6.2 U-Pb zircon dating

U-Pb zircon dating is a powerful tool in Isotope Geochemistry for determining precise geological ages. It utilizes the radioactive decay of uranium isotopes to lead, providing crucial insights into Earth's history and geological processes.

This method relies on zircon's unique properties, including its ability to incorporate uranium while excluding lead during formation. The technique involves various analytical approaches, from high-precision mass spectrometry to in-situ microanalysis, each offering distinct advantages for different applications.

Principles of U-Pb dating

• U-Pb dating forms a cornerstone of Isotope Geochemistry allows precise determination of geological ages
• Utilizes the radioactive decay of uranium isotopes to lead provides insights into Earth's history and geological processes

Radioactive decay of uranium

Top images from around the web for Radioactive decay of uranium

• 

  Frontiers | Impact and Correction of Analytical Positioning on Accuracy of Zircon U-Pb Dating by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nuclear Decay and Conservation Laws | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  2.2 Absolute age dating | Digital Atlas of Ancient Life View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Impact and Correction of Analytical Positioning on Accuracy of Zircon U-Pb Dating by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nuclear Decay and Conservation Laws | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Radioactive decay of uranium

• 

  Frontiers | Impact and Correction of Analytical Positioning on Accuracy of Zircon U-Pb Dating by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nuclear Decay and Conservation Laws | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  2.2 Absolute age dating | Digital Atlas of Ancient Life View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Impact and Correction of Analytical Positioning on Accuracy of Zircon U-Pb Dating by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nuclear Decay and Conservation Laws | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Involves decay of 238U to 206Pb and 235U to 207Pb with half-lives of 4.47 billion and 704 million years respectively
• Decay occurs through a series of intermediate daughter isotopes follows exponential decay law
• Ratio of parent to daughter isotopes used to calculate age of the mineral or rock

Zircon crystal structure

• Tetragonal crystal system with chemical formula ZrSiO4
• Incorporates uranium easily during formation excludes lead from its crystal lattice
• Contains trace amounts of uranium (usually 10-1000 ppm) makes it ideal for U-Pb dating
• Strong covalent bonds between zirconium and oxygen atoms contribute to its stability

Closure temperature concept

• Temperature below which radiogenic daughter isotopes are retained within the mineral system
• For zircon U-Pb system closure temperature ~900°C
• Allows dating of crystallization or high-grade metamorphic events
• Concept crucial for interpreting ages in metamorphic terranes or slowly cooled igneous bodies

Zircon as geochronometer

• Zircon serves as a robust and versatile mineral for U-Pb geochronology in Isotope Geochemistry
• Provides precise and accurate ages for various geological events and processes across Earth's history

Zircon formation environments

• Crystallizes in silica-rich magmas (granitic compositions) during late stages of magmatic differentiation
• Forms in high-grade metamorphic rocks (granulites, migmatites) during partial melting or recrystallization
• Occurs as detrital grains in sedimentary rocks derived from erosion of igneous or metamorphic sources
• Can crystallize in pegmatites hydrothermal systems under specific conditions

U and Pb incorporation

• Uranium readily substitutes for zirconium in the crystal structure due to similar ionic radii and charge
• Lead excluded from zircon structure during initial crystallization due to larger ionic radius
• U4+ replaces Zr4+ in the lattice while Pb2+ incompatible in the zircon structure
• Initial Pb content in zircon typically very low allows for precise age determinations

Resistance to weathering

• Extremely durable mineral resistant to physical and chemical weathering processes
• Hardness of 7.5 on Mohs scale contributes to its persistence in sedimentary environments
• High melting point (~1850°C) allows survival through multiple cycles of erosion and redeposition
• Retains its U-Pb isotopic system integrity under most geological conditions preserves age information

U-Pb decay series

• U-Pb decay series fundamental to understanding the principles of radiometric dating in Isotope Geochemistry
• Provides basis for calculating ages and interpreting complex geological histories

238U decay chain

• Starts with 238U ends with stable 206Pb
• Includes 14 intermediate daughter isotopes (thorium, radium, radon, polonium, lead, bismuth)
• Total half-life of 4.47 billion years dominated by the long half-life of 238U
• Key intermediate isotopes include 234U (245,500 years) and 230Th (75,380 years)

235U decay chain

• Begins with 235U terminates at stable 207Pb
• Comprises 11 intermediate daughter isotopes
• Total half-life of 704 million years significantly shorter than 238U decay chain
• Important intermediate isotopes include 231Pa (32,760 years) and 227Ac (21.8 years)

Secular equilibrium

• State where production rate of a daughter isotope equals its decay rate in a closed system
• Reached after approximately 5-7 half-lives of the longest-lived intermediate daughter
• Important for accurate age calculations assumes all intermediate daughters in equilibrium
• Disruption of secular equilibrium can lead to inaccurate age determinations requires careful interpretation

Analytical techniques

• Various analytical methods employed in U-Pb geochronology reflect advancements in Isotope Geochemistry
• Each technique offers unique advantages for different applications and sample types

Isotope dilution mass spectrometry

• High-precision technique involves adding known amount of isotopic spike to sample
• Measures ratios of spiked to unspiked isotopes allows precise determination of element concentrations
• Typically uses thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS) for isotope ratio measurements
• Provides very precise ages (±0.1% or better) requires dissolution of entire zircon grains

Laser ablation ICP-MS

• In-situ technique uses laser to ablate small portions of zircon grains
• Ablated material analyzed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS)
• Allows rapid analysis of multiple grains or different zones within single grains
• Spatial resolution typically 20-50 μm precision generally lower than TIMS (±1-2%)

