3.7 Lu-Hf system

The Lu-Hf system is a powerful tool in isotope geochemistry, used for dating rocks and understanding Earth's evolution. It relies on the radioactive decay of lutetium-176 to hafnium-176, with a half-life of 37.1 billion years.

This system provides insights into crustal growth, mantle differentiation, and meteorite formation. By analyzing Lu-Hf isotope ratios in minerals and rocks, geologists can uncover valuable information about Earth's geochemical processes and planetary formation events.

Fundamentals of Lu-Hf system

• Lu-Hf system provides valuable insights into Earth's geochemical processes and evolution
• Widely used in isotope geochemistry for dating rocks and understanding planetary formation

Lutetium and hafnium properties

Top images from around the web for Lutetium and hafnium properties

• 

  Chemical Elements - Lutetium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  EJM - Partitioning of chromium between garnet and clinopyroxene: first-principle modelling ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chemical Elements - Hafnium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chemical Elements - Lutetium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  EJM - Partitioning of chromium between garnet and clinopyroxene: first-principle modelling ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Lutetium and hafnium properties

• 

  Chemical Elements - Lutetium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  EJM - Partitioning of chromium between garnet and clinopyroxene: first-principle modelling ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chemical Elements - Hafnium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chemical Elements - Lutetium View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  EJM - Partitioning of chromium between garnet and clinopyroxene: first-principle modelling ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Lutetium (Lu) belongs to the lanthanide series with atomic number 71
• Hafnium (Hf) sits in group 4 of the periodic table with atomic number 72
• Both elements exhibit similar ionic radii but different chemical behaviors
• Lu tends to concentrate in minerals like garnet and clinopyroxene
• Hf commonly substitutes for zirconium in zircon crystals

Radioactive decay process

• 176Lu decays to 176Hf through beta decay
• Decay equation $^{176}Lu \rightarrow ^{176}Hf + \beta^- + \bar{v}_e$
• Process involves emission of an electron and an antineutrino
• Decay rate remains constant regardless of temperature or pressure
• Allows for accurate dating of geological materials

Half-life and decay constant

• Half-life of 176Lu measures 37.1 billion years
• Decay constant (λ) calculated as $\lambda = \frac{ln(2)}{t_{1/2}}$
• Long half-life makes Lu-Hf system suitable for dating ancient rocks
• Decay constant used in age calculations and isotope evolution models
• Slow decay rate allows for high precision in geochronological studies

Isotopic composition

• Isotopic composition of Lu and Hf crucial for understanding geochemical processes
• Variations in isotope ratios provide information on source materials and geological history

Lu isotopes

• Lutetium has two naturally occurring isotopes: 175Lu and 176Lu
• 175Lu stable isotope with 97.41% natural abundance
• 176Lu radioactive isotope with 2.59% natural abundance
• 176Lu/175Lu ratio used in geochronological calculations
• Isotopic composition can vary slightly due to fractionation processes

Hf isotopes

• Hafnium has six naturally occurring isotopes: 174Hf, 176Hf, 177Hf, 178Hf, 179Hf, and 180Hf
• 176Hf both radiogenic (from 176Lu decay) and primordial in origin
• 177Hf commonly used as a reference isotope in ratio measurements
• 176Hf/177Hf ratio key parameter in Lu-Hf dating and geochemical tracing

Natural abundance ratios

• 176Lu/177Hf ratio in chondrites approximately 0.0332
• 176Hf/177Hf ratio in chondrites about 0.282785
• Variations in these ratios used to determine age and petrogenetic history
• Ratios differ between reservoirs (crust, mantle, meteorites)
• Understanding natural abundances essential for accurate isotope measurements

Lu-Hf dating method

• Lu-Hf dating method allows determination of rock formation ages
• Particularly useful for dating igneous and metamorphic rocks

Principles of isochron dating

• Isochron method based on linear relationship between 176Lu/177Hf and 176Hf/177Hf ratios
• Slope of isochron line proportional to age of the rock
• Y-intercept represents initial 176Hf/177Hf ratio
• Requires analysis of multiple cogenetic samples with varying Lu/Hf ratios
• Equation for Lu-Hf isochron: $(\frac{^{176}Hf}{^{177}Hf})_{measured} = (\frac{^{176}Hf}{^{177}Hf})_{initial} + (\frac{^{176}Lu}{^{177}Hf})_{measured} \times (e^{\lambda t} - 1)$

Sample preparation techniques

• Careful mineral separation to isolate Lu and Hf-bearing phases
• Crushing and sieving to obtain appropriate grain sizes
• Heavy liquid separation to concentrate target minerals (garnet, zircon)
• Magnetic separation to further purify mineral fractions
• Acid washing to remove surface contamination

