3.2 Hernán Cortés's Letters from Mexico

Hernán Cortés's Letters from Mexico offer a firsthand account of the Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire. These writings detail Cortés's arrival in Mexico, his march to Tenochtitlan, and the eventual fall of the Aztec capital.

The letters provide insight into Cortés's portrayal of Aztec society and his self-representation as a loyal servant to the Spanish Crown. They employ various strategies to justify the conquest and have significantly influenced the colonial narrative and perceptions of the Americas.

Cortés's Letters from Mexico: Content and Context

Main events of Cortés's conquests

Top images from around the web for Main events of Cortés's conquests

• 

  Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fall of Tenochtitlan - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chute de l'Empire aztèque — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fall of Tenochtitlan - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Main events of Cortés's conquests

• 

  Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fall of Tenochtitlan - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chute de l'Empire aztèque — Wikipédia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fall of Tenochtitlan - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Arrival and initial encounters
  • Landed at Veracruz in 1519 established first Spanish settlement on mainland
  • Interacted with indigenous peoples gathered information about Aztec Empire
• March to Tenochtitlan
  • Formed alliances with Tlaxcalans and other groups opposed to Aztec rule
  • Fought battles with Cholula and other cities demonstrated Spanish military superiority
• Encounter with Montezuma II
  • Received peacefully in Tenochtitlan initially marveled at city's grandeur
  • Captured and imprisoned Montezuma used as puppet ruler to control Aztecs
• La Noche Triste (The Night of Sorrows)
  • Forced to flee Tenochtitlan after Aztec uprising against Spanish occupation
  • Suffered significant losses many Spanish soldiers and indigenous allies killed
• Siege and fall of Tenochtitlan
  • Regrouped and reinforced Spanish forces with more men and resources
  • Launched final assault captured Aztec capital in 1521 ended Aztec Empire

Portrayal of Aztecs and self

• Depiction of Aztec society
  • Highlighted architectural and urban achievements (pyramids, causeways)
  • Described religious practices often negatively (human sacrifice, polytheism)
  • Portrayed complex political structure and formidable military might
• Cortés's self-representation
  • Positioned himself as loyal servant to Spanish Crown justified actions
  • Emphasized diplomatic and military skills portrayed self as capable leader
  • Justified actions through claims of spreading Christianity civilizing mission
• Contrasts between Aztec and Spanish cultures
  • Emphasized technological superiority (guns, horses)
  • Highlighted differences in religious beliefs and practices (monotheism vs polytheism)
  • Compared political and social organization centralized monarchy vs city-states
• Reliability of Cortés's account
  • Showed potential biases and exaggerations glorified Spanish achievements
  • Contained omissions and selective reporting downplayed Spanish atrocities

Strategies and Significance of Cortés's Letters

Strategies in Cortés's letters

• Rhetorical techniques
  • Used vivid descriptions engaged readers with detailed accounts of Aztec civilization
  • Appealed to authority invoked Spanish Crown and Christian faith to legitimize actions
  • Strategically omitted or downplayed controversial actions (massacres, looting)
• Legal and moral justifications
  • Emphasized spreading Christianity portrayed conquest as religious mission
  • Depicted Aztecs as heathens in need of salvation justified Spanish intervention
  • Claimed to act in interests of Spanish Crown expanded empire and wealth
• Political maneuvering
  • Legitimized actions and position sought royal approval for conquest
  • Undermined potential rivals or critics presented self as sole capable leader
  • Sought royal favor and support requested resources and reinforcements
• Military strategies
  • Provided detailed accounts of battles and conquests demonstrated tactical prowess
  • Emphasized tactical decisions and leadership justified military actions
  • Explained alliances with indigenous groups as strategic necessity

Impact on colonial narrative

• Influenced European perceptions of Americas
  • Created lasting images of Aztec civilization (wealth, sophistication, barbarism)
  • Fueled interest in further exploration and conquest inspired other conquistadors
• Justified Spanish colonization
  • Provided template for future conquistadors established precedents for conquest
  • Established precedents for treatment of indigenous peoples (encomienda system)
• Impacted historical understanding
  • Served as primary source for early colonial history shaped historical narratives
  • Influenced subsequent historical interpretations debates on colonialism
• Literary and cultural significance
  • Contributed to genre of conquest literature inspired later works
  • Influenced artistic and literary depictions of conquest (paintings, novels)
• Legacy in Mexican and Latin American history
  • Shaped national myths and identities complex figure in Mexican history
  • Sparked ongoing debates about colonialism and its impacts on indigenous peoples