10.2 Performance ethnography

Performance ethnography combines anthropological fieldwork with performative analysis, bridging the gap between observing and embodying cultural practices. This approach allows researchers to engage more deeply with cultural phenomena by participating in and recreating performances.

Key concepts include participant observation, reflexivity, and embodied knowledge. Researchers actively participate in cultural practices, balance insider and outsider perspectives, and recognize that cultural knowledge is often transmitted through bodily practices. This approach challenges traditional notions of objectivity and Western academic traditions.

Origins of performance ethnography

• Performance ethnography emerged as a methodology in performance studies combining anthropological fieldwork with performative analysis
• This approach bridges the gap between observing cultural practices and embodying them through performance
• Performance ethnography allows researchers to engage with cultural phenomena more deeply by participating in and recreating performances

Anthropological roots

Top images from around the web for Anthropological roots

• 

  Kiriwina-eilanden - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bronisław Malinowski among Trobriand tribe View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Margaret Mead - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Kiriwina-eilanden - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bronisław Malinowski among Trobriand tribe View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Anthropological roots

• 

  Kiriwina-eilanden - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bronisław Malinowski among Trobriand tribe View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Margaret Mead - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Kiriwina-eilanden - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bronisław Malinowski among Trobriand tribe View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Developed from traditional ethnographic methods used in anthropology to study cultures
• Emphasizes long-term immersion in a community to gain insider knowledge
• Incorporates participant observation techniques to understand cultural practices firsthand
• Draws on the work of anthropologists like Bronisław Malinowski and Margaret Mead

Influence of cultural studies

• Integrates critical analysis of power structures and social inequalities
• Examines how cultural practices reflect and reinforce societal norms
• Focuses on the production and circulation of meaning within cultures
• Influenced by scholars like Stuart Hall and Raymond Williams

Emergence in performance studies

• Developed as performance studies scholars sought to understand performance in cultural contexts
• Combines ethnographic methods with performance analysis and practice
• Emphasizes the embodied nature of cultural knowledge and expression
• Pioneered by researchers like Dwight Conquergood and Victor Turner

Key concepts and principles

• Performance ethnography integrates performance theory with ethnographic methods to study cultural practices
• This approach emphasizes the embodied nature of knowledge and the importance of participation in understanding cultural performances
• Key principles include reflexivity, thick description, and the recognition of performance as a site of cultural meaning-making

Participant observation

• Involves researchers actively participating in the cultural practices they study
• Requires balancing insider and outsider perspectives to gain deep understanding
• Allows researchers to experience cultural performances firsthand
• Challenges traditional notions of objectivity in research

Reflexivity and positionality

• Acknowledges the researcher's own cultural background and biases
• Requires ongoing self-reflection throughout the research process
• Examines how the researcher's presence impacts the observed performances
• Encourages transparency about the researcher's relationship to the studied community

Embodied knowledge

• Recognizes that cultural knowledge is often stored and transmitted through bodily practices
• Emphasizes learning through physical participation in cultural performances
• Challenges the mind-body dualism prevalent in Western academic traditions
• Explores how cultural meanings are encoded in gestures, movements, and sensory experiences

Thick description

• Provides detailed, contextualized accounts of cultural performances
• Goes beyond surface-level observations to interpret underlying meanings
• Incorporates multiple perspectives and layers of interpretation
• Developed by anthropologist Clifford Geertz to capture the complexity of cultural phenomena

Methodological approaches

• Performance ethnography employs a range of methods to gather and analyze data on cultural performances
• These approaches combine traditional ethnographic techniques with performance-based research methods
• Researchers often adapt and combine methods to suit the specific cultural context and research questions

Fieldwork techniques

• Involves extended periods of immersion in the studied community
• Utilizes field notes, audio-visual recordings, and artifacts to document observations
• Requires building rapport and trust with community members
• Includes mapping performance spaces and tracking patterns of cultural activity

Interviewing strategies

• Employs semi-structured and unstructured interviews to gather insider perspectives
• Uses oral history techniques to collect narratives about cultural performances
• Incorporates performance-based interviewing methods (re-enactments, role-playing)
• Considers the interview itself as a performance worthy of analysis

Performance as research method

• Researchers learn and perform cultural practices as a way of understanding them
• Involves creating original performances based on ethnographic data
• Uses performance to test hypotheses and generate new insights
• Explores how performance can communicate research findings to diverse audiences

Autoethnography vs ethnography

• Autoethnography focuses on the researcher's personal experiences within a cultural context
• Traditional ethnography studies the experiences of others in a cultural group
• Autoethnography emphasizes reflexivity and the researcher's positionality
• Both approaches can be combined to provide multiple perspectives on cultural performances

Ethical considerations

• Performance ethnography raises unique ethical challenges due to its participatory nature
• Researchers must navigate complex power dynamics and cultural differences
• Ethical considerations are ongoing throughout the research process, from design to dissemination

Informed consent

• Requires clear communication about research goals and potential impacts
• Involves ongoing negotiation of consent throughout the research process
• Considers how to obtain consent for performances that may be spontaneous or improvised
• Addresses challenges of obtaining consent in group settings or public performances

Representation of others

• Examines how researchers portray the studied community in their writings and performances
• Considers the potential consequences of representation for community members
• Explores collaborative approaches to representation (member checking, co-authorship)
• Addresses issues of cultural appropriation and misrepresentation

Power dynamics in research

• Acknowledges the inherent power imbalances between researchers and participants
• Examines how researchers' privileges and institutional affiliations impact the research process
• Explores ways to share power and decision-making with research participants
• Considers how performance can challenge or reinforce existing power structures