Analytical procedures

• Dissolution of samples in strong acids (HF, HNO3, HCl)
• Chemical separation of Lu and Hf using ion exchange chromatography
• Mass spectrometric analysis to measure isotope ratios
• Internal standardization and external calibration for accurate results
• Data reduction and error propagation to calculate final ages and uncertainties

Applications in geochronology

• Lu-Hf system widely applied in various fields of geochronology
• Provides insights into Earth's early history and ongoing geological processes

Crustal evolution studies

• Lu-Hf isotopes track crustal growth and recycling over time
• Hf isotope compositions in zircons reveal crustal formation events
• Allows reconstruction of continental growth rates throughout Earth's history
• Helps identify periods of major crust formation (Archean, Proterozoic)
• Useful for understanding tectonic processes and plate reconstructions

Mantle differentiation

• Lu-Hf system traces mantle melting and differentiation events
• Hf isotopes in basalts provide information on mantle source compositions
• Allows identification of different mantle reservoirs (depleted, enriched)
• Helps constrain timing and extent of major mantle melting episodes
• Useful for understanding mantle dynamics and convection patterns

Meteorite dating

• Lu-Hf dating applied to various types of meteorites (chondrites, achondrites)
• Provides constraints on the timing of solar system formation
• Allows dating of early planetary differentiation events
• Helps establish chronology of asteroid and planetesimal formation
• Useful for understanding the thermal and chemical evolution of planetesimals

Lu-Hf vs Sm-Nd systems

• Lu-Hf and Sm-Nd systems both used in isotope geochemistry
• Comparison of these systems provides valuable insights into geological processes

Similarities and differences

• Both systems based on radioactive decay of parent to daughter isotope
• Lu-Hf system has longer half-life (37.1 Ga) compared to Sm-Nd (106 Ga)
• Lu-Hf more sensitive to fractionation during partial melting and crystallization
• Hf more incompatible than Lu, while Sm and Nd have similar compatibilities
• Lu-Hf system often provides higher precision ages for certain rock types

Complementary applications

• Combined Lu-Hf and Sm-Nd studies provide robust age constraints
• Dual-dating approach helps identify disturbances in isotopic systems
• Lu-Hf better for dating high-Lu/Hf phases (garnet, zircon)
• Sm-Nd useful for whole-rock dating and tracing crustal residence times
• Integration of both systems improves understanding of petrogenetic processes

Fractionation processes

• Fractionation of Lu and Hf during geological processes affects isotopic compositions
• Understanding fractionation crucial for accurate interpretation of Lu-Hf data

Lu-Hf behavior during melting

• Lu more compatible than Hf during mantle melting
• Partial melting increases Lu/Hf ratio in residual mantle
• Melts have lower Lu/Hf ratios compared to their source
• Degree of melting affects extent of Lu-Hf fractionation
• Fractional crystallization can further modify Lu/Hf ratios in evolving magmas

Partitioning in minerals

• Lu and Hf exhibit different partitioning behaviors in various minerals
• Garnet strongly incorporates Lu relative to Hf
• Zircon preferentially incorporates Hf over Lu
• Clinopyroxene and amphibole show moderate Lu/Hf fractionation
• Mineral partitioning affects Lu-Hf systematics in igneous and metamorphic rocks

Geochemical reservoirs

• Earth composed of distinct geochemical reservoirs with varying Lu-Hf compositions
• Understanding reservoir compositions crucial for interpreting isotopic data

Chondritic uniform reservoir (CHUR)

• CHUR represents bulk Earth composition based on chondritic meteorites
• Used as a reference for calculating epsilon Hf values
• Present-day CHUR 176Hf/177Hf ratio approximately 0.282785
• CHUR evolution line represents undifferentiated mantle composition over time
• Deviations from CHUR indicate differentiation or mixing processes

Depleted mantle

• Depleted mantle formed by extraction of continental crust
• Characterized by higher 176Hf/177Hf ratios compared to CHUR
• Represents source of most mid-ocean ridge basalts (MORB)
• Depleted mantle evolution line used to calculate model ages
• Provides insights into mantle differentiation and crust formation processes

Continental crust

• Continental crust generally has lower 176Hf/177Hf ratios than mantle
• Old continental crust characterized by highly negative epsilon Hf values
• Juvenile crust shows epsilon Hf values close to depleted mantle
• Crustal Lu-Hf compositions reflect age and petrogenetic history
• Useful for tracing crustal recycling and mantle-crust interactions

