12.7 Myth and psychoanalytic literary theory

Psychoanalytic theory revolutionized myth and literature studies by introducing psychological interpretations of narratives and characters. It emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, providing new frameworks for understanding human behavior and cultural expressions.

Key concepts like the unconscious mind, archetypes, and symbolic interpretation reshaped how we analyze myths and stories. These ideas offer unique insights into the hidden meanings and psychological functions of narratives across cultures.

Origins of psychoanalytic theory

• Psychoanalytic theory revolutionized the study of myth and literature by introducing psychological interpretations of narratives and characters
• Emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, providing new frameworks for understanding human behavior and cultural expressions
• Influenced literary criticism by emphasizing the role of the unconscious in creative processes and narrative structures

Freud's influence on literature

Top images from around the web for Freud's influence on literature

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Psychology | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Schools-of-Thought - Psychoanalysis View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Psychology | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Freud's influence on literature

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Psychology | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Schools-of-Thought - Psychoanalysis View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  History of Psychology | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Sigmund Freud developed psychoanalysis as a method to treat mental disorders and understand human psychology
• Introduced concepts of the unconscious mind, repression, and dream symbolism that profoundly impacted literary analysis
• Applied psychoanalytic principles to interpret literary works (Oedipus Rex, Hamlet)
• Emphasized the role of childhood experiences and sexual desires in shaping human behavior and artistic expression

Jung's archetypal approach

• Carl Jung expanded on Freud's theories, developing analytical psychology
• Introduced the concept of collective unconscious, a shared reservoir of universal human experiences
• Proposed the existence of archetypes, primordial images and patterns that appear across cultures and mythologies
• Applied archetypal analysis to myths, folktales, and literature to uncover universal themes and symbols
• Influenced literary criticism by providing a framework for interpreting recurring character types and narrative structures

Key psychoanalytic concepts

• Psychoanalytic theory introduced fundamental ideas about the human psyche that reshaped the understanding of myth and literature
• These concepts provided new tools for analyzing characters, plot structures, and symbolic elements in narratives
• Understanding these key concepts is essential for applying psychoanalytic approaches to mythological and literary texts

Unconscious vs conscious mind

• Unconscious mind contains repressed thoughts, memories, and desires that influence behavior
• Conscious mind represents the awareness of immediate thoughts, perceptions, and experiences
• Psychoanalysis aims to bring unconscious content into conscious awareness
• Literary works often explore the tension between characters' conscious actions and unconscious motivations
• Myths frequently symbolize the struggle between conscious and unconscious forces (light vs darkness, order vs chaos)

Id, ego, and superego

• Id represents primitive instincts and desires, operates on the pleasure principle
• Ego mediates between id and reality, follows the reality principle
• Superego embodies moral and societal standards, strives for perfection
• These three components of the psyche often manifest as conflicting characters or forces in myths and literature
• Literary analysis can interpret characters as representations of id (impulsive characters), ego (protagonists), or superego (authority figures)

Oedipus complex in mythology

• Freud's theory of unconscious desire for the opposite-sex parent and rivalry with the same-sex parent
• Named after the Greek myth of Oedipus, who unknowingly killed his father and married his mother
• Appears in various mythological narratives across cultures (Electra complex for females)
• Influences character relationships and plot dynamics in literature and myth
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees this complex as a universal stage of psychological development reflected in cultural narratives

Psychoanalysis and myth interpretation

• Psychoanalytic approaches offer unique insights into the hidden meanings and psychological functions of myths
• These interpretations view myths as expressions of collective human experiences and unconscious desires
• Applying psychoanalytic techniques to myth analysis reveals deeper layers of meaning and cultural significance

Symbolism in mythic narratives

• Myths employ symbols to represent complex psychological concepts and experiences
• Psychoanalysis interprets mythic symbols as representations of unconscious desires, fears, and conflicts
• Common mythic symbols include:
  • Water: rebirth, the unconscious mind
  • Trees: growth, connection between conscious and unconscious
  • Serpents: transformation, hidden knowledge
• Symbolic interpretation reveals universal themes and psychological processes embedded in diverse mythologies
• Psychoanalytic approach sees mythic symbols as a "language" of the unconscious shared across cultures

Dream analysis techniques

• Freud viewed dreams as the "royal road to the unconscious"
• Dream analysis techniques applied to myths reveal hidden meanings and psychological content
• Key elements of dream analysis in myth interpretation:
  • Condensation: multiple meanings compressed into single images
  • Displacement: emotions transferred from one object to another
  • Symbolization: abstract ideas represented by concrete images
• Myths often structured like dreams, with non-linear narratives and symbolic imagery
• Analyzing myths using dream interpretation techniques uncovers deeper psychological significance

