9.1 Libel, Slander, and Defamation

Journalism ethics and law are crucial for reporters to understand. Libel, slander, and defamation can lead to serious legal consequences if not handled carefully. Knowing the definitions and risks helps journalists avoid costly lawsuits.

Verifying facts, documenting sources, and framing controversial statements as allegations are key ways to minimize defamation risk. Public figures face a higher standard of proof, but journalists must still exercise caution when reporting on sensitive personal issues.

Defamation in Journalism

Defining Defamation and Its Forms

Top images from around the web for Defining Defamation and Its Forms

• 

  Civil Penalties - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal 1 image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defamation Claims - Free of Charge Creative Commons Keyboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Libel Claim - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Civil Penalties - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal 1 image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defamation Claims - Free of Charge Creative Commons Keyboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Defamation and Its Forms

• 

  Civil Penalties - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal 1 image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defamation Claims - Free of Charge Creative Commons Keyboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Libel Claim - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Civil Penalties - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal 1 image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defamation Claims - Free of Charge Creative Commons Keyboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Defamation is a catch-all term that encompasses both libel and slander
  • Refers to any false statement, whether printed or spoken, that harms a person's reputation
• Libel is a false statement that is printed or broadcast about an individual that damages their reputation or standing in the community
  • It is a civil wrong that can result in a lawsuit and damages against the publisher (newspaper, website)
• Slander is a false spoken statement that damages someone's reputation
  • While slander is not printed or published, it can still be the basis for a civil lawsuit if it causes harm to the subject (public speech, conversation)
• In the United States, defamation is not a crime, but rather a civil wrong or "tort"
  • Subjects of defamatory statements can sue publishers for monetary damages

Legal Consequences of Defamation

• Publishing false statements that damage someone's reputation can open up journalists and news organizations to expensive civil lawsuits seeking monetary damages
• Even true statements can sometimes lead to defamation claims if they are published with actual malice or reckless disregard for the truth
• Defamation suits are more likely when stories deal with private individuals rather than public figures or officials who have to meet a higher standard of proof
  • Private figures generally only need to prove negligence, while public figures must prove actual malice
• Special care must be taken when quoting sources making potentially defamatory allegations
  • The journalist can be liable even if they are simply reporting what someone else said (republication liability)

Legal Risks of Defamation

Sensitive Personal Issues

• Journalists should be especially careful when reporting on sensitive personal issues that could severely damage someone's reputation, such as:
  • Health problems (HIV status, mental illness)
  • Sexual misconduct (extramarital affairs, sexual assault allegations)
  • Criminal allegations (accusations of theft, fraud, violence)
• Reporting on these issues, even when factual, can lead to defamation claims if done maliciously or recklessly
  • Journalists must take great care to verify information and provide context

Quoting Defamatory Statements

• Directly quoting or paraphrasing someone else's defamatory statement can still expose the journalist to legal liability
  • This is known as republication liability - the reporter is "republishing" the defamatory allegation
• Journalists must be cautious about repeating unverified allegations, even if attributed to a source
  • Should seek to independently verify any potentially defamatory quotes before publication
• Framing controversial statements as allegations rather than facts can help mitigate risk
  • Attribute statements to specific sources and use words like "allegedly" (Smith allegedly embezzled funds)

Elements of Defamation Claims

Falsity and Identification

• The statement must be demonstrably false
  • True statements, no matter how damaging, cannot be defamatory (truth is an absolute defense)
• The statement must be "of and concerning" the plaintiff
  • It must be clear the statement is about that specific individual (refer to them by name)
  • Group libel against broad classes of people is usually not actionable (all lawyers are crooks)

Publication and Harm

• The statement must be published or broadcast to at least one other person beyond the subject
  • Private one-on-one conversations typically cannot be defamatory
• The plaintiff must prove the statement harmed their reputation or standing in the community in a quantifiable way
  • Typically proven through monetary losses or damages (lost job, lost clients, medical bills)
• If the plaintiff is a public figure or official, they must additionally prove actual malice
  • The journalist knew the statement was false or had reckless disregard for the truth

Minimizing Defamation Risk

Verification and Documentation

• Carefully fact-check sources and documents to ensure all aspects of a story are truthful and can be verified prior to publication
• Obtain independent confirmation of key facts from multiple credible sources rather than relying on a single source
  • Especially important for sensitive or damaging allegations
• Keep careful notes, recordings, or other documentation of research, interviews, and sources
  • Helps prove the truth of published statements if challenged in court

Pre-Publication Diligence

• When possible, provide the subject of a story an opportunity to respond to any allegations of wrongdoing or misconduct prior to publication
  • Demonstrates fairness and lack of actual malice
• Frame controversial statements as allegations rather than facts and attribute them to specific sources when possible
  • Avoid stating contested claims as definitive truths (Smith stole money vs Smith allegedly stole money)
• Consult legal counsel prior to publication when a story contains potentially defamatory content
  • Ensures all statements can be defended if challenged in a lawsuit