Analytical techniques

• Various analytical methods employed for Lu-Hf isotope measurements
• Choice of technique depends on sample type, required precision, and research goals

Thermal ionization mass spectrometry

• TIMS provides high-precision isotope ratio measurements
• Samples loaded onto metal filaments and thermally ionized
• Allows for precise measurement of 176Hf/177Hf ratios
• Requires chemical separation of Lu and Hf prior to analysis
• Suitable for whole-rock and mineral separate analyses

Laser ablation ICP-MS

• LA-ICP-MS enables in situ analysis of minerals (zircon, garnet)
• Laser ablates small spots on sample surface
• Allows for spatial resolution and analysis of zoning patterns
• Rapid analysis of large numbers of grains
• Useful for detrital zircon studies and provenance analysis

MC-ICP-MS methods

• Multi-collector ICP-MS provides high-precision isotope measurements
• Allows simultaneous measurement of multiple isotopes
• Higher sample throughput compared to TIMS
• Requires careful correction for isobaric interferences (176Yb on 176Hf)
• Suitable for both solution and laser ablation analyses

Data interpretation

• Proper interpretation of Lu-Hf data crucial for understanding geological processes
• Various notations and calculations used to present and analyze results

Epsilon Hf notation

• Epsilon Hf (εHf) expresses deviation from CHUR in parts per 10,000
• Calculated using formula: $\varepsilon Hf = [(\frac{^{176}Hf}{^{177}Hf})_{sample} / (\frac{^{176}Hf}{^{177}Hf})_{CHUR} - 1] \times 10,000$
• Positive εHf values indicate depleted mantle source
• Negative εHf values suggest crustal contamination or enriched sources
• Useful for comparing Hf isotope compositions across different geological settings

Model age calculations

• Hf model ages estimate time of separation from a reference reservoir
• Depleted mantle model age (TDM) assumes derivation from depleted mantle
• Two-stage model ages account for crustal residence time
• Calculated using measured 176Hf/177Hf and 176Lu/177Hf ratios
• Provides insights into crustal formation and reworking processes

Hf isotope evolution diagrams

• Plot 176Hf/177Hf or εHf against time to show isotopic evolution
• Evolution lines for different reservoirs (CHUR, depleted mantle, crust)
• Allows visualization of isotopic changes over geological time
• Useful for identifying mixing trends and source components
• Helps constrain timing of major geological events

Limitations and challenges

• Lu-Hf system, while powerful, faces several limitations and challenges
• Understanding these issues crucial for accurate data interpretation

Analytical precision issues

• Precise measurement of 176Lu/177Hf ratios challenging due to low Lu abundance
• Isobaric interference of 176Yb on 176Hf requires careful correction
• Matrix effects can influence isotope ratio measurements
• Interlaboratory calibration important for data comparison
• Improvements in mass spectrometry continuously enhancing precision

Sample contamination risks

• Lu and Hf concentrations often low, making samples susceptible to contamination
• Laboratory blanks must be carefully monitored and minimized
• Sample preparation procedures critical to avoid cross-contamination
• Weathering and alteration can disturb Lu-Hf systematics in natural samples
• Careful sample selection and screening essential for reliable results

Interpretation complexities

• Multiple geological processes can produce similar isotopic signatures
• Mixing of different reservoirs complicates straightforward interpretations
• Metamorphism and metasomatism may reset or disturb Lu-Hf systematics
• Inherited components in igneous rocks can skew age determinations
• Integration with other isotope systems and geochemical data often necessary

Case studies

• Examination of specific applications of Lu-Hf system in various geological contexts
• Demonstrates versatility and power of Lu-Hf isotope geochemistry

Lu-Hf in igneous petrology

• Lu-Hf isotopes used to trace magma sources and differentiation processes
• Zircon Hf isotopes reveal magma mixing and crustal assimilation
• Allows identification of juvenile vs. reworked crustal components in granitoids
• Helps constrain timing and extent of large igneous province formation
• Useful for understanding arc magmatism and subduction zone processes

Sedimentary provenance analysis

• Detrital zircon Hf isotopes trace sediment sources and transport pathways
• Combination with U-Pb ages provides powerful provenance tool
• Allows reconstruction of paleogeography and tectonic configurations
• Helps identify major crustal formation events in source regions
• Useful for understanding basin evolution and sedimentary recycling

Metamorphic rock dating

• Lu-Hf system applied to date metamorphic events and P-T-t paths
• Garnet Lu-Hf dating provides insights into metamorphic crystallization
• Allows dating of high-grade metamorphic events in lower crust
• Helps constrain rates of metamorphic processes and exhumation
• Useful for understanding tectonic and orogenic processes in deep crust