10.4 Model Validation and Verification

Model validation and verification are crucial steps in ensuring the accuracy and reliability of mechatronic system models. By comparing model outputs with experimental data and analytical solutions, engineers can refine and improve their simulations to better represent real-world behavior.

These processes help identify sources of uncertainty, acknowledge limitations, and establish model credibility. Through systematic validation techniques and documentation, engineers can create robust models that accurately predict system performance and guide design decisions in mechatronic systems integration.

Model Validation with Experimental Data

Comparing Model Outputs with Experimental Data

Top images from around the web for Comparing Model Outputs with Experimental Data

• 

  Lab 1: Introduction to Simulation | EME 171: Analysis, Simulation and Design of Mechatronic Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chi-square Goodness of Fit test View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Goodness-of-Fit (2 of 2) | Concepts in Statistics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lab 1: Introduction to Simulation | EME 171: Analysis, Simulation and Design of Mechatronic Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chi-square Goodness of Fit test View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Comparing Model Outputs with Experimental Data

• 

  Lab 1: Introduction to Simulation | EME 171: Analysis, Simulation and Design of Mechatronic Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chi-square Goodness of Fit test View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Goodness-of-Fit (2 of 2) | Concepts in Statistics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lab 1: Introduction to Simulation | EME 171: Analysis, Simulation and Design of Mechatronic Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chi-square Goodness of Fit test View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Validate mathematical models of mechatronic systems by comparing their outputs with experimental data obtained from physical prototypes or real-world systems
• Use statistical techniques to quantify the agreement between model predictions and experimental observations
  • Hypothesis testing
  • Regression analysis
  • Analysis of variance (ANOVA)
• Employ goodness-of-fit measures to assess the accuracy of the model in representing the actual system behavior
  • Coefficient of determination (R-squared)
  • Root mean square error (RMSE)
  • Mean absolute error (MAE)

Refining and Generalizing the Model

• Perform sensitivity analysis to identify the model parameters that have the most significant impact on the model outputs
  • Evaluate the robustness of the model to parameter variations
• Use cross-validation techniques to assess the model's ability to generalize to new data and detect overfitting
  • k-fold cross-validation
  • Leave-one-out cross-validation
• Refine the model structure, adjust parameter values, and incorporate additional physical phenomena through an iterative process until satisfactory agreement between model predictions and experimental data is achieved

Simulation Model Accuracy vs Reality

Comparing Simulation Outputs with Analytical Solutions

• Verify the accuracy of simulation models by comparing their outputs with analytical solutions derived from the underlying mathematical equations
• Use analytical solutions as a benchmark for assessing the accuracy of the simulation model in capturing the essential dynamics of the system
  • Closed-form expressions
  • Eigenvalue analysis
  • Frequency response functions
• Check the consistency and convergence of numerical algorithms to ensure the reliability of the simulation results
  • Finite element analysis (FEA)
  • Computational fluid dynamics (CFD)
  • Multibody dynamics

Comparing Simulation Outputs with Experimental Results

• Compare simulation model outputs with experimental results obtained from physical prototypes or real-world systems
  • Use sensors and data acquisition systems to provide a direct measure of the actual system behavior
  • Validate the simulation model's ability to replicate real-world performance
• Conduct mesh refinement studies to assess the sensitivity of the simulation results to the spatial and temporal discretization of the model
  • Determine the optimal mesh resolution for accurate and efficient simulations
• Compare results obtained from different simulation software packages or solvers to ensure consistency and reproducibility

Limitations of Model Validation

Sources of Uncertainty

• Recognize that model validation and verification processes are subject to various sources of uncertainty that can affect the reliability of model predictions
  • Measurement errors arising from sensor noise, calibration errors, and environmental factors
  • Model simplifications such as linearization, lumped-parameter approximations, and neglecting certain physical phenomena
  • Parameter uncertainties resulting from variability in material properties, manufacturing tolerances, and operating conditions
• Use uncertainty quantification techniques to assess the impact of uncertainties on model outputs and establish confidence intervals
  • Monte Carlo simulation
  • Polynomial chaos expansion
  • Bayesian inference

Acknowledging Limitations

• Perform sensitivity analysis to identify model parameters and assumptions that have the most significant influence on model uncertainties
  • Guide the refinement of the model structure and parameter estimation
• Acknowledge the limitations of model validation and verification processes
  • Finite number of experimental data points
  • Limited range of operating conditions
  • Inherent complexity of the system
• Communicate these limitations to the users of the model to ensure appropriate interpretation and application of the model results

Model Validation for Credibility

Systematic Validation and Verification

• Apply model validation and verification techniques throughout the development cycle of mechatronic system models to ensure their credibility and usefulness
• Use Design of Experiments (DOE) techniques to systematically plan and conduct experiments for model validation and verification
  • Factorial designs
  • Response surface methodology
  • Taguchi methods
• Employ model-based design approaches to progressively validate and verify the model at different levels of abstraction and integration with the physical system
  • Model-in-the-loop (MIL)
  • Software-in-the-loop (SIL)
  • Hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) simulations

Documenting and Updating the Model

• Use validation metrics to quantify the agreement between model predictions and experimental data and assess the model's fitness for purpose
  • Normalized root mean square error (NRMSE)
  • Relative error
  • Theil's inequality coefficient
• Develop verification and validation (V&V) plans to define the objectives, criteria, and procedures for model validation and verification
  • Ensure systematic and rigorous assessment of the model's credibility and usefulness
• Maintain documentation of the model validation and verification process, including experimental data, statistical analyses, and validation metrics
  • Provide transparency and traceability of the model's credibility
  • Facilitate reuse and extension by other researchers and practitioners
• Continuously monitor and update the model as new experimental data become available or as the system undergoes changes to ensure ongoing validity and usefulness for intended applications