12.3 Magic and marginalized groups (women, foreigners, slaves)

Magic in ancient Greece and Rome was often linked to marginalized groups like women, foreigners, and slaves. This reflected societal power dynamics and biases, with magic seen as a tool of the powerless to gain influence.

The association of magic with these groups served to reinforce social hierarchies and justify discrimination. However, it also provided a way for marginalized people to resist oppression and exert control over their lives.

Magic and Marginalization in Greco-Roman Society

Societal Dynamics and Cultural Biases

Top images from around the web for Societal Dynamics and Cultural Biases

• 

  Getty Voices: Mystery Cults and the Mother Goddess | Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Roman sarcophagus (detail), Rome, 240-260 CE - Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art - DSC08220.JPG ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Potions and Poisons: Classical Ancestors of the Wicked Witch, Part 1 | The Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Getty Voices: Mystery Cults and the Mother Goddess | Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Roman sarcophagus (detail), Rome, 240-260 CE - Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art - DSC08220.JPG ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Societal Dynamics and Cultural Biases

• 

  Getty Voices: Mystery Cults and the Mother Goddess | Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Roman sarcophagus (detail), Rome, 240-260 CE - Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art - DSC08220.JPG ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Potions and Poisons: Classical Ancestors of the Wicked Witch, Part 1 | The Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Getty Voices: Mystery Cults and the Mother Goddess | Getty Iris View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Roman sarcophagus (detail), Rome, 240-260 CE - Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art - DSC08220.JPG ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Magic associated with individuals on fringes of Greco-Roman society (women, foreigners, slaves) reflected societal power dynamics and cultural biases
• Concept of "otherness" linked marginalized groups to magical practices
  • Those not conforming to societal norms more likely accused of or associated with magic
• Literary and historical sources portrayed marginalized groups as magic practitioners, reinforcing stereotypes and societal fears
• Association of magic with marginalized groups served as means of social control and reinforcement of existing power structures
• Magical practices attributed to marginalized groups often included:
  • Divination
  • Curse tablets
  • Love spells
  • Viewed as threats to social order
• Perception of magic as tool of the powerless contributed to its association with marginalized groups
  • Believed to resort to supernatural means to gain influence

Perception and Impact of Magical Practices

• Mystery and secrecy surrounding certain magical practices made them easy to associate with groups viewed with suspicion or fear
• Portrayal of marginalized groups as magical practitioners reflected anxieties about:
  • Social change
  • Challenges to established power structures
• Attribution of magical practices to marginalized groups served to:
  • Reinforce social hierarchies
  • Justify discriminatory treatment
• Public perception of magical practices varied based on practitioner's social status
  • Elite male practitioners sometimes viewed as learned philosophers rather than dangerous sorcerers
• Intersection of gender and social status created complex dynamics in magical accusations
  • Elite women sometimes used their status to protect themselves from prosecution

Stereotypes of Magic Practitioners

Gender and Cultural Stereotypes

• Gender roles and expectations in Greco-Roman society contributed to portrayal of women as magic practitioners
  • Particularly in areas related to fertility, love, and domestic affairs
• Xenophobia and ethnocentrism led to association of foreigners with exotic and potentially dangerous magical practices
  • Especially those from Egypt, Persia, and other "Eastern" cultures
• Lack of social and political power among slaves made them vulnerable to accusations of using magic
  • Seen as means of resistance or revenge against their masters
• Literary tropes and mythological traditions reinforced stereotypes of women and foreigners as powerful and dangerous magical practitioners
  • Example: Figure of Medea (sorceress from Greek mythology)

Reasons for Stereotypical Portrayals

• Attribution of magical practices to marginalized groups served to reinforce social hierarchies
• Portrayal of marginalized groups as magical practitioners reflected anxieties about social change
• Mystery and secrecy surrounding certain magical practices made them easy to associate with groups viewed with suspicion
• Concept of "otherness" played crucial role in linking marginalized groups to magical practices
  • Those not conforming to societal norms more likely accused of or associated with magic
• Perception of magic as tool of the powerless contributed to its association with marginalized groups
  • Believed to resort to supernatural means to gain influence

Social Status and Magic Perception

Legal and Social Consequences

• Higher social status generally provided protection against accusations of magic
  • Lower status individuals more vulnerable to prosecution
• Gender played significant role in magical accusations
  • Women more frequently targeted for certain types of magic (love spells and poisoning)
• Legal framework for prosecuting magical practices often disproportionately affected marginalized groups
  • Reflected broader societal biases
• Prosecution of magical practices often served as pretext for addressing other social or political conflicts
  • Particularly when targeting marginalized individuals
• Severity of punishments for magical practices varied significantly based on accused's social status and gender
  • Reflected broader inequalities in the legal system

Societal Perceptions and Biases

• Public perception of magical practices varied based on practitioner's social status
  • Elite male practitioners sometimes viewed as learned philosophers rather than dangerous sorcerers
• Intersection of gender and social status created complex dynamics in magical accusations
  • Elite women sometimes used their status to protect themselves from prosecution
• Attribution of magical practices to marginalized groups served to reinforce social hierarchies
• Portrayal of marginalized groups as magical practitioners reflected anxieties about:
  • Social change
  • Challenges to established power structures
• Concept of "otherness" played crucial role in linking marginalized groups to magical practices
  • Those not conforming to societal norms more likely accused of or associated with magic

Magic as Empowerment and Resistance

Forms of Magical Resistance

• Magic provided perceived avenue for marginalized groups to exert influence and control over their lives
  • Limited power through conventional means in society
• Curse tablets and binding spells used by slaves and lower-class individuals as form of resistance
  • Targeted those in positions of authority
• Love magic and fertility spells allowed women to exercise agency in relationships and reproduction
  • Areas where they traditionally had limited control
• Practice of magic served as means of cultural preservation for foreign groups
  • Allowed maintenance of connections to ancestral traditions
• Magical practices sometimes provided economic opportunities for marginalized individuals
  • Offered services as diviners, healers, or spell-casters

Social Impact of Magical Practices

• Secrecy and mystery surrounding magical practices created alternative power structures and communities
  • Challenged established social hierarchies
• Fear and respect accorded to perceived magical practitioners offered degree of protection or elevated status
  • Benefited marginalized individuals within their communities
• Magical practices attributed to marginalized groups often seen as threats to social order
  • Included forms of divination, curse tablets, and love spells
• Association of magic with marginalized groups served as means of social control
  • Reinforced existing power structures in Greco-Roman society
• Perception of magic as tool of the powerless contributed to its association with marginalized groups
  • Believed to resort to supernatural means to gain influence