7.1 Characteristics of SPEs and VIEs

Special Purpose Entities (SPEs) and Variable Interest Entities (VIEs) are key players in complex financial structures. These legal entities are created for specific business purposes, often used in off-balance sheet financing and asset securitization.

Understanding SPEs and VIEs is crucial for accountants dealing with mergers and acquisitions. Their characteristics, legal structures, and consolidation requirements significantly impact financial reporting and risk assessment in complex transactions.

Definition of SPEs and VIEs

• Special Purpose Entities (SPEs) and Variable Interest Entities (VIEs) are legal entities created for a specific business purpose or activity
• SPEs and VIEs play a significant role in complex financial structures, particularly in off-balance sheet financing and asset securitization
• Understanding the characteristics and consolidation requirements of SPEs and VIEs is crucial for accountants dealing with mergers, acquisitions, and complex financial structures

Legal structure of SPEs

Limited partnership vs corporation

Top images from around the web for Limited partnership vs corporation

• 

  Corporate Law and Corporate Responsibility – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Chart of a limited partnership.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4.4 Corporation – Foundations of Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Corporate Law and Corporate Responsibility – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Chart of a limited partnership.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Limited partnership vs corporation

• 

  Corporate Law and Corporate Responsibility – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Chart of a limited partnership.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4.4 Corporation – Foundations of Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Corporate Law and Corporate Responsibility – Business Ethics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Chart of a limited partnership.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• SPEs can be structured as limited partnerships or corporations depending on the specific purpose and desired legal characteristics
• Limited partnerships offer flexibility in terms of management and ownership structure but may have restrictions on transferability of ownership interests
• Corporations provide limited liability protection for owners and allow for easier transferability of ownership interests through the issuance of shares
• The choice of legal structure impacts the governance, taxation, and reporting requirements of the SPE

Ownership and control of SPEs

Sponsor's equity investment

• The sponsor, typically the parent company or originator, often holds a significant equity stake in the SPE to demonstrate its commitment and align interests with investors
• The sponsor's equity investment may be in the form of common stock, preferred stock, or subordinated debt
• The level of equity investment by the sponsor can impact the consolidation assessment under the variable interest model

Sponsor's voting rights

• The sponsor may retain certain voting rights in the SPE, such as the right to appoint board members or make key decisions
• However, to achieve off-balance sheet treatment, the sponsor's voting rights are often limited to protective rights rather than participating rights
• Protective rights allow the sponsor to veto certain actions that could adversely affect its interests, while participating rights give the sponsor the ability to direct the SPE's activities

Purposes of SPEs and VIEs

Off-balance sheet financing

• SPEs are commonly used to obtain off-balance sheet financing by transferring assets or liabilities to the SPE, which then issues securities to investors
• Off-balance sheet financing allows companies to raise capital without increasing debt on their balance sheets, improving financial ratios and credit ratings
• Examples of off-balance sheet financing include operating leases, sale-leaseback transactions, and asset-backed securitizations (credit card receivables, mortgages)

Asset securitization

• SPEs facilitate asset securitization by purchasing a pool of financial assets (loans, receivables) from the originator and issuing asset-backed securities to investors
• Asset securitization enables originators to convert illiquid assets into marketable securities, providing liquidity and diversifying funding sources
• Securitization SPEs are typically structured as bankruptcy-remote entities to protect investors from the originator's credit risk

Risk isolation

• SPEs can be used to isolate specific risks, such as credit risk or market risk, from the sponsor's balance sheet
• By transferring assets or liabilities to an SPE, the sponsor can limit its exposure to potential losses associated with those assets or liabilities
• Risk isolation is particularly relevant in the context of asset securitization, where the credit risk of the underlying assets is transferred to the SPE and its investors

Characteristics of SPEs

Narrow scope of activities

• SPEs are designed to have a limited and well-defined purpose, such as holding a specific asset or conducting a particular transaction
• The narrow scope of activities helps to ensure that the SPE's operations are transparent and predictable for investors
• Restricting the SPE's activities also reduces the risk of the SPE engaging in unintended or unauthorized transactions that could jeopardize its financial stability

Thin capitalization

• SPEs often have minimal equity capital relative to their total assets, a characteristic known as thin capitalization
• Thin capitalization allows the SPE to achieve high leverage and generate attractive returns for equity investors
• However, thin capitalization also increases the SPE's vulnerability to financial distress in the event of asset value deterioration or cash flow disruptions

Non-substantive equity investment

• In some cases, the equity investment in an SPE may be considered non-substantive, meaning that it does not provide a meaningful level of capital support
• Non-substantive equity investments may take the form of nominal equity contributions, equity-linked notes, or other instruments that do not absorb significant losses
• The presence of non-substantive equity investment can impact the consolidation assessment under the variable interest model, as it may indicate that the SPE is a VIE