SHRIMP vs TIMS

• SHRIMP (Sensitive High-Resolution Ion Microprobe) allows in-situ analysis of zircon grains
  • Uses primary ion beam to sputter sample surface
  • Secondary ions analyzed by mass spectrometer
  • Spatial resolution ~20 μm allows analysis of complex zoned zircons
• TIMS (Thermal Ionization Mass Spectrometry) provides highest precision for whole-grain analysis
  • Requires chemical dissolution and separation of U and Pb
  • Analyzes larger sample volumes than SHRIMP
  • Precision typically better than ±0.1% ideal for high-precision geochronology

Data interpretation

• Interpretation of U-Pb data crucial aspect of Isotope Geochemistry requires understanding of various plots and corrections
• Allows geologists to extract meaningful ages and geological histories from complex datasets

Concordia diagram

• Graphical representation of 206Pb/238U vs 207Pb/235U ratios
• Concordia curve represents locus of points where 206Pb/238U and 207Pb/235U ages are equal
• Concordant analyses plot on curve discordant analyses plot off curve
• Upper intercept of discordia line with concordia often interpreted as crystallization age
• Lower intercept may represent Pb loss event or metamorphism

Discordant vs concordant ages

• Concordant ages occur when 206Pb/238U and 207Pb/235U ages agree within analytical uncertainty
  • Indicate closed system behavior reliable age determination
• Discordant ages show disagreement between 206Pb/238U and 207Pb/235U ages
  • Can result from Pb loss metamict damage or inherited cores
  • Require careful interpretation may provide information on multiple geological events

Common Pb correction

• Accounts for non-radiogenic Pb present in sample at time of crystallization
• Methods include:
  • 204Pb correction uses non-radiogenic 204Pb as index of common Pb
  • 207Pb correction assumes all 207Pb excess over radiogenic component due to common Pb
  • 3D isochron method uses multiple analyses to determine initial Pb composition
• Proper correction crucial for accurate age determinations especially in young or low-U samples

Applications in geology

• U-Pb zircon dating widely applied in various geological contexts demonstrates versatility of method in Isotope Geochemistry
• Provides crucial constraints on timing of geological events processes across Earth's history

Igneous rock dating

• Determines crystallization ages of plutonic and volcanic rocks
• Constrains timing of magmatic events magma chamber processes
• Used to date volcanic ash beds provides absolute age control in stratigraphic sequences
• Allows correlation of igneous events across different geological terranes

Detrital zircon studies

• Analyzes zircons in sedimentary rocks to determine provenance and maximum depositional age
• Provides insights into sediment transport pathways paleogeography
• Used to reconstruct tectonic histories of sedimentary basins and orogenic belts
• Helps identify major crustal formation events through peaks in zircon age distributions

Metamorphic event dating

• Dates timing of high-grade metamorphic events through analysis of metamorphic zircon growth
• Constrains pressure-temperature-time (P-T-t) paths of metamorphic rocks
• Helps unravel complex histories of polymetamorphic terranes
• Can date anatexis partial melting events in high-grade metamorphic rocks

Limitations and challenges

• Understanding limitations of U-Pb zircon dating essential for accurate interpretation in Isotope Geochemistry
• Awareness of potential pitfalls allows researchers to design appropriate analytical strategies and interpret data critically

Pb loss

• Occurs when radiogenic Pb diffuses out of zircon crystal lattice
• Can result from thermal events metamictization or fluid interaction
• Leads to apparently younger ages than true crystallization age
• Identified through discordant analyses on concordia diagram
• Mitigated by chemical abrasion techniques or analysis of least damaged grains

Inheritance in zircons

• Presence of older zircon cores within younger overgrowths
• Common in metamorphic rocks or magmas derived from partial melting of older crust
• Results in mixed ages can lead to misinterpretation of crystallization timing
• Identified through careful imaging (cathodoluminescence, BSE) and in-situ microanalysis
• Requires analysis of multiple grains or grain domains to resolve true crystallization age

High-U metamictization

• Accumulation of radiation damage in zircon crystal lattice due to high U content
• Leads to breakdown of crystal structure increased susceptibility to Pb loss
• Can result in discordant analyses unreliable age determinations
• Identified through low totals in electron microprobe analysis or unusual cathodoluminescence patterns
• Mitigated by selecting low-U grains or using chemical abrasion techniques

Recent advances

• Ongoing developments in U-Pb zircon dating techniques reflect continuous innovation in Isotope Geochemistry
• New methods improve precision accuracy and spatial resolution of age determinations

Chemical abrasion techniques

• Involves partial dissolution of zircon grains to remove damaged portions susceptible to Pb loss
• Improves concordance of analyses reduces effects of Pb loss
• CA-TIMS (Chemical Abrasion Thermal Ionization Mass Spectrometry) combines chemical abrasion with high-precision TIMS analysis
• Allows for extremely precise and accurate dating of single zircon grains

In-situ microanalysis methods

• Development of high-resolution in-situ techniques (SHRIMP, LA-ICP-MS)
• Allows analysis of complex zoned zircons with spatial resolution <20 μm
• Enables dating of multiple domains within single grains
• Facilitates rapid analysis of large numbers of grains for detrital zircon studies

Integration with other chronometers

• Combining U-Pb zircon dating with other isotopic systems (Hf, O) in zircon
• Lu-Hf isotopes provide insights into magma sources crustal evolution
• Oxygen isotopes indicate involvement of supracrustal materials in magma genesis
• Integration with other mineral chronometers (monazite, titanite) allows for more comprehensive understanding of geological histories