Archetypes in world mythology

• Jung's concept of archetypes as universal patterns in the collective unconscious
• Common archetypes in world mythology include:
  • The Hero: represents the ego's quest for identity and wholeness
  • The Great Mother: nurturing and destructive aspects of the feminine
  • The Wise Old Man: guidance and wisdom
  • The Trickster: chaos, transformation, and the breaking of conventions
• Archetypal analysis reveals shared psychological structures across diverse mythological traditions
• Helps explain similarities in myths from unconnected cultures

Mythic heroes and psychoanalysis

• Psychoanalytic theory provides a framework for understanding the psychological significance of mythic heroes
• Heroes in myths often represent the human psyche's journey towards wholeness and self-realization
• Analyzing mythic heroes through a psychoanalytic lens reveals universal patterns of psychological development

Hero's journey as individuation

• Joseph Campbell's monomyth concept aligns with Jung's idea of individuation
• Individuation represents the process of integrating unconscious aspects of the psyche into consciousness
• Stages of the hero's journey correspond to psychological development:
  • Departure: separation from the familiar (ego development)
  • Initiation: confronting challenges (integrating unconscious content)
  • Return: bringing newfound wisdom back to society (achieving psychic wholeness)
• Mythic heroes embody the human struggle for self-realization and psychological growth
• Analysis of hero myths reveals universal patterns of psychological transformation across cultures

Mother goddess archetype

• Represents the nurturing and destructive aspects of the feminine principle
• Manifests in various mythological figures (Gaia, Kali, Isis)
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees the mother goddess as symbolizing:
  • The unconscious mind
  • The source of life and death
  • The ambivalent nature of the maternal relationship
• Plays a crucial role in hero myths, often as both helper and obstacle
• Reflects complex psychological attitudes towards femininity and motherhood in different cultures

Shadow self in mythic villains

• Jung's concept of the shadow represents repressed aspects of the psyche
• Mythic villains often embody the hero's shadow, representing unacknowledged or rejected parts of the self
• Characteristics of shadow figures in myths:
  • Often share traits with the hero
  • Represent temptations or fears the hero must overcome
  • May transform or be integrated as the hero develops
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees the hero-villain conflict as an internal psychological struggle
• Analyzing mythic villains reveals cultural and individual attitudes towards socially unacceptable traits or desires

Psychosexual stages in myths

• Freud's theory of psychosexual development provides a framework for interpreting mythic motifs and symbols
• Myths often contain elements that correspond to different stages of psychosexual development
• Analyzing myths through this lens reveals cultural attitudes towards sexuality and psychological maturation

Oral stage mythic motifs

• Represents the earliest stage of psychosexual development, focused on oral gratification
• Mythic motifs associated with the oral stage:
  • Devouring monsters (Cronos eating his children)
  • Magical foods or drinks (ambrosia, soma)
  • Heroes with extraordinary vocal abilities (Orpheus)
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees these motifs as reflecting early childhood experiences and anxieties
• Reveals cultural attitudes towards dependency, nurturance, and consumption

Anal stage in folklore

• Corresponds to the stage of development focused on toilet training and control
• Folkloric elements associated with the anal stage:
  • Stories involving cleanliness or dirtiness
  • Tales of hoarding or excessive generosity
  • Characters with magical control over bodily functions
• Psychoanalytic analysis interprets these elements as reflecting issues of control, order, and possession
• Reveals cultural attitudes towards discipline, authority, and personal boundaries

Phallic symbolism in legends

• Relates to the stage of development focused on genital awareness and Oedipal conflicts
• Phallic symbols in legends and myths:
  • Weapons (swords, spears)
  • Tall structures (towers, mountains)
  • Serpents and dragons
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees these symbols as representing sexual power, potency, and competition
• Analysis reveals cultural attitudes towards masculinity, femininity, and sexual identity

Myth and collective unconscious

• Jung's concept of the collective unconscious provides a framework for understanding shared mythic patterns across cultures
• Psychoanalytic theory sees myths as expressions of universal psychological structures and experiences
• Analyzing myths through this lens reveals deep connections between diverse cultural narratives

Cultural myths as shared psyche

• Myths reflect and shape the collective psyche of a culture
• Represent shared values, fears, and aspirations of a society
• Function as psychological tools for:
  • Socialization
  • Explaining natural phenomena
  • Coping with existential questions
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees cultural myths as expressions of collective unconscious content
• Analyzing cultural myths reveals underlying psychological structures of different societies

Universal symbols across cultures

• Certain symbols appear consistently in myths from diverse cultures
• Common universal symbols include:
  • The World Tree: connection between realms
  • The Great Flood: destruction and renewal
  • The Divine Child: potential and new beginnings
• Psychoanalytic theory interprets these symbols as expressions of shared human experiences and psychological structures
• Analysis of universal symbols reveals common psychological concerns and archetypes across humanity

Mythic patterns in dreams

• Jung observed similarities between mythic narratives and dream content
• Dreams often incorporate mythic themes and symbols
• Common mythic patterns in dreams:
  • Quests or journeys
  • Encounters with monsters or divine beings
  • Transformations or magical events
• Psychoanalytic interpretation sees these patterns as expressions of universal psychological processes
• Analyzing mythic patterns in dreams reveals connections between individual and collective unconscious content

