6.2 Common Sense by Thomas Paine

Thomas Paine's "Common Sense" was a groundbreaking pamphlet that ignited the American Revolution. Published in 1776, it used plain language to argue for independence from Britain, making complex political ideas accessible to the masses.

Paine's work revolutionized political discourse and set a new standard for impactful journalism. Its success demonstrated how powerful, accessible writing could shape public opinion and catalyze social change during times of political upheaval.

Historical context

• Common Sense emerged as a pivotal text in the American literary and journalistic landscape during a time of political upheaval
• The pamphlet exemplifies how literature can shape public opinion and catalyze social change
• Paine's work demonstrates the power of accessible writing in disseminating complex political ideas to a broad audience

Colonial America in 1776

Top images from around the web for Colonial America in 1776

• 

  Common Sense - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Common Sense - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Colonial America in 1776

• 

  Common Sense - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Common Sense - Wikisource, the free online library View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Thirteen British colonies populated by approximately 2.5 million people
• Growing tensions with Britain over taxation and representation (Stamp Act, Tea Act)
• Emerging sense of distinct American identity separate from British rule
• Economic disparities between colonies and social stratification within colonial society
• Increasing literacy rates among colonists, enabling wider dissemination of political ideas

Political climate pre-revolution

• First Continental Congress convened in 1774 to address British policies
• Formation of militias and stockpiling of weapons in anticipation of conflict
• Divided loyalties among colonists (Patriots, Loyalists, and neutrals)
• Outbreak of armed conflict at Lexington and Concord in April 1775
• Second Continental Congress managing colonial war effort and debating independence

Enlightenment influence

• Emphasis on reason, individual rights, and questioning traditional authority
• John Locke's concepts of natural rights and social contract theory
• Montesquieu's ideas on separation of powers in government
• Voltaire's advocacy for religious tolerance and freedom of speech
• American thinkers like Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson incorporating Enlightenment principles

Key arguments

• Common Sense presented a compelling case for American independence through logical reasoning
• The pamphlet's arguments reflect the evolving nature of political discourse in journalism
• Paine's work exemplifies how writers can use rhetoric to sway public opinion on crucial issues

Monarchy vs independence

• Critiques hereditary succession as unnatural and prone to corruption
• Argues that monarchy contradicts principles of equality among men
• Presents independence as aligned with God's will and natural order
• Challenges the notion of Britain as a "parent country" to the colonies
• Proposes a representative democracy as a superior form of government

British oppression critique

• Details economic exploitation through unfair taxation and trade restrictions
• Highlights lack of colonial representation in British Parliament ("taxation without representation")
• Exposes brutality of British military actions against colonists
• Argues that reconciliation with Britain would lead to continued oppression
• Demonstrates how distance between Britain and America makes effective governance impossible

Call for American autonomy

• Advocates for immediate declaration of independence from Britain
• Proposes a united American government with elected representatives
• Suggests a continental charter to protect individual rights and liberties
• Outlines potential for America to become a beacon of freedom for the world
• Emphasizes the urgency of action to seize the opportune moment for independence

Writing style and structure

• Paine's approach to writing Common Sense revolutionized political discourse
• The pamphlet's style influenced future journalistic writing on complex topics
• Common Sense demonstrates effective techniques for engaging a broad readership

Pamphlet format

• Concise, easily reproducible format for mass distribution
• Divided into four main sections for organized presentation of arguments
• Included an introduction explaining the author's intent and anonymity
• Affordable pricing (two shillings) to ensure widespread accessibility
• Designed for quick reading and easy comprehension by diverse audiences

Plain language approach

• Avoided complex philosophical jargon in favor of everyday language
• Used simple analogies and examples to explain abstract concepts
• Employed short, direct sentences to maintain reader engagement
• Incorporated rhetorical questions to prompt critical thinking
• Balanced emotional appeals with logical arguments for maximum impact

Rhetorical devices

• Employed ethos, pathos, and logos to strengthen persuasive power
• Used repetition of key phrases to reinforce central ideas
• Incorporated biblical references to appeal to religious sensibilities
• Utilized sarcasm and irony to mock opposing viewpoints
• Created vivid imagery to evoke emotional responses from readers

Impact and reception

• Common Sense had an unprecedented influence on public opinion and political action
• The pamphlet's success demonstrated the power of accessible political writing
• Paine's work set a new standard for impactful journalism in times of social change

Initial public response

• Sold an estimated 120,000 copies within first three months of publication
• Sparked widespread debate and discussion in taverns, homes, and public spaces
• Received endorsements from influential figures like Benjamin Franklin
• Faced criticism from Loyalists and some moderate Patriots as too radical
• Translated into multiple languages for distribution beyond the colonies

Influence on revolution

• Shifted public opinion towards favoring independence from Britain
• Provided intellectual ammunition for pro-independence arguments in Congress
• Inspired many colonists to join the Continental Army and support the war effort
• Influenced the language and ideas in the Declaration of Independence
• Boosted morale among revolutionaries during early stages of the conflict

Long-term historical significance

• Established a model for future political pamphlets and opinion pieces
• Contributed to the development of American political identity and values
• Inspired revolutionary movements in other parts of the world (France, Latin America)
• Continues to be studied as a seminal work in American political literature
• Demonstrates the enduring power of persuasive writing in shaping history

Themes and ideas

• Common Sense articulated key philosophical concepts that shaped American ideology
• The pamphlet's themes continue to resonate in contemporary political discourse
• Paine's ideas exemplify how journalism can introduce and popularize complex concepts

