5.5 Living conditions on reservations

The reservation system, a cornerstone of Native American history, continues to shape tribal life today. Established in the 19th century to confine Native populations, reservations have evolved through policies of allotment, reorganization, and self-determination.

Today, 326 reservations house 22% of Native Americans, facing unique challenges. Land ownership complexities, resource management issues, and environmental concerns intersect with efforts to improve housing, infrastructure, and economic conditions on reservations.

Overview of reservation system

• Reservation system forms a crucial part of Native American history and contemporary life in the United States
• Established as a result of complex historical processes and government policies aimed at controlling Native American populations
• Continues to shape the socioeconomic, cultural, and political realities of Native American tribes today

Purpose and establishment

Top images from around the web for Purpose and establishment

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trail of Tears - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trail of Tears - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Purpose and establishment

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trail of Tears - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Trail of Tears - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Created in the 19th century as part of U.S. government's policy of Native American removal and containment
• Intended to confine Native American tribes to specific areas, freeing up land for white settlers
• Formalized through numerous treaties between the U.S. government and Native American tribes
• Often resulted in forced relocation of tribes from their ancestral lands (Trail of Tears)

Historical development

• Evolved from initial concept of separate "Indian Territory" to smaller, scattered reservations
• Allotment Era (1887-1934) led to significant loss of Native American land through individual land ownership policies
• Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 halted allotment and promoted tribal self-governance
• Termination policy (1940s-1960s) sought to end federal recognition of tribes, later reversed
• Self-Determination Era (1975-present) increased tribal control over reservation affairs

Current reservation statistics

• 326 Indian reservations in the United States as of 2023
• Vary greatly in size, from the Navajo Nation (27,413 square miles) to small California rancherias
• Home to approximately 22% of the 5.2 million Native Americans in the U.S.
• Located in 35 states, with the highest concentration in western states

Land and resources

• Land and resource management on reservations intertwines with complex issues of sovereignty, federal trust responsibility, and economic development
• Historically, reservation lands have been subject to exploitation and mismanagement by both federal agencies and outside interests
• Current efforts focus on sustainable resource use and economic development while preserving cultural and environmental integrity

Reservation land ownership

• Trust land held by federal government for benefit of tribes or individual Native Americans
• Fee simple land owned outright by tribes or individual Native Americans
• Fractionated ownership due to allotment policies complicates land use and management
• Checkerboard pattern of ownership within reservation boundaries creates jurisdictional issues

Natural resource management

• Tribes have varying degrees of control over natural resources on reservation lands
• Management includes timber, minerals, oil and gas, water rights, and wildlife
• Tribal resource management often integrates traditional ecological knowledge with modern practices
• Conflicts arise between tribal interests and federal or state regulations (hunting and fishing rights)

Environmental challenges

• Many reservations face environmental degradation from past and present resource extraction
• Water pollution from mining and agricultural runoff affects numerous reservations
• Climate change disproportionately impacts reservations, threatening traditional food sources and cultural practices
• Limited funding and capacity hinder environmental protection and restoration efforts

Housing and infrastructure

• Housing and infrastructure on reservations often lag behind national standards, reflecting historical neglect and underfunding
• Improving living conditions on reservations remains a significant challenge for tribal governments and federal agencies
• Infrastructure development intersects with issues of sovereignty, land use, and economic development

Housing conditions

• Overcrowding affects many reservation households, with multiple families sharing single-family homes
• Substandard housing prevalent, with issues of mold, inadequate insulation, and structural problems
• Housing shortage on many reservations leads to long waiting lists for tribal housing programs
• Native American Housing Assistance and Self-Determination Act (NAHASDA) provides funding for tribal housing initiatives

Water and sanitation

• Many reservation homes lack access to clean running water and adequate sanitation systems
• Water quality issues stem from contamination of groundwater and surface water sources
• Aging or non-existent water infrastructure contributes to health problems and limits economic development
• Tribal water rights often contested, impacting water availability for domestic and agricultural use

Electricity and internet access

• Rural location of many reservations results in limited access to reliable electricity
• High energy costs burden many reservation households
• Digital divide persists, with lower rates of broadband internet access compared to national average
• Lack of internet connectivity impacts education, healthcare, and economic opportunities

Economic conditions

• Economic conditions on reservations generally lag behind national averages, reflecting historical marginalization and limited resources
• Tribal governments and federal agencies work to address economic challenges through various initiatives and programs
• Economic development efforts often balance traditional values with modern economic opportunities

Poverty rates

• Poverty rates on reservations significantly higher than national average, often exceeding 25-30%
• Child poverty particularly acute, with some reservations experiencing rates over 50%
• Factors contributing to high poverty rates include limited job opportunities, geographic isolation, and historical trauma
• Poverty interconnected with other social issues, including health disparities and educational challenges

Employment opportunities

• Limited job markets on many reservations due to geographic isolation and lack of infrastructure
• High unemployment rates, often several times the national average
• Seasonal and part-time work common, leading to underemployment
• Tribal governments often largest employers on reservations, followed by federal agencies

Tribal enterprises

• Gaming operations significant source of revenue for some tribes (Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988)
• Tourism and cultural attractions provide economic opportunities (museums, cultural centers)
• Natural resource-based enterprises include timber, mining, and renewable energy projects
• Challenges in attracting outside businesses due to complex regulatory environment and limited infrastructure