13.4 International Organizations and Global Governance

International organizations shape global policy by setting agendas, facilitating cooperation, and influencing state behavior. From the UN to NGOs, these entities tackle transnational issues like trade, human rights, and security, though powerful states often wield outsized influence.

Global governance involves managing common problems internationally through multiple actors and levels. While states remain key players, non-state entities like corporations and NGOs also shape agendas and rules. This complex system both constrains and enhances national policy autonomy.

International Organizations and Global Policy

Role and Influence of International Organizations

Top images from around the web for Role and Influence of International Organizations

• 

  Organization - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Delegation to Treaty Bodies and International Organizations for Conventional Arms Control ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The G7 and G20 in the global governance landscape | Heinrich Böll Stiftung | Washington, DC ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Organization - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Delegation to Treaty Bodies and International Organizations for Conventional Arms Control ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Role and Influence of International Organizations

• 

  Organization - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Delegation to Treaty Bodies and International Organizations for Conventional Arms Control ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The G7 and G20 in the global governance landscape | Heinrich Böll Stiftung | Washington, DC ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Organization - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Delegation to Treaty Bodies and International Organizations for Conventional Arms Control ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• International organizations are entities established by formal political agreements between their members that have the status of international treaties
• These multilateral institutions operate with global or regional scope
• International organizations play a key role in setting the agenda and framing issues in global public policy by identifying problems, conducting research and analysis, proposing solutions, and building political momentum around certain policy approaches
• They facilitate cooperation and coordination among states on transnational issues like trade, finance, development, human rights, the environment, and security by providing forums for states to negotiate agreements and standards

Types and Characteristics of International Organizations

• Some international organizations, like the United Nations, have near universal membership, while others are more limited in scope
• Membership criteria and decision-making processes vary across organizations
• International organizations can be classified as intergovernmental organizations (IGOs) with states as members (European Union) or international non-governmental organizations (INGOs) composed of non-state actors like civil society groups (Amnesty International)
• Powerful states often have outsized influence within international organizations, shaping their priorities and constraining their autonomy, which raises questions about the legitimacy and accountability of these organizations
• International organizations do not have the power to directly implement or enforce policies on sovereign states, instead relying on tools like agenda-setting, information-sharing, capacity-building, and monitoring to influence state behavior

Dynamics of Global Governance

Nature and Characteristics of Global Governance

• Global governance refers to the collective management of common problems at the international level, encompassing the activities and processes of both state and non-state actors
• In an interdependent world, national policies are increasingly shaped by forces and decisions beyond the state's borders as international rules, standards, and policy frameworks limit purely national solutions
• Global governance is characterized by polycentricity, with multiple organizations and initiatives rather than a single world government, and authority is dispersed with decision-making occurring at multiple levels
• States remain the primary actors in global governance, but non-state actors like multinational corporations (Apple), NGOs (Greenpeace), philanthropic foundations (Gates Foundation), and international organizations (World Bank) also play important roles in agenda-setting, rule-making, and implementation

Instruments and Interactions of Global Governance

• Formal international law, created through treaties and conventions, is a key instrument of global governance, but it also occurs through informal means like standards, guidelines, and codes of conduct
• Effective global governance requires balancing the principle of state sovereignty with the need for collective action to address transnational challenges, as sovereignty concerns often impede international cooperation
• Global governance can enhance or constrain the policy autonomy of national governments - international rules may limit domestic policy options, while in other cases engagement in global initiatives can expand states' capacities
• Domestic politics and global governance are intertwined, with national policy preferences shaping states' positions in international forums, while conversely, international commitments create pressures for domestic compliance

Challenges and Opportunities of Cross-Border Policy Coordination

Obstacles to Policy Coordination

• Policy coordination across borders is necessary to effectively address transnational problems like climate change, pandemics, financial instability, organized crime, and migration that cannot be managed by countries acting alone
• Divergent national interests, values, and priorities are a fundamental challenge to policy coordination as states may have incentives to free ride on the efforts of others rather than contribute to collective solutions
• Differences in economic development, technical capacity, and political systems can impede coordination, as states may not have equivalent abilities to participate in policymaking or implement agreements
• Coordinating policies often involves trade-offs between national autonomy and international commitments, making states reluctant to bind themselves to rules that limit their future freedom of action
• Unequal power dynamics among states shape the terms of policy coordination, with dominant powers potentially using coordination mechanisms to impose their preferred policies on weaker states

Facilitators and Benefits of Policy Coordination

• Transnational policy networks, composed of officials and experts across countries, can facilitate coordination by building trust, sharing information, and promoting policy learning, although their informality raises questions of transparency and accountability
• Effective coordination requires monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with shared rules and commitments, but the anarchic nature of the international system makes enforcement challenging
• Policy coordination can lead to greater efficiency and impact by reducing duplication, leveraging comparative advantages (specialization based on strengths), and mobilizing collective resources
• Coordination can also promote policy coherence across different issue areas (trade and environment)