6.3 Female subjectivity

Female subjectivity challenges traditional male-centered perspectives in literature and culture. It recognizes women's unique experiences, validating their ways of knowing and being that have been historically marginalized.

This concept emerged from feminist literary theory, aiming to address gender inequalities in society and literature. It emphasizes the importance of women's subjective experiences, shaped by factors like race, class, and sexuality, rather than universal notions of womanhood.

Origins of female subjectivity

• Female subjectivity emerged as a critical concept in feminist literary theory during the 1970s and 1980s, challenging traditional notions of the universal, male-centered subject
• The concept of female subjectivity aims to recognize and validate women's unique experiences, perspectives, and ways of knowing, which have historically been marginalized or ignored in literary and cultural discourses
• The development of female subjectivity as a theoretical framework is closely tied to the rise of second-wave feminism and the growing recognition of the need to address gender inequalities in society and in the production and interpretation of literature

Defining female subjectivity

Subjectivity vs objectivity

Top images from around the web for Subjectivity vs objectivity

• 

  Who's That Lady?: Women's Historical Fiction and the Writing of Female Subjectivity - Broadly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Writing: Creating Feminist, gender-sensitive language | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Teaching: overcoming binary narratives | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Who's That Lady?: Women's Historical Fiction and the Writing of Female Subjectivity - Broadly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Writing: Creating Feminist, gender-sensitive language | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Subjectivity vs objectivity

• 

  Who's That Lady?: Women's Historical Fiction and the Writing of Female Subjectivity - Broadly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Writing: Creating Feminist, gender-sensitive language | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Teaching: overcoming binary narratives | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Who's That Lady?: Women's Historical Fiction and the Writing of Female Subjectivity - Broadly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Power of Feminist Writing: Creating Feminist, gender-sensitive language | Heinrich Böll Stiftung View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Subjectivity refers to an individual's personal experiences, feelings, beliefs, and perspectives, which are shaped by their unique social, cultural, and historical context
• Objectivity, in contrast, is the notion of a neutral, impartial, and universally valid perspective, which feminist theorists argue is a myth that often serves to reinforce male-centered norms and values
• Female subjectivity emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and valuing women's subjective experiences and perspectives, rather than dismissing them as irrational, emotional, or inferior to male objectivity

Subjectivity and identity

• Subjectivity is closely linked to the formation and expression of individual and collective identities, as it shapes how people understand themselves and their place in the world
• Female subjectivity recognizes that women's identities are complex, diverse, and often shaped by multiple, intersecting factors such as gender, race, class, sexuality, and culture
• The concept of female subjectivity challenges essentialist notions of a fixed, universal female identity and instead emphasizes the fluidity, multiplicity, and contextual nature of women's identities

Female vs male subjectivity

• Female subjectivity is often contrasted with male subjectivity, which has traditionally been presented as the norm or default perspective in literature and culture
• Male subjectivity is often associated with qualities such as rationality, autonomy, and agency, while female subjectivity has been stereotyped as emotional, passive, and dependent
• Feminist theorists argue that the binary opposition between male and female subjectivity is a social construct that serves to reinforce gender hierarchies and inequalities, and that both male and female subjectivities are diverse, complex, and shaped by multiple factors beyond gender

Feminist perspectives on subjectivity

Liberal feminist views

• Liberal feminism emphasizes the importance of individual rights, equality, and autonomy for women, and argues that women should have the same opportunities as men to develop and express their subjectivity
• Liberal feminist approaches to subjectivity often focus on issues such as access to education, employment, and political representation, and on challenging gender stereotypes and discrimination that limit women's agency and self-determination
• Critics of liberal feminism argue that it does not adequately address systemic and structural inequalities that shape women's experiences and identities, and that it may reinforce individualistic and male-centered norms of subjectivity

Radical feminist views

• Radical feminism views patriarchy as the root cause of women's oppression and argues that the construction of female subjectivity is fundamentally shaped by male domination and violence
• Radical feminist approaches to subjectivity often emphasize the need for women to create separate, autonomous spaces and cultures that allow them to develop and express their own subjectivities, free from male influence and control
• Radical feminists also highlight the importance of the body and sexuality in shaping female subjectivity, and argue that women's experiences of embodiment, desire, and pleasure are often repressed or controlled by patriarchal norms and institutions

Postmodern feminist views

• Postmodern feminism challenges the notion of a fixed, essential female subjectivity and instead emphasizes the fluid, fragmented, and socially constructed nature of identity and experience
• Postmodern feminist approaches to subjectivity often draw on theories of language, discourse, and power to analyze how women's identities and experiences are shaped by cultural and historical contexts, and how they can be resisted or transformed through practices of self-representation and self-creation
• Postmodern feminists also highlight the intersectional nature of female subjectivity, arguing that women's experiences and identities are shaped by multiple, overlapping factors such as race, class, sexuality, and nationality, and cannot be reduced to a single, universal category of "woman"

