7.7 Edward Said

Edward Said's concept of Orientalism examines how the West has historically represented and constructed the East. This influential theory explores the power dynamics inherent in Western portrayals of Eastern cultures, highlighting stereotypes and misrepresentations that reinforce Western superiority.

Said argues that Orientalism functions as a discourse deeply embedded in Western culture, shaping perceptions of the East. This system of knowledge and power has profound implications for literature, politics, and academia, influencing how the West interacts with and understands Eastern societies and peoples.

Orientalism and Western representations

• Orientalism is a critical concept developed by Edward Said that examines the ways in which the Western world has historically represented and constructed the "Orient" or the East
• Said argues that Orientalism is a discourse, a system of knowledge and power that shapes how the West perceives and interacts with the East
• Orientalism is deeply embedded in Western culture, politics, and academia, influencing how the East is portrayed and understood

Orientalism as a discourse

Top images from around the web for Orientalism as a discourse

• 

  Orientalism: Edward Said's Postcolonial Thoughts and Theories Against the Eastern World and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : อีกมุมมองเรื่อง Orientalism : Orientalism is everywhere. Here's what Edward Said ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalism: Edward Said's Postcolonial Thoughts and Theories Against the Eastern World and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Orientalism as a discourse

• 

  Orientalism: Edward Said's Postcolonial Thoughts and Theories Against the Eastern World and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Thai E-News : อีกมุมมองเรื่อง Orientalism : Orientalism is everywhere. Here's what Edward Said ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalism: Edward Said's Postcolonial Thoughts and Theories Against the Eastern World and ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Orientalismo: O Oriente como invenção do Ocidente – Edward W. Said - Vida Indigital View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Orientalism functions as a discourse, a way of thinking, writing, and speaking about the East that is rooted in Western culture and ideology
• This discourse is not neutral or objective but rather reflects the power dynamics and interests of the West
• Orientalist discourse often relies on binary oppositions (civilized/barbaric, rational/irrational) that reinforce Western superiority and Eastern inferiority
• Orientalism is perpetuated through various forms of cultural production, including literature, art, media, and academic scholarship

Stereotypes and misrepresentations

• Orientalist discourse often relies on stereotypes and misrepresentations of Eastern cultures, peoples, and religions
• The East is frequently portrayed as exotic, mysterious, sensual, and dangerous, reflecting Western fantasies and anxieties
• Eastern societies are often depicted as static, timeless, and resistant to change, in contrast to the dynamic and progressive West
• These stereotypes and misrepresentations serve to justify Western domination and intervention in the East

East vs West dichotomy

• Orientalism is built upon a fundamental dichotomy between the East and the West, which are seen as inherently different and opposed
• The West is associated with rationality, progress, and modernity, while the East is linked to irrationality, stagnation, and tradition
• This dichotomy is not based on reality but rather on Western perceptions and constructions of the East
• The East vs West dichotomy reinforces Western hegemony and justifies colonial and imperial projects in the name of "civilizing" the East

Power dynamics in Orientalism

• Orientalism is not simply a matter of representation but also a system of power relations between the West and the East
• The production of knowledge about the East is intimately connected to the exercise of power over the East
• Orientalism serves to legitimize and perpetuate Western dominance and control over Eastern societies and peoples

Knowledge and power

• Orientalism demonstrates the close relationship between knowledge and power in the Western world
• The production of knowledge about the East is not neutral or objective but rather shaped by Western interests and agendas
• Western scholars, writers, and artists who engage in Orientalist discourse often claim authority and expertise over the East, even if they have limited or no direct experience with Eastern cultures
• This knowledge is used to justify Western intervention and domination in the East, as well as to shape Western public opinion and policy towards the East

Cultural hegemony

• Orientalism is a form of cultural hegemony, the dominance of one culture over another through the production and dissemination of ideas and values
• Western cultural hegemony is exercised through various forms of cultural production, including literature, art, media, and academia
• Orientalist discourse becomes naturalized and internalized, shaping how both Westerners and Easterners perceive and understand the East
• Cultural hegemony serves to maintain and reproduce Western power and dominance over the East

Colonialism and imperialism

• Orientalism is closely tied to the history of Western colonialism and imperialism in the East
• Orientalist discourse provided a justification for Western colonial and imperial projects, which were often framed as a "civilizing mission" to bring progress and modernity to the East
• Colonial administrators, scholars, and writers produced a vast body of Orientalist knowledge that served to legitimize and facilitate Western control over Eastern territories and peoples
• The legacy of colonialism and imperialism continues to shape contemporary power relations between the West and the East, as well as the ongoing production of Orientalist discourse

