1.7 Modernism in classical music

Modernism in classical music emerged as a radical departure from tradition, challenging established norms in the early 20th century. Composers broke free from tonal constraints, exploring new sonic possibilities and expressive techniques that reflected broader cultural shifts.

Key characteristics included atonality, rhythmic complexity, and experimental forms. Prominent figures like Schoenberg, Stravinsky, and Bartók pioneered innovative techniques, while movements such as expressionism and futurism pushed boundaries further.

Origins of musical modernism

• Modernism in classical music emerged as a radical departure from traditional Western music, challenging established norms and conventions
• This movement reflected broader cultural shifts occurring in the early 20th century, including rapid technological advancements and changing social structures
• Composers sought to break free from the constraints of tonality and traditional forms, exploring new sonic possibilities and expressive techniques

Late romantic influences

Top images from around the web for Late romantic influences

• 

  Symphony No.5 (Mahler, Gustav) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Richard Strauss Tone Poems Rudolf Kempe Warner Classics | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Richard Wagner by Caesar Willich ca 1862.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Symphony No.5 (Mahler, Gustav) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Richard Strauss Tone Poems Rudolf Kempe Warner Classics | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Late romantic influences

• 

  Symphony No.5 (Mahler, Gustav) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Richard Strauss Tone Poems Rudolf Kempe Warner Classics | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Richard Wagner by Caesar Willich ca 1862.jpg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Symphony No.5 (Mahler, Gustav) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Richard Strauss Tone Poems Rudolf Kempe Warner Classics | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Expansion of harmonic language in works of Wagner and Mahler pushed tonal boundaries
• Chromaticism intensified, leading to increased dissonance and ambiguous tonality
• Large-scale orchestral works (Symphony No. 8 by Mahler) paved the way for more complex textures
• Exploration of programmatic music and tone poems (Richard Strauss) influenced modernist narrative approaches

Turn of the century shifts

• Debussy's impressionism introduced new approaches to timbre and harmony
• Whole-tone scales and non-functional harmony became more prevalent
• Rhythmic innovations, including the use of ostinatos and irregular meters, emerged
• Incorporation of non-Western musical elements (gamelan music) expanded compositional palettes

Reaction against tradition

• Rejection of functional harmony and traditional formal structures
• Abandonment of predictable melodic patterns and cadential formulas
• Exploration of new instrumental combinations and extended techniques
• Emphasis on individual expression over adherence to established rules or conventions

Key characteristics

Atonality and dissonance

• Abandonment of traditional tonal centers and key relationships
• Increased use of dissonant intervals and chord structures
• Exploration of microtonal systems and alternative tuning methods
• Development of new harmonic languages (Schoenberg's emancipation of dissonance)
• Emphasis on timbral qualities over traditional harmonic progressions

Rhythmic complexity

• Irregular and constantly changing time signatures (Stravinsky's "The Rite of Spring")
• Polyrhythms and cross-rhythms became more prevalent
• Use of additive rhythms and asymmetrical patterns
• Exploration of extreme tempo contrasts and metric modulation
• Integration of jazz-influenced syncopation and improvisation

Experimental forms

• Rejection of traditional sonata form and other established structures
• Development of through-composed and non-linear narrative approaches
• Incorporation of aleatoric elements and chance procedures
• Exploration of open forms and graphic notation
• Creation of new formal concepts based on mathematical or visual principles

Prominent composers

Schoenberg and Second Viennese School

• Arnold Schoenberg pioneered atonal and twelve-tone composition techniques
• Alban Berg combined expressionist elements with more traditional forms (Wozzeck)
• Anton Webern focused on extreme brevity and pointillistic textures
• Developed serialism as a systematic approach to composition
• Influenced generations of composers through their teaching and theoretical writings

Stravinsky's revolutionary works

• "The Rite of Spring" revolutionized rhythm and orchestration in classical music
• Explored primitivism and folk-inspired elements in early ballets
• Developed a neoclassical style in later works (Symphony in C)
• Experimented with serialism and aleatory techniques in his late period
• Influenced diverse musical genres, including jazz and popular music

Bartók's folk-inspired modernism

• Incorporated Hungarian and Eastern European folk melodies into his compositions
• Developed innovative approaches to rhythm and meter (Music for Strings, Percussion and Celesta)
• Explored new string techniques and extended playing methods
• Created a unique harmonic language combining modality and chromaticism
• Influenced ethnomusicology through his extensive field recordings and research

Techniques and innovations

Twelve-tone technique

• Systematic method of composition using all 12 chromatic pitches equally
• Developed by Arnold Schoenberg as an alternative to traditional tonality
• Based on a predetermined row or series of the 12 pitches
• Employs transformations of the row (retrograde, inversion, retrograde inversion)
• Influenced serialist approaches to other musical parameters (rhythm, dynamics, timbre)