Subjectivity in literature by women

19th century female authors

• 19th century female authors such as Jane Austen, Charlotte Brontë, and George Eliot challenged traditional notions of female subjectivity by creating complex, nuanced female characters who asserted their agency and desire in the face of social and cultural constraints
• These authors often used the novel form to explore the interior lives and subjective experiences of women, and to critique the gender norms and expectations that limited women's opportunities and self-expression
• 19th century female authors also experimented with narrative techniques such as free indirect discourse and multiple perspectives to represent the complexity and diversity of female subjectivity

20th century female authors

• 20th century female authors such as Virginia Woolf, Zora Neale Hurston, and Simone de Beauvoir further pushed the boundaries of representing female subjectivity in literature, often using experimental forms and techniques to capture the fluid, fragmented, and socially constructed nature of identity and experience
• These authors often explored themes of gender, sexuality, race, and class in their work, and used literature as a means of challenging dominant cultural narratives and creating new spaces for female self-expression and solidarity
• 20th century female authors also increasingly engaged with feminist theory and politics in their writing, using literature as a tool for consciousness-raising, activism, and social change

Contemporary female authors

• Contemporary female authors such as Toni Morrison, Margaret Atwood, and Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie continue to explore and expand the possibilities of representing female subjectivity in literature, often using postmodern, postcolonial, and intersectional approaches to identity and experience
• These authors often engage with issues such as globalization, migration, technology, and environmental crisis in their work, and use literature to imagine new forms of female agency, resistance, and solidarity in the face of complex social and political challenges
• Contemporary female authors also often experiment with genre, form, and media in their writing, using techniques such as magical realism, speculative fiction, and digital storytelling to create new spaces for female subjectivity and expression

Representing female subjectivity in texts

Narrative techniques

• Narrative techniques such as point of view, voice, and focalization can be used to represent female subjectivity in texts, often by privileging women's perspectives, experiences, and ways of knowing
• For example, the use of first-person narration or free indirect discourse can allow readers to access the interior thoughts, feelings, and perceptions of female characters, and to understand their subjective experiences of the world
• Narrative techniques can also be used to challenge or subvert traditional gender norms and expectations, for example by using unreliable narrators or multiple perspectives to destabilize dominant cultural narratives and create space for alternative female subjectivities

Poetic techniques

• Poetic techniques such as imagery, metaphor, and symbolism can be used to represent female subjectivity in texts, often by evoking the sensory, emotional, and embodied aspects of women's experiences
• For example, the use of nature imagery or bodily metaphors can allow poets to explore the intimate, visceral, and often taboo aspects of female subjectivity, such as sexuality, reproduction, and aging
• Poetic techniques can also be used to challenge or subvert traditional gender norms and expectations, for example by using irony, parody, or juxtaposition to critique the objectification or idealization of women in literature and culture

Dramatic techniques

• Dramatic techniques such as dialogue, monologue, and staging can be used to represent female subjectivity in texts, often by privileging women's voices, actions, and interactions with others
• For example, the use of extended monologues or soliloquies can allow female characters to express their innermost thoughts, feelings, and desires, and to assert their agency and subjectivity in the face of social and cultural constraints
• Dramatic techniques can also be used to challenge or subvert traditional gender norms and expectations, for example by using cross-gender casting, non-linear storytelling, or audience participation to create new spaces for female subjectivity and expression

Intersectionality and female subjectivity

Race and subjectivity

• Intersectionality theory highlights the ways in which race intersects with gender to shape women's experiences and identities, and argues that female subjectivity cannot be understood or represented without attending to the specific histories, cultures, and politics of women of color
• For example, Black feminist theorists such as Kimberlé Crenshaw and Patricia Hill Collins have argued that the experiences and perspectives of Black women are often marginalized or erased in both feminist and anti-racist discourses, and that a specifically Black female subjectivity needs to be recognized and valued
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture must grapple with the complex, often painful histories of racism, colonialism, and oppression that have shaped the lives and identities of women of color, and with the ongoing struggles for racial justice and liberation

Class and subjectivity

• Class is another key factor that intersects with gender to shape women's experiences and identities, and feminist theorists have long argued that female subjectivity is deeply influenced by economic and social inequalities
• For example, Marxist feminist theorists such as Silvia Federici and Angela Davis have argued that the experiences and perspectives of working-class and poor women are often marginalized or erased in both feminist and leftist discourses, and that a specifically class-based female subjectivity needs to be recognized and valued
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture must grapple with the complex, often painful histories of labor exploitation, poverty, and social exclusion that have shaped the lives and identities of working-class and poor women, and with the ongoing struggles for economic justice and liberation