Cultural sensitivity

• Requires researchers to develop deep understanding of cultural norms and taboos
• Involves respecting cultural boundaries and sacred practices
• Addresses challenges of translating cultural concepts across linguistic and cultural divides
• Considers how to approach sensitive topics or controversial performances ethically

Writing and presenting ethnography

• Performance ethnography employs various strategies to communicate research findings
• These approaches often blur the boundaries between academic writing and creative expression
• Researchers experiment with form and style to capture the embodied nature of cultural performances

Narrative strategies

• Uses storytelling techniques to convey the lived experiences of cultural participants
• Incorporates multiple voices and perspectives into the ethnographic narrative
• Employs literary devices (dialogue, scene-setting, character development) to engage readers
• Balances descriptive detail with analytical insights

Performative writing

• Experiments with writing styles that evoke the sensory and emotional aspects of performances
• Uses poetic and non-linear forms to capture the complexity of cultural experiences
• Incorporates visual elements, typography, and layout to enhance the text's performative qualities
• Challenges traditional academic writing conventions to better represent embodied knowledge

Ethnodrama and ethnotheatre

• Transforms ethnographic data into scripted performances or theatrical productions
• Uses verbatim techniques to incorporate participants' own words into performances
• Explores how staging and embodiment can communicate research findings
• Engages audiences in dialogues about cultural performances and research ethics

Digital ethnography

• Utilizes digital tools and platforms to collect, analyze, and present ethnographic data
• Incorporates multimedia elements (video, audio, interactive graphics) into ethnographic accounts
• Explores virtual and online spaces as sites of cultural performance
• Addresses challenges of representing embodied practices in digital formats

Critical perspectives

• Performance ethnography has been influenced by various critical theories and approaches
• These perspectives challenge traditional ethnographic methods and assumptions
• Critical approaches encourage researchers to examine power relations and cultural biases in their work

Postcolonial critiques

• Examines how ethnographic practices have been implicated in colonial and neocolonial projects
• Challenges Western-centric assumptions about cultural performances and their meanings
• Explores how performance can be a site of resistance to colonial legacies
• Emphasizes the importance of indigenous methodologies and knowledge systems

Feminist approaches

• Focuses on gender as a key factor in shaping cultural performances and their interpretations
• Examines how performance ethnography can reinforce or challenge gender norms
• Explores embodied knowledge from feminist perspectives
• Addresses issues of representation and voice in ethnographic accounts

Queer theory in ethnography

• Investigates how heteronormative assumptions influence ethnographic research and writing
• Explores performances of gender and sexuality that challenge binary categories
• Examines how queer perspectives can reveal hidden or marginalized cultural practices
• Considers how researchers' own sexual identities impact their fieldwork experiences

Decolonizing methodologies

• Seeks to dismantle colonial influences in research methods and academic institutions
• Prioritizes indigenous ways of knowing and researching
• Explores collaborative and community-based approaches to performance ethnography
• Examines how performance can be used to reclaim and revitalize cultural practices

Applications in performance studies

• Performance ethnography has been applied to various areas within performance studies
• This approach allows researchers to examine how performance shapes and reflects cultural identities
• Applications range from studying traditional rituals to analyzing everyday social interactions

Ritual and social drama

• Examines how rituals and ceremonial performances reinforce social structures
• Analyzes the role of performance in managing social conflicts and transitions
• Draws on Victor Turner's concepts of liminality and communitas
• Explores how rituals adapt and change in response to social and cultural shifts

Everyday life performances

• Investigates how people perform their identities in daily interactions
• Examines the performative aspects of social roles and behaviors
• Draws on Erving Goffman's dramaturgical approach to social interaction
• Explores how cultural norms are enacted and contested through everyday performances

Cultural performances

• Studies large-scale public events and spectacles (festivals, parades, ceremonies)
• Examines how cultural performances reflect and shape collective identities
• Analyzes the role of performance in preserving and transmitting cultural heritage
• Explores how globalization impacts traditional and contemporary cultural performances

Identity and performance

• Investigates how individuals and groups perform their cultural, ethnic, and national identities
• Examines the intersection of multiple identities in performance contexts
• Explores how marginalized groups use performance to assert their identities and rights
• Analyzes how performances can reinforce or challenge stereotypes and cultural assumptions

Challenges and limitations

• Performance ethnography faces several challenges in its application and theoretical foundations
• Researchers must navigate complex ethical and methodological issues
• Critics have raised concerns about the validity and generalizability of performance ethnographic research

Subjectivity vs objectivity

• Grapples with balancing personal experiences with rigorous analysis
• Challenges traditional notions of scientific objectivity in research
• Explores how researchers' subjectivity can be a valuable source of insight
• Addresses concerns about the reliability and validity of subjective accounts

Insider vs outsider perspectives

• Navigates the complexities of researchers' positions relative to studied communities
• Examines the benefits and limitations of both insider and outsider statuses
• Explores how researchers can move between insider and outsider roles
• Addresses challenges of translation and interpretation across cultural boundaries

Generalizability of findings

• Questions the extent to which findings from specific cultural contexts can be applied more broadly
• Explores tensions between deep, contextual understanding and broader theoretical insights
• Examines how performance ethnography can contribute to larger discussions in social sciences
• Addresses critiques of ethnography as merely descriptive or anecdotal

Ethical dilemmas in practice

• Navigates complex situations where research ethics and cultural norms may conflict
• Addresses challenges of maintaining confidentiality in performance contexts
• Explores the potential for research to exploit or harm vulnerable communities
• Examines the long-term impacts of performance ethnography on studied communities