3.3 Limitations and criticisms of national accounting

National income accounting has its flaws. While GDP is a key economic indicator, it doesn't tell the whole story of a nation's well-being. It misses things like income inequality, environmental costs, and unpaid work.

That's why economists have developed alternative measures. The Human Development Index and Genuine Progress Indicator try to paint a fuller picture by factoring in health, education, and sustainability. These tools help us understand the true state of a country's economic welfare.

GDP as a measure of well-being

Limitations in income distribution and quality of goods

Top images from around the web for Limitations in income distribution and quality of goods

• 

  Income Inequality and the Decline of the Middle Class in Two Charts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global Economic Inequality - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Incomes across the Distribution - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality and the Decline of the Middle Class in Two Charts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global Economic Inequality - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Limitations in income distribution and quality of goods

• 

  Income Inequality and the Decline of the Middle Class in Two Charts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global Economic Inequality - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Incomes across the Distribution - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality and the Decline of the Middle Class in Two Charts View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global Economic Inequality - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• GDP does not account for the distribution of income within a country, which can lead to a misrepresentation of the overall economic well-being of the population
  • High levels of income inequality can persist even with a growing GDP (United States)
  • A small wealthy class can skew GDP upward, masking the economic struggles of the majority
• GDP does not consider the quality of goods and services produced, only their market value, which may not accurately reflect the true value or utility to society
  • Increased production of low-quality, disposable goods can inflate GDP without improving well-being
  • High-quality, durable goods may have a lower impact on GDP but provide greater long-term value

Exclusion of externalities and non-market activities

• GDP does not account for negative externalities, such as pollution or environmental degradation, which can have a detrimental impact on economic well-being
  • Industrial growth can boost GDP while causing air and water pollution that harms health (China)
  • Deforestation driven by economic activities can lead to biodiversity loss and ecosystem disruption
• GDP does not capture non-market activities, such as household production, volunteer work, or the informal economy, which can contribute significantly to economic well-being
  • Unpaid caregiving and domestic work, often performed by women, are not included in GDP calculations
  • Volunteer work in community organizations and charities is not reflected in GDP (Habitat for Humanity)

Sustainability and resource depletion

• GDP does not account for the depletion of natural resources, which can lead to an overestimation of economic growth and well-being in the long run
  • Rapid extraction of finite resources like oil and minerals can boost GDP in the short term but lead to future scarcity
  • Overfishing can increase GDP temporarily but result in the collapse of fish populations and long-term economic hardship (Atlantic cod fishery)
• GDP does not consider the sustainability of economic growth, which may be achieved at the expense of future generations' well-being
  • Short-term economic gains from unsustainable practices can undermine long-term prosperity
  • Climate change driven by fossil fuel consumption can disrupt economies and livelihoods (rising sea levels, extreme weather events)

Criticisms of national income accounting

Undervaluation of women's contributions and informal economies

• National income accounting, which includes the calculation of GDP, does not account for non-market activities such as household production, childcare, and volunteer work, leading to an underestimation of total economic output and well-being
  • The value of unpaid household work, such as cooking, cleaning, and childcare, is not captured in GDP (estimated at 10-50% of GDP in various countries)
  • Volunteer work in schools, hospitals, and community organizations is not included in national income accounts
• The exclusion of non-market activities disproportionately affects the measurement of women's contributions to the economy, as they often engage in a larger share of unpaid work
  • Women spend more time on unpaid care work than men, which is not reflected in economic statistics (2-10 times more hours per day)
  • The gender gap in unpaid work can limit women's participation in the formal labor market and their economic empowerment
• The informal economy, which includes activities such as street vending, home-based businesses, and undeclared income, is not captured in national income accounting, leading to an underestimation of economic activity in many developing countries
  • Informal employment can account for a significant portion of total employment in developing economies (60-80% in some African and Asian countries)
  • Unregistered businesses and undeclared income are not included in official GDP calculations, leading to an incomplete picture of economic activity

Neglect of leisure time and environmental services

• The focus on market transactions in national income accounting ignores the value of leisure time, which can contribute to overall well-being and quality of life
  • Increased leisure time can improve mental health, social relationships, and personal development
  • The opportunity cost of leisure time is not considered in GDP calculations, leading to an overemphasis on market production
• National income accounting does not consider the value of environmental services, such as clean air and water, which are essential for human well-being but are not traded in markets
  • Ecosystems provide valuable services, such as carbon sequestration, water filtration, and biodiversity, which are not captured in economic statistics
  • The degradation of environmental services can have negative impacts on human health and economic productivity (air pollution, water scarcity)

Alternative measures of economic welfare

Human Development Index (HDI)

• The Human Development Index (HDI) is a composite measure that considers life expectancy, education, and per capita income, providing a more comprehensive assessment of a country's development and well-being than GDP alone
  • Life expectancy serves as a proxy for health and access to healthcare
  • Education is measured by a combination of mean years of schooling and expected years of schooling
  • Per capita income is adjusted for purchasing power parity to enable cross-country comparisons
• The HDI allows for comparisons of development levels across countries and over time, highlighting areas where improvements in health, education, and living standards are needed
  • Countries can have similar GDP per capita levels but vastly different HDI scores due to differences in health and education outcomes (Saudi Arabia and Poland)
  • Tracking changes in HDI over time can reveal progress or setbacks in human development, even if GDP growth remains steady

Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI)

• The Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) adjusts GDP by accounting for factors such as income distribution, environmental damage, and the value of non-market activities, providing a more accurate measure of economic welfare
  • Income inequality is factored into the GPI, with greater weight given to income gains among the poor
  • Environmental costs, such as pollution and resource depletion, are subtracted from the GPI
  • The value of non-market activities, like household work and volunteering, is added to the GPI
• The GPI subtracts the costs of negative externalities, such as pollution and crime, and adds the value of positive non-market activities, such as household work and volunteer services, to provide a more comprehensive assessment of economic well-being
  • The costs of air and water pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and ozone depletion are subtracted from the GPI
  • The value of unpaid household work, such as cooking, cleaning, and childcare, is added to the GPI
  • The costs of crime, including property damage, medical expenses, and lost productivity, are subtracted from the GPI

Limitations and insights of alternative measures

• Alternative measures of economic welfare, like the HDI and GPI, help to shift the focus from purely economic growth to a more holistic view of human development and well-being
  • These measures emphasize the importance of health, education, environmental sustainability, and social factors in assessing the overall well-being of a society
  • They provide a more nuanced understanding of the trade-offs between economic growth and other dimensions of human welfare
• These alternative measures have limitations, such as the difficulty in quantifying some aspects of well-being and the potential for subjective judgments in their construction, but they provide valuable insights that complement traditional economic indicators
  • Measuring the value of non-market activities and environmental services can be challenging and subject to debate
  • The weights assigned to different components of the HDI and GPI can be subjective and may not reflect the priorities of all societies
  • Despite their limitations, these alternative measures offer a broader perspective on economic welfare and can inform policy decisions aimed at improving quality of life