Characteristics of VIEs

Insufficient equity investment

• A key characteristic of VIEs is that they have insufficient equity investment at risk to finance their activities without additional subordinated financial support
• Insufficient equity investment means that the VIE's equity holders do not have a substantial economic interest in the entity's success or failure
• The lack of sufficient equity investment is one of the criteria used to determine whether an entity is a VIE under the variable interest model

Lack of control rights

• VIEs often have a governance structure that does not provide equity holders with the ability to make significant decisions about the entity's activities
• The lack of control rights may be evidenced by the absence of voting rights, the presence of contractual arrangements that limit decision-making power, or the existence of a dominant variable interest holder
• The absence of control rights is another factor considered in the VIE determination process

Sponsor's obligation to absorb losses

• In some VIE structures, the sponsor may have an explicit or implicit obligation to absorb losses or provide financial support to the VIE
• This obligation can arise from contractual arrangements, such as guarantees, liquidity facilities, or other credit enhancements provided by the sponsor
• The sponsor's obligation to absorb losses is a key consideration in the consolidation assessment under the variable interest model, as it may indicate that the sponsor has a controlling financial interest in the VIE

Consolidation of SPEs and VIEs

Risks and rewards approach

• The risks and rewards approach focuses on identifying the party that has the majority of the economic risks and rewards associated with the SPE or VIE
• Under this approach, the party with the majority of risks and rewards would consolidate the SPE or VIE, regardless of voting rights or legal ownership
• The risks and rewards approach was commonly used before the introduction of the variable interest model but has been largely superseded by the latter

Voting interest model

• The voting interest model is the traditional consolidation approach based on the ownership of a majority voting interest in an entity
• Under this model, the party with a controlling financial interest, typically through majority voting rights, would consolidate the entity
• However, the voting interest model may not be appropriate for SPEs and VIEs, where voting rights often do not align with the economic risks and rewards

Variable interest model

• The variable interest model, introduced by FIN 46(R) and now codified in ASC 810, is the primary consolidation model for VIEs
• Under this model, the party with a controlling financial interest in a VIE, known as the primary beneficiary, must consolidate the VIE
• The primary beneficiary is the party that has both (1) the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the VIE's economic performance and (2) the obligation to absorb losses or the right to receive benefits that could potentially be significant to the VIE

Disclosure requirements for SPEs and VIEs

Financial statement footnotes

• Companies are required to disclose information about their involvement with SPEs and VIEs in the notes to their financial statements
• Footnote disclosures should include a description of the SPE or VIE, the nature and purpose of the entity, the company's maximum exposure to loss, and any significant judgments or assumptions made in determining the consolidation status
• Footnote disclosures help stakeholders assess the risks and potential impact of SPEs and VIEs on the company's financial position and performance

Management's discussion and analysis

• In the Management's Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) section of their financial reports, companies should discuss the key risks, uncertainties, and potential impacts associated with their SPEs and VIEs
• The MD&A should provide a transparent and comprehensive analysis of the company's off-balance sheet arrangements, including the business purpose, financial impact, and risk exposure related to SPEs and VIEs
• The MD&A disclosures complement the footnote disclosures and provide stakeholders with a more holistic understanding of the company's involvement with SPEs and VIEs

Examples of SPEs and VIEs

Enron's use of SPEs

• Enron, a former energy company, used SPEs extensively to hide debt, inflate earnings, and engage in fraudulent accounting practices
• Enron created numerous SPEs, such as LJM Cayman and Raptor, to enter into complex transactions that shifted liabilities off its balance sheet and artificially boosted its financial performance
• The collapse of Enron in 2001 highlighted the potential for abuse of SPEs and led to significant changes in accounting standards and regulations, including the introduction of the variable interest model

Collateralized debt obligations (CDOs)

• CDOs are a type of structured finance product that involves the securitization of a pool of debt obligations, such as loans or bonds, through an SPE
• The SPE issues multiple tranches of securities with varying levels of seniority and credit risk, which are sold to investors
• CDOs played a significant role in the 2007-2008 financial crisis, as the complex and opaque nature of these instruments made it difficult for investors to assess their true risks and values

Structured investment vehicles (SIVs)

• SIVs are a type of SPE that invests in long-term, high-yield assets (such as mortgage-backed securities) and finances these investments through the issuance of short-term, low-yield debt (such as commercial paper)
• SIVs aim to profit from the spread between the higher yields on their asset portfolio and the lower cost of their liabilities
• However, SIVs are vulnerable to liquidity risk and market disruptions, as they rely on the continuous rollover of short-term debt to fund their long-term investments
• The failure of numerous SIVs during the 2007-2008 financial crisis highlighted the risks associated with these off-balance sheet vehicles and their potential impact on the stability of the financial system