Impact on literature and culture

• Orientalism has had a profound impact on Western literature and culture, shaping how the East is represented and imagined
• Western writers, artists, and intellectuals have long been fascinated by the East, producing a vast body of Orientalist works that reflect and reinforce Western perceptions and fantasies
• Orientalist literature and culture have played a key role in shaping Western attitudes towards the East, as well as in justifying and facilitating Western domination and control

Representation in Western literature

• Western literature has a long history of representing the East through an Orientalist lens, often relying on stereotypes and misrepresentations
• Examples of Orientalist literature include the Arabian Nights, the works of Rudyard Kipling, and the novels of E.M. Forster
• These works often depict the East as exotic, sensual, and dangerous, reflecting Western fantasies and anxieties about the East
• Orientalist literature has played a key role in shaping Western perceptions of the East, as well as in reinforcing Western cultural hegemony

Influence on postcolonial studies

• Said's critique of Orientalism has had a significant influence on the development of postcolonial studies, which examines the cultural, political, and economic legacies of colonialism and imperialism
• Postcolonial scholars have built upon Said's insights to analyze the ways in which Western representations of the East have shaped and justified colonial and imperial projects
• Postcolonial studies also examine the ways in which Eastern writers and intellectuals have responded to and challenged Orientalist discourse
• Said's work has inspired a new generation of scholars to critically examine the power dynamics and cultural politics of representation

Challenging Orientalist narratives

• Said's critique of Orientalism has inspired efforts to challenge and subvert Orientalist narratives in literature, art, and popular culture
• Postcolonial writers and artists have sought to reclaim and rewrite the history and culture of the East, challenging Western stereotypes and misrepresentations
• Examples include the works of Salman Rushdie, Arundhati Roy, and Mohsin Hamid, which offer alternative perspectives on the East and its relationship to the West
• These efforts to challenge Orientalist narratives have played a key role in decolonizing Western knowledge and culture, as well as in promoting cross-cultural understanding and dialogue

Said's critical reception

• Said's Orientalism has had a profound impact on literary theory and criticism, as well as on a range of other disciplines, including history, anthropology, and political science
• The book has been widely praised for its groundbreaking analysis of the relationship between knowledge and power, as well as for its critique of Western cultural hegemony
• However, the book has also been the subject of significant criticism and controversy, with some scholars questioning its methodology, evidence, and conclusions

Influence on literary theory

• Orientalism has had a significant influence on the development of literary theory, particularly in the fields of postcolonial studies and cultural studies
• Said's critique of the relationship between knowledge and power has inspired a new generation of scholars to examine the politics of representation in literature and culture
• The book has also contributed to the development of new theoretical frameworks, such as postcolonial theory and subaltern studies, which seek to challenge Western cultural hegemony and give voice to marginalized perspectives
• Said's work has played a key role in shaping contemporary debates about the role of literature and culture in reproducing or challenging power relations

Critiques and controversies

• Despite its significant influence, Orientalism has also been the subject of significant criticism and controversy
• Some scholars have questioned Said's methodology, arguing that he relies too heavily on literary sources and neglects the complexity and diversity of Western scholarship on the East
• Others have criticized Said for essentializing the West and the East, and for failing to account for the agency and resistance of Eastern peoples
• Some critics have also accused Said of promoting a form of reverse Orientalism, in which the West is demonized and the East is idealized
• These critiques have led to ongoing debates about the validity and limitations of Said's arguments, as well as about the broader politics of representation and cultural difference

Legacy and continued relevance

• Despite these critiques and controversies, Orientalism remains a seminal work in the field of literary theory and criticism, as well as in the broader study of culture and power
• The book has had a lasting impact on the way scholars and students approach the study of literature and culture, particularly in relation to issues of representation, identity, and difference
• Said's insights continue to be relevant in the contemporary world, as issues of cultural hegemony, racism, and imperialism remain pressing concerns
• The legacy of Orientalism can be seen in ongoing debates about the politics of representation, the role of the intellectual, and the relationship between knowledge and power
• As such, Said's work continues to inspire and challenge scholars, activists, and readers to critically examine the cultural and political dimensions of literature and culture