Sexuality and subjectivity

• Sexuality is another key factor that intersects with gender to shape women's experiences and identities, and feminist theorists have long argued that female subjectivity is deeply influenced by sexual norms, practices, and politics
• For example, lesbian feminist theorists such as Adrienne Rich and Audre Lorde have argued that the experiences and perspectives of lesbian and queer women are often marginalized or erased in both feminist and LGBTQ+ discourses, and that a specifically lesbian or queer female subjectivity needs to be recognized and valued
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture must grapple with the complex, often painful histories of sexual oppression, violence, and stigma that have shaped the lives and identities of lesbian and queer women, and with the ongoing struggles for sexual liberation and justice

Critiques of female subjectivity

Essentialist critiques

• Essentialist critiques of female subjectivity argue that the concept relies on a fixed, universal notion of womanhood or femininity that does not account for the diversity and complexity of women's experiences and identities
• For example, some feminist theorists have argued that the idea of a specifically female subjectivity may reinforce gender stereotypes and binaries, and may exclude or marginalize women who do not conform to dominant cultural norms of femininity
• Essentialist critiques call for a more nuanced, context-specific understanding of female subjectivity that recognizes the multiple, intersecting factors that shape women's lives and identities, and that resists the temptation to reduce womanhood to a single, essential essence

Poststructuralist critiques

• Poststructuralist critiques of female subjectivity argue that the concept relies on a humanist, individualist notion of the self that does not account for the ways in which subjectivity is constructed through language, discourse, and power relations
• For example, poststructuralist feminist theorists such as Judith Butler and Hélène Cixous have argued that the idea of a coherent, autonomous female subject is a fiction produced through the regulatory norms and practices of gender, and that female subjectivity is always already shaped by the cultural and historical contexts in which it emerges
• Poststructuralist critiques call for a more deconstructive, anti-essentialist approach to female subjectivity that attends to the ways in which women's experiences and identities are mediated by language, representation, and power, and that resists the temptation to posit a fixed, stable notion of the female self

Materialist critiques

• Materialist critiques of female subjectivity argue that the concept often neglects the material, economic, and institutional conditions that shape women's lives and identities, and that a focus on individual subjectivity may obscure the structural inequalities and oppressive systems that constrain women's agency and self-determination
• For example, Marxist and socialist feminist theorists have argued that the idea of female subjectivity must be grounded in an analysis of the gendered division of labor, the exploitation of women's reproductive and domestic work, and the role of capitalism in shaping women's experiences and identities
• Materialist critiques call for a more historically and materially grounded approach to female subjectivity that attends to the ways in which women's experiences and identities are shaped by the economic, political, and social structures of power, and that resists the temptation to reduce subjectivity to a purely psychological or individual phenomenon

Female subjectivity and agency

Subjectivity and resistance

• The concept of female subjectivity is often linked to the idea of resistance, or the ways in which women can assert their agency and challenge the oppressive norms and structures that shape their lives and identities
• For example, feminist theorists such as bell hooks and Gloria Anzaldúa have argued that the development of a critical, oppositional female subjectivity is crucial for resisting the multiple forms of oppression that women face, and for imagining and creating alternative ways of being and knowing
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture can serve as a form of resistance by giving voice to women's experiences and perspectives, by challenging dominant cultural narratives and stereotypes, and by imagining new possibilities for female agency and empowerment

Subjectivity and empowerment

• The concept of female subjectivity is also often linked to the idea of empowerment, or the ways in which women can develop a sense of self-worth, autonomy, and control over their lives and identities
• For example, feminist theorists such as Carol Gilligan and Nel Noddings have argued that the development of a relational, care-based female subjectivity is crucial for empowering women to resist the individualistic, competitive values of patriarchal culture, and to create more nurturing, collaborative ways of being and knowing
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture can serve as a form of empowerment by affirming women's experiences and perspectives, by celebrating women's strengths and achievements, and by providing models and resources for women's personal and collective growth and development

Subjectivity and social change

• The concept of female subjectivity is also often linked to the idea of social change, or the ways in which women's individual and collective struggles for self-determination can contribute to broader movements for social justice and liberation
• For example, feminist theorists such as Audre Lorde and Chandra Talpade Mohanty have argued that the development of a intersectional, transnational female subjectivity is crucial for building solidarity across differences of race, class, sexuality, and nationality, and for challenging the global systems of oppression that shape women's lives and identities
• Representations of female subjectivity in literature and culture can serve as a form of social change by raising awareness about women's issues and struggles, by inspiring and mobilizing women to take action for their rights and freedoms, and by envisioning and enacting more just, equitable, and liberatory futures for all