Natural rights

• Asserts that all individuals possess inherent, inalienable rights
• Argues that governments should protect, not infringe upon, these rights
• Connects natural rights to the concept of equality among all people
• Challenges divine right of kings as a violation of natural law
• Influences later documents like the Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights

Self-governance

• Promotes the idea that people have the right to choose their own government
• Argues for a representative system based on the consent of the governed
• Emphasizes the importance of civic participation in political decision-making
• Critiques the arbitrary nature of hereditary rule and aristocracy
• Envisions a society where laws are created by and for the people

Religious freedom

• Advocates for separation of church and state in governance
• Challenges the notion of divinely ordained monarchs and religious authority in politics
• Argues for tolerance of diverse religious beliefs within society
• Uses biblical references to support arguments while maintaining secular reasoning
• Proposes a society where individuals can practice their faith without government interference

Literary analysis

• Common Sense exemplifies effective use of literary techniques in political writing
• The pamphlet's stylistic elements contribute to its persuasive power and readability
• Paine's approach influenced future journalists in crafting compelling opinion pieces

Metaphors and symbolism

• Uses the metaphor of a ship to represent government and society
• Employs the symbol of the crown to critique monarchy and hereditary rule
• Compares Britain to a parent and America to a child to challenge colonial relationship
• Utilizes natural imagery (trees, roots) to illustrate concepts of growth and independence
• Invokes biblical symbolism to appeal to religious readers and add moral weight

Tone and voice

• Adopts a conversational yet authoritative tone to engage readers
• Balances passionate rhetoric with logical argumentation
• Employs a sense of urgency to convey the importance of immediate action
• Uses first-person plural ("we") to create a sense of shared identity with readers
• Incorporates occasional humor and sarcasm to maintain reader interest

Persuasive techniques

• Builds arguments through a logical progression of ideas
• Anticipates and addresses potential counterarguments
• Uses emotional appeals to evoke patriotic sentiment and moral indignation
• Employs repetition of key phrases to reinforce central messages
• Balances abstract principles with concrete examples for clarity

Paine's background

• Thomas Paine's life experiences shaped his political philosophy and writing style
• Understanding Paine's background provides context for his approach to journalism
• His work exemplifies how personal experiences can inform and enrich political writing

Early life and influences

• Born in 1737 in Thetford, England to a Quaker father and Anglican mother
• Received basic education and apprenticed as a corset maker in his youth
• Worked various jobs including tax collector, providing insight into government operations
• Experienced personal and financial hardships, informing his views on social inequality
• Influenced by Enlightenment thinkers and discussions in London coffeehouses

Political philosophy

• Developed strong belief in individual rights and opposition to hereditary privilege
• Advocated for democratic governance and representation of the common people
• Embraced rationalism and rejected traditional religious dogma in politics
• Supported social welfare programs and economic reforms to benefit the working class
• Believed in the power of reason and education to improve society

Other notable works

• The American Crisis series (1776-1783) supporting the revolutionary war effort
• Rights of Man (1791) defending the French Revolution and outlining human rights
• The Age of Reason (1793-1794) critiquing organized religion and promoting deism
• Agrarian Justice (1797) proposing early concepts of social security and land reform
• Various essays and letters addressing issues like slavery and women's rights

Criticism and controversy

• Common Sense faced significant opposition and sparked intense debate
• The pamphlet's reception illustrates the polarizing nature of revolutionary ideas
• Criticism of Paine's work demonstrates the challenges faced by political writers

Loyalist opposition

• Accused Paine of inciting rebellion and treason against the British Crown
• Criticized the pamphlet's arguments as oversimplified and idealistic
• Challenged Paine's credibility as a recent immigrant to the colonies
• Produced counter-pamphlets defending British rule and monarchy
• Warned of potential chaos and economic ruin resulting from independence

Religious objections

• Some clergy opposed Paine's use of biblical references to support political arguments
• Critics accused Paine of promoting secularism and undermining religious authority
• Conservative religious groups objected to Paine's later deist writings in The Age of Reason
• Debates arose over the role of religion in governance and public life
• Some argued that Paine's ideas contradicted traditional Christian values

Modern interpretations

• Scholars debate Paine's originality versus his synthesis of existing ideas
• Some criticize Paine's oversimplification of complex political and economic issues
• Discussions on the relevance of Paine's ideas in contemporary global politics
• Debates over Paine's legacy and his place in the pantheon of Founding Fathers
• Analysis of Common Sense's influence on modern concepts of democracy and human rights

Legacy in journalism

• Common Sense established a precedent for impactful political writing in America
• Paine's work influenced the development of opinion journalism and editorial writing
• The pamphlet's success demonstrates the power of accessible writing in shaping public discourse

Pamphlet tradition

• Popularized the use of pamphlets as a medium for political discourse
• Inspired future pamphleteers to address social and political issues
• Contributed to the rise of print culture in early American society
• Demonstrated the effectiveness of mass-produced, affordable publications
• Influenced the development of newspapers and periodicals in the new nation

Political writing evolution

• Shifted political discourse from elite circles to the general public
• Established a model for clear, persuasive argumentation in political writing
• Influenced the style of future political essays and manifestos
• Contributed to the development of American political rhetoric
• Set a standard for combining emotional appeal with logical reasoning

Influence on opinion journalism

• Shaped the role of the journalist as a commentator on public affairs
• Inspired future generations of political columnists and editorial writers
• Contributed to the tradition of using journalism to advocate for social change
• Influenced the development of investigative journalism and muckraking
• Demonstrated the power of the written word in mobilizing public opinion