Influenced major film movements shaped cinematic history
  • Soviet Montage (Eisenstein)
  • German Expressionism (Lang, Murnau)
  • Italian Neorealism (De Sica, Rossellini)
  • French New Wave (Godard, Truffaut)
• Drove technological advancements in filmmaking
  • Refined editing techniques (cross-cutting, jump cuts)
  • Improved camera mobility (Steadicam, handheld)
  • Evolved sound design (diegetic vs non-diegetic sound)
• Expanded narrative possibilities in storytelling
  • Non-linear structures challenge traditional chronology
  • Subjective point-of-view immerses audience in character perspective
  • Blended fiction and documentary styles blur reality boundaries

Application to specific films

• Formalist examples showcase artistic manipulation
  • Sergei Eisenstein's montage in "Battleship Potemkin" creates emotional impact
  • Alfred Hitchcock's subjective camera in "Vertigo" heightens psychological tension
  • Wes Anderson's symmetrical compositions in "The Grand Budapest Hotel" establish unique visual style
• Realist examples prioritize authenticity and natural elements
  • Vittorio De Sica's "Bicycle Thieves" uses non-professional actors and real locations
  • Yasujirō Ozu's static camera and long takes in "Tokyo Story" capture everyday life
  • Dogme 95 movement (Lars von Trier, Thomas Vinterberg) adheres to strict realist principles
• Hybrid approaches combine formalist and realist techniques
  • Orson Welles' "Citizen Kane" blends deep focus with expressionistic lighting
  • Federico Fellini's "La Strada" incorporates neorealism with surrealist elements
  • Christopher Nolan's "Inception" mixes practical effects with formalist visual concepts