8.2 Timing and Frequency of Feedback

Timing and frequency of feedback are crucial in motor learning. They impact how well we acquire and retain skills. Immediate feedback helps us quickly fix errors, while delayed feedback promotes deeper processing and better long-term retention. Finding the right balance is key.

Feedback frequency also matters. High-frequency feedback helps early on, but reducing it later encourages self-evaluation. A fading feedback schedule tailored to individual needs can optimize learning. Avoiding feedback dependence is important for long-term skill development and adaptability.

Feedback Timing for Motor Learning

Impact of Feedback Timing on Skill Acquisition and Retention

Top images from around the web for Impact of Feedback Timing on Skill Acquisition and Retention

• 

  Frontiers | Impaired Motor Skill Acquisition Using Mirror Visual Feedback Improved by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | When and How to Provide Feedback and Instructions to Athletes?—How Sport Psychology ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Impaired Motor Skill Acquisition Using Mirror Visual Feedback Improved by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | When and How to Provide Feedback and Instructions to Athletes?—How Sport Psychology ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Impact of Feedback Timing on Skill Acquisition and Retention

• 

  Frontiers | Impaired Motor Skill Acquisition Using Mirror Visual Feedback Improved by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | When and How to Provide Feedback and Instructions to Athletes?—How Sport Psychology ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Impaired Motor Skill Acquisition Using Mirror Visual Feedback Improved by ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | When and How to Provide Feedback and Instructions to Athletes?—How Sport Psychology ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Feedback timing significantly influences the acquisition and retention of motor skills
  • Timing affects cognitive processing of information related to the motor skill
  • Influences development of error detection and correction mechanisms
• Immediate feedback is given directly after the performance of a motor skill
• Delayed feedback is provided after a certain time interval following the performance
• Optimal timing of feedback may vary depending on:
  • Complexity of the motor skill
  • Skill level of the learner
  • Stage of learning (acquisition, retention, or transfer)

Definition and Types of Feedback Timing

• Feedback timing refers to when feedback is provided relative to the performance of a motor skill
• Two main types of feedback timing:
  • Immediate feedback
    • Given directly after the performance of a motor skill
    • Allows for quick identification and correction of errors
  • Delayed feedback
    • Provided after a certain time interval following the performance
    • May promote deeper cognitive processing and development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms

Immediate vs Delayed Feedback Effects

Benefits and Drawbacks of Immediate Feedback

• Immediate feedback can be beneficial for initial acquisition of motor skills
  • Allows learners to quickly identify and correct errors in their performance
  • Helps establish correct movement patterns early in the learning process
• Potential drawbacks of immediate feedback:
  • May lead to dependency on external feedback (guidance hypothesis)
  • Can hinder development of intrinsic error detection and correction abilities
  • May not promote deep cognitive processing of feedback information

Advantages of Delayed Feedback for Long-term Retention and Transfer

• Delayed feedback may promote deeper cognitive processing and development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms
  • Encourages learners to actively engage in self-evaluation and error detection
  • Leads to better long-term retention and transfer of motor skills
• Challenge point framework suggests optimal timing of feedback depends on:
  • Skill level of the learner
  • Difficulty of the task
  • More challenging tasks and advanced learners may benefit from delayed feedback
• Delayed feedback can help reduce dependency on external feedback
  • Promotes development of robust internal representations of the motor skill
  • Enhances learner's ability to adapt to varying performance contexts

Optimal Feedback Frequency

Feedback Frequency and Motor Skill Acquisition

• Feedback frequency refers to how often feedback is provided during the learning process
• High-frequency feedback may be beneficial during early stages of motor skill acquisition
  • Helps learners identify and correct errors quickly
  • Establishes correct movement patterns and reinforces desired performance
• As learners progress to later stages of skill development, reduced feedback frequency may be more effective
  • Promotes development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms
  • Reduces dependency on external feedback
  • Encourages self-evaluation and error correction abilities

Fading Feedback Schedule and Individual Differences

• Fading feedback schedule involves gradually reducing the frequency of feedback as learners become more proficient
  • Allows learners to develop self-evaluation and error correction abilities
  • Promotes transition from external to internal feedback reliance
• Optimal feedback frequency may vary depending on:
  • Complexity of the motor skill (simple vs. complex tasks)
  • Skill level of the learner (novice vs. advanced)
  • Individual differences in learning preferences and motivation
• Tailoring feedback frequency to individual needs can enhance learning outcomes
  • Some learners may require more frequent feedback for longer periods
  • Others may benefit from reduced feedback frequency earlier in the learning process

Feedback Dependence and Performance

Concept and Consequences of Feedback Dependence

• Feedback dependence occurs when learners rely heavily on external feedback to guide their motor performance
  • Can hinder development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms
  • May lead to decreased performance when feedback is withdrawn or unavailable
• Excessive reliance on external feedback can result in:
  • Difficulty in self-evaluating and correcting movements
  • Reduced ability to adapt to varying performance contexts
  • Decreased long-term retention and transfer of motor skills
• Feedback dependence is more likely to occur when:
  • Feedback is provided too frequently
  • Feedback is given immediately after every performance attempt

Strategies to Mitigate Feedback Dependence

• Employ fading feedback schedules
  • Gradually reduce the frequency of feedback as learners become more proficient
  • Encourages development of self-evaluation and error correction abilities
• Provide summary feedback
  • Give feedback after a series of performance attempts rather than after each attempt
  • Allows learners to process and integrate feedback information more effectively
• Encourage active engagement in self-evaluation and reflection
  • Prompt learners to analyze their own performance and identify areas for improvement
  • Promotes development of intrinsic feedback mechanisms and reduces reliance on external feedback
• Reducing feedback dependence is crucial for long-term motor performance
  • Develops robust internal representations of the motor skill
  • Enhances learner's ability to adapt to varying performance contexts
  • Promotes long-term retention and transfer of motor skills