12.10 Linda Hutcheon

Linda Hutcheon's work explores postmodern literature and art, focusing on how they challenge traditional notions of representation and meaning. She examines key features like parody, historiographic metafiction, and irony, highlighting their role in questioning dominant narratives and ideologies.

Hutcheon's theories illuminate the political dimensions of postmodern aesthetics, showing how techniques like intertextuality and adaptation can subvert power structures. Her insights on postmodern architecture and the impact of her work across various fields have shaped ongoing discussions about art's role in society.

Hutcheon's postmodern poetics

• Examines the key features and techniques of postmodern literature and art
• Focuses on how postmodern works challenge traditional notions of representation, meaning, and reality
• Explores the political and ideological implications of postmodern aesthetics

Parody vs satire

• Distinguishes between parody and satire as two distinct forms of intertextual reference
• Parody involves the imitation and transformation of a prior text or genre, often with humorous or critical intent (Don Quixote, Ulysses)
• Satire targets and critiques social or political issues, using wit and irony to expose and correct perceived wrongs (A Modest Proposal, The Onion)
• Hutcheon argues that postmodern works often blend elements of parody and satire to challenge dominant discourses and ideologies

Historiographic metafiction

• Refers to a type of postmodern novel that self-consciously engages with historical discourse and the process of writing history
• Blends historical fiction with metafictional techniques that draw attention to the constructed nature of the text and the act of narration (Midnight's Children, The French Lieutenant's Woman)
• Challenges the notion of objective historical truth and highlights the role of interpretation and ideology in shaping our understanding of the past

Problematizing historical knowledge

Top images from around the web for Problematizing historical knowledge

• 

  Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using genre to describe the progression of historical thinking in school history textbooks View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Explaining Personality: Learning and Humanistic Approaches | Introduction to Psychology – Lindh View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using genre to describe the progression of historical thinking in school history textbooks View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Problematizing historical knowledge

• 

  Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using genre to describe the progression of historical thinking in school history textbooks View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Explaining Personality: Learning and Humanistic Approaches | Introduction to Psychology – Lindh View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Pragmatism, Critical Theory and Post-structuralism | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Using genre to describe the progression of historical thinking in school history textbooks View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Questions the possibility of accessing and representing the past with accuracy and certainty
• Emphasizes the gaps, contradictions, and silences in historical records and the ways in which power structures shape historical narratives
• Foregrounds the subjectivity and situatedness of the historian or narrator in the process of constructing historical accounts

Self-reflexivity in historical fiction

• Incorporates metafictional elements that draw attention to the artifice and constructedness of the text
• Uses techniques such as unreliable narration, multiple perspectives, and anachronisms to disrupt the illusion of historical authenticity
• Encourages readers to reflect on the process of writing and interpreting history and their own role in making meaning from the text

Irony in postmodern literature

• Examines the central role of irony in postmodern works as a means of questioning and subverting dominant meanings and assumptions
• Argues that postmodern irony is often ambiguous, open-ended, and resistant to stable interpretation
• Distinguishes between different forms and functions of irony in postmodern contexts

Oppositional irony vs reinforcing irony

• Oppositional irony serves to challenge and undermine dominant ideologies, values, or power structures (The Crying of Lot 49)
• Reinforcing irony works to support and perpetuate existing social or cultural norms, often through subtle or implicit means (The Simpsons)
• Hutcheon suggests that the political effects of irony depend on the context and the interpretive strategies of the reader

Politics of postmodern representation

• Explores the political dimensions of postmodern aesthetics and the ways in which postmodern works engage with issues of power, identity, and marginality
• Argues that postmodern techniques such as parody, irony, and metafiction can serve to critique and subvert dominant ideologies and discourses
• Examines how postmodern works give voice to marginalized perspectives and challenge the authority of master narratives

Subverting dominant ideologies

• Uses strategies of appropriation, juxtaposition, and fragmentation to destabilize and denaturalize dominant belief systems and values (Kathy Acker's novels)
• Exposes the contradictions and limitations of totalizing worldviews and binary oppositions (male/female, high/low culture)
• Encourages readers to question the assumptions and power structures that underlie cultural representations and social practices

Marginalized voices and identities

• Foregrounds the experiences and perspectives of groups that have been excluded or silenced by dominant historical and cultural narratives (women, people of color, LGBTQ+ individuals)
• Uses postmodern techniques to challenge essentialist notions of identity and to explore the intersections of race, gender, class, and sexuality (Toni Morrison's Beloved)
• Highlights the ways in which marginalized subjects negotiate, resist, and transform the discourses that shape their lives

Intertextuality and adaptation

• Examines the ways in which postmodern works engage with and transform prior texts, genres, and cultural forms
• Argues that all texts are inherently intertextual, drawing on and responding to a web of cultural codes and conventions
• Explores the creative and critical possibilities of adaptation as a form of intertextual dialogue

Dialogic relationship between texts

• Emphasizes the dynamic and reciprocal nature of intertextual relations, in which texts both shape and are shaped by one another
• Draws on Bakhtin's concept of dialogism to highlight the ways in which texts engage in ongoing conversations and negotiations of meaning (Jean Rhys's Wide Sargasso Sea in relation to Jane Eyre)
• Challenges the notion of originality and the idea of texts as self-contained, autonomous entities

Adaptation as interpretation

• Frames adaptation as a process of creative interpretation and transformation, rather than a simple transfer of content from one medium to another
• Highlights the ways in which adaptations reflect the cultural, historical, and ideological contexts in which they are produced (multiple film adaptations of Shakespeare's plays)
• Argues that adaptations can serve to critique, revise, or reimagine the source text and its meanings

Postmodern architecture

• Applies Hutcheon's theories of postmodern poetics to the field of architecture and the built environment
• Examines how postmodern buildings and spaces challenge modernist principles of form, function, and progress
• Explores the ways in which postmodern architecture engages with history, context, and symbolism

Historicism vs anti-historicism

• Historicist postmodern architecture seeks to engage with and reinterpret historical styles and forms, often through pastiche or ironic juxtaposition (Charles Moore's Piazza d'Italia)
• Anti-historicist postmodern architecture rejects the authority of historical precedent and seeks to create new forms and spaces that break with tradition (Frank Gehry's Guggenheim Museum Bilbao)
• Hutcheon suggests that both approaches reflect a postmodern sensibility that questions the linear progression of architectural history and the possibility of pure originality

Paradox and contradiction

• Postmodern architecture often embraces paradox, contradiction, and ambiguity as generative design principles
• Juxtaposes disparate elements, materials, and styles to create spaces that are multivalent and open to interpretation (Robert Venturi's "decorated shed" concept)
• Challenges the modernist emphasis on clarity, consistency, and functional purity in favor of complexity, diversity, and multiple meanings

Hutcheon's impact on postmodern theory

• Hutcheon's work has been influential in shaping the discourse and debates around postmodernism across various fields, including literature, art, architecture, and cultural studies
• Her theories of parody, irony, and historiographic metafiction have provided key frameworks for analyzing the formal and political strategies of postmodern texts
• Her emphasis on the critical and subversive potential of postmodern aesthetics has contributed to ongoing discussions about the role of art and literature in challenging dominant ideologies and power structures
• Hutcheon's work has also been important in foregrounding the complex relationships between postmodernism, feminism, and postcolonial theory, highlighting the ways in which postmodern techniques can be used to articulate marginalized perspectives and experiences