Serialism vs aleatory music

• Serialism extended twelve-tone principles to other musical elements
• Total serialism (Boulez, Stockhausen) applied serial techniques to all parameters
• Aleatory music incorporated chance elements and indeterminacy
• John Cage's "4'33"" challenged traditional notions of music and silence
• Both approaches sought to break from traditional compositional control

Extended instrumental techniques

• Exploration of non-traditional playing methods to create new sounds
• Prepared piano techniques developed by John Cage
• Use of multiphonics and microtones in wind instruments
• Extended string techniques (col legno, sul ponticello) became more common
• Incorporation of electronic and tape elements in instrumental works

Modernist movements

Expressionism in music

• Emphasized intense emotional expression and psychological states
• Often featured atonal harmonies and extreme dynamic contrasts
• Schoenberg's "Erwartung" exemplified expressionist opera
• Influenced by visual arts movements (Die Brücke, Der Blaue Reiter)
• Explored themes of alienation, anxiety, and inner turmoil

Futurism and machine music

• Celebrated technology, speed, and industrial sounds
• Luigi Russolo's "Art of Noises" manifesto introduced noise music
• Incorporation of non-musical sounds and industrial noises in compositions
• Influenced early electronic music and musique concrète
• Explored new notational systems to represent unconventional sounds

Neoclassicism

• Reinterpreted classical forms and techniques through a modernist lens
• Stravinsky's "Pulcinella" marked a shift towards neoclassical style
• Emphasized clarity, balance, and objectivity in contrast to romanticism
• Often incorporated elements of irony or parody
• Influenced composers such as Hindemith, Prokofiev, and Poulenc

Cultural context

World wars and societal upheaval

• Disruption of cultural institutions and artistic communities
• Exploration of themes of violence, chaos, and existential crisis in music
• Displacement of composers and musicians led to cross-cultural exchanges
• Rise of nationalism influenced some composers' use of folk elements
• Post-war avant-garde movements (Darmstadt School) sought radical new directions

Technological advancements

• Development of electronic instruments (theremin, ondes Martenot)
• Recording technology allowed for new approaches to composition and performance
• Radio broadcasts expanded audience reach and influenced compositional styles
• Early experiments with tape music and musique concrète
• Influence of scientific concepts (quantum mechanics, relativity) on musical thinking

Artistic cross-pollination

• Collaboration between composers and visual artists (Kandinsky, Klee)
• Influence of literary movements (Symbolism, Surrealism) on musical aesthetics
• Integration of dance and theatrical elements in modernist works
• Exploration of synesthesia and multi-sensory artistic experiences
• Exchange of ideas between classical composers and jazz musicians

Reception and impact

Audience reactions

• Initial shock and controversy surrounding premieres of modernist works
• Gradual acceptance and appreciation of new musical languages
• Development of specialized audiences for avant-garde music
• Challenges in accessibility and comprehension for general listeners
• Influence on film music and popular culture perceptions of "modern" sound

Critical responses

• Debates over the value and validity of atonal and experimental music
• Emergence of new analytical approaches and theoretical frameworks
• Polarization between advocates of modernism and defenders of tradition
• Reassessment of earlier modernist works as they entered the canon
• Influence on music education and conservatory curricula

Influence on later composers

• Expansion of compositional techniques and sound palettes
• Integration of modernist elements in more accessible styles (minimalism)
• Continued exploration of electronic and computer-based composition
• Influence on film scoring and contemporary classical music
• Legacy of challenging conventions and pushing boundaries in music

Modernism vs postmodernism

Philosophical differences

• Modernism sought to break from tradition and find new universal truths
• Postmodernism questioned the existence of universal truths or grand narratives
• Modernist emphasis on progress vs postmodern skepticism of linear progress
• Exploration of subjectivity and multiple perspectives in postmodern thought
• Postmodern embrace of eclecticism and mixing of high and low culture

Compositional approaches

• Modernist focus on innovation and originality in technique and form
• Postmodern tendency to combine or juxtapose diverse styles and genres
• Modernist emphasis on structural unity vs postmodern fragmentation
• Use of quotation and pastiche in postmodern compositions
• Postmodern reexamination and recontextualization of historical styles

Aesthetic goals

• Modernist pursuit of abstraction and non-representational art
• Postmodern embrace of plurality and multiple interpretations
• Modernist rejection of ornament vs postmodern return to decoration
• Exploration of irony, parody, and self-referentiality in postmodern works
• Postmodern blurring of boundaries between art music and popular music