Psychoanalytic literary criticism

• Applies psychoanalytic concepts and techniques to the analysis of literary texts
• Views literature as an expression of the author's and readers' unconscious desires and conflicts
• Provides tools for deeper understanding of character motivations, plot structures, and symbolic elements in literature

Character analysis techniques

• Examines characters as representations of psychological states or processes
• Techniques for psychoanalytic character analysis:
  • Identifying defense mechanisms (repression, projection, sublimation)
  • Analyzing character relationships through Oedipal or family dynamics
  • Interpreting character actions as expressions of unconscious desires
• Reveals deeper layers of meaning in character interactions and development
• Helps understand characters as complex psychological entities rather than simple archetypes

Plot as psychological journey

• Interprets narrative structures as representations of psychological processes
• Views plot development as a metaphor for:
  • Individual maturation
  • Resolution of internal conflicts
  • Integration of unconscious content
• Analyzes key plot points as symbolic representations of psychological milestones
• Reveals underlying psychological themes and patterns in narrative structures
• Helps understand how stories reflect and shape human psychological experiences

Setting as mental landscape

• Interprets literary settings as representations of psychological states or the unconscious mind
• Techniques for analyzing setting psychoanalytically:
  • Identifying symbolic representations of mental states (forests as the unconscious)
  • Examining transitions between settings as psychological shifts
  • Analyzing the interaction between characters and their environment
• Reveals how authors use setting to externalize internal psychological processes
• Helps understand the psychological significance of spatial and environmental elements in literature

Contemporary applications

• Modern psychoanalytic approaches to myth and literature incorporate diverse perspectives and methodologies
• These contemporary applications expand the scope of psychoanalytic interpretation to address issues of gender, culture, and identity
• Integrating psychoanalytic theory with other critical approaches provides new insights into mythic and literary texts

Feminist psychoanalytic approaches

• Critiques and revises traditional Freudian and Jungian theories from a feminist perspective
• Focuses on:
  • Reinterpreting female characters and symbols in myths and literature
  • Examining the impact of patriarchal structures on psychic development
  • Exploring alternative models of feminine psychology (Horney, Chodorow)
• Analyzes myths and literature for representations of female experience and desire
• Reveals how gender dynamics shape narrative structures and symbolic systems in texts

Postcolonial psychoanalytic readings

• Applies psychoanalytic concepts to understand the psychological effects of colonialism
• Examines:
  • The impact of cultural displacement on individual and collective psyche
  • Psychological dynamics between colonizer and colonized
  • Reinterpretation of myths and literature from non-Western perspectives
• Analyzes how colonial experiences shape narrative structures and character psychology
• Reveals the psychological dimensions of cultural conflict and identity formation in postcolonial contexts

Queer theory and myth analysis

• Integrates psychoanalytic concepts with queer theory to examine representations of sexuality and gender in myths and literature
• Focuses on:
  • Reinterpreting mythic figures and narratives through a queer lens
  • Examining the psychological dynamics of non-normative sexualities and gender identities
  • Analyzing the role of desire and identification in myth and literature
• Reveals hidden or suppressed queer elements in traditional mythic narratives
• Provides new perspectives on the psychological functions of myths in relation to sexuality and gender identity

Critiques of psychoanalytic theory

• While influential, psychoanalytic approaches to myth and literature have faced significant criticisms
• Understanding these critiques is essential for a balanced application of psychoanalytic theory in literary and mythological studies
• Considering alternative approaches alongside psychoanalysis can provide a more comprehensive understanding of texts

Limitations in myth interpretation

• Overemphasis on sexual symbolism can lead to reductive interpretations
• Tendency to impose Western psychological models on non-Western myths
• Difficulty in verifying interpretations due to the subjective nature of analysis
• Risk of overlooking historical and cultural contexts in favor of psychological explanations
• Potential for circular reasoning when interpreting myths to support psychoanalytic theories

Cultural bias in psychoanalysis

• Traditional psychoanalytic theory rooted in Western, patriarchal worldviews
• May not adequately account for diverse cultural experiences and psychological structures
• Risk of pathologizing cultural differences or non-Western psychological models
• Tendency to universalize Western concepts of self, family, and sexuality
• Need for greater cultural sensitivity and inclusivity in psychoanalytic approaches to myth and literature

Alternative psychological approaches

• Cognitive approaches focus on mental processes and schema in myth comprehension
• Evolutionary psychology examines the adaptive functions of myths and storytelling
• Social psychology explores how myths reflect and shape group dynamics
• Narrative psychology analyzes how individuals use mythic structures to construct personal identities
• Transpersonal psychology investigates spiritual and transcendent aspects of mythic experiences
• Integrating multiple psychological perspectives can provide a more comprehensive understanding of myths and literature