8.4 Trail of Broken Treaties

The Trail of Broken Treaties protest in 1972 marked a pivotal moment in Native American activism. It brought national attention to ongoing treaty violations and systemic injustices faced by indigenous communities. The protest emerged from the civil rights era, drawing inspiration from other movements while highlighting unique Native American struggles.

Organized by groups like the American Indian Movement, the protest involved a cross-country caravan to Washington D.C. It culminated in the occupation of the Bureau of Indian Affairs building, forcing the government to address Native grievances and sparking debates on federal Indian policy.

Background of protest movement

• Native American activism in the 1960s and 1970s emerged as a response to centuries of oppression and marginalization
• Trail of Broken Treaties protest connected to broader civil rights movements of the era, highlighting unique struggles of indigenous peoples
• Aimed to bring national attention to the ongoing violations of treaty rights and systemic injustices faced by Native American communities

Roots in civil rights era

Top images from around the web for Roots in civil rights era

• 

  The Civil Rights Movement Continues | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Educational Resources - Baltimore’s Civil Rights Heritage View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Culture and Activism | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Civil Rights Movement Continues | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Educational Resources - Baltimore’s Civil Rights Heritage View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Roots in civil rights era

• 

  The Civil Rights Movement Continues | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Educational Resources - Baltimore’s Civil Rights Heritage View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Culture and Activism | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Civil Rights Movement Continues | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Educational Resources - Baltimore’s Civil Rights Heritage View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Inspired by African American civil rights movement, Native Americans adopted similar tactics of nonviolent resistance and direct action
• Red Power movement gained momentum, emphasizing cultural pride and self-determination for indigenous peoples
• Increased awareness of Native American issues among younger generations fueled activism on college campuses

AIM and other organizations

• American Indian Movement (AIM) founded in 1968 to address poverty, housing, treaty issues, and police harassment
• National Indian Youth Council (NIYC) focused on education and cultural preservation
• National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) worked through legal and political channels to advocate for Native rights

Grievances and demands

• Violations of treaty obligations by the U.S. government, including land seizures and resource exploitation
• Lack of economic opportunities and inadequate healthcare in Native communities
• Cultural suppression through forced assimilation policies and boarding schools
• Demand for tribal sovereignty and self-governance

Planning and organization

• Trail of Broken Treaties protest conceived as a peaceful demonstration to highlight Native American concerns
• Organizers drew inspiration from historical events like the 1830s Trail of Tears to emphasize ongoing injustices
• Extensive coordination among various tribal nations and activist groups to mobilize participants across the country

Twenty-point manifesto

• Comprehensive document outlining specific demands and proposed solutions for Native American issues
• Called for restoration of treaty-making authority between tribes and federal government
• Demanded review of treaty violations and restitution for broken agreements
• Proposed reforms in areas of health, education, and economic development on reservations

Cross-country caravan

• Caravans organized from Seattle, San Francisco, and Los Angeles to converge on Washington D.C.
• Participants traveled in cars, vans, and buses, gathering supporters along the route
• Stops made at reservations and urban Native communities to raise awareness and recruit more protesters

Arrival in Washington D.C.

• Protesters arrived in the capital on November 1, 1972, initially seeking meetings with government officials
• Lack of adequate accommodations and perceived dismissal by authorities led to frustration among demonstrators
• Decision made to occupy the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) building as a form of direct action

Occupation of BIA building

• Unprecedented takeover of a federal building by Native American activists
• Highlighted the desperation and determination of protesters to have their grievances addressed
• Sparked national debate on Native American rights and federal Indian policy

Takeover and initial response

• Protesters entered BIA headquarters on November 2, 1972, initially intending a brief sit-in
• Occupation quickly escalated as more demonstrators joined and barricaded themselves inside
• Government officials initially hesitant to use force, fearing violent confrontation and negative publicity

Negotiations with government

• White House representatives engaged in talks with protest leaders to address demands
• Negotiations complicated by diverse interests within the protest group and government reluctance to make concessions
• Discussions centered on implementation of twenty-point manifesto and immediate needs of occupiers

Duration and conditions

• Occupation lasted six days, from November 2 to November 8, 1972
• Protesters faced challenges of food shortages, sanitation issues, and overcrowding in the building
• Supporters outside provided supplies and moral support to those inside the BIA offices

Government reaction

• Federal response to the Trail of Broken Treaties protest reflected complex political considerations
• Balancing act between addressing legitimate grievances and maintaining law and order
• Incident highlighted need for comprehensive reform in federal-tribal relations

Nixon administration's approach

• Initially sought to avoid violent confrontation, preferring negotiation over forceful removal
• President Nixon's policy of Indian self-determination influenced handling of the protest
• Administration faced pressure from Congress and public to end the occupation quickly

Law enforcement involvement

• Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) monitored situation closely, gathering intelligence on protest leaders
• Local police and federal marshals maintained perimeter around BIA building
• Restraint exercised in use of force to prevent escalation and potential violence

Media coverage and public opinion

• National news outlets provided extensive coverage of the occupation, raising public awareness
• Mixed reactions from American public, ranging from sympathy for Native causes to criticism of protest tactics
• Debate sparked on treatment of Native Americans and effectiveness of federal Indian policies

Aftermath and consequences

• Trail of Broken Treaties protest had immediate and long-lasting impacts on Native American activism and federal policy
• Demonstrated power of organized indigenous resistance to effect change
• Set precedent for future Native American protest movements and direct actions

Damage to BIA offices

• Extensive damage reported to BIA headquarters during occupation, including destruction of documents
• Controversy over extent of damage and responsibility for repairs
• Loss of records created administrative challenges for BIA operations in subsequent months

Legal repercussions for protesters

• Some participants faced criminal charges related to property damage and trespassing
• Legal defense committees formed to support arrested protesters
• Cases highlighted issues of tribal sovereignty and jurisdiction in federal prosecutions

Policy changes and reforms

• Increased funding allocated for Native American programs in response to protest demands
• Review of federal Indian policies initiated, leading to reforms in areas of education and healthcare
• Greater emphasis placed on tribal consultation in decision-making processes affecting Native communities

Long-term impact

• Trail of Broken Treaties marked a turning point in Native American activism and federal-tribal relations
• Influenced subsequent generations of indigenous leaders and activists
• Contributed to shift in public perception of Native American issues and rights

Native American activism

• Inspired formation of new indigenous rights organizations and grassroots movements
• Encouraged more Native Americans to engage in political processes and advocacy
• Strengthened inter-tribal cooperation and solidarity in addressing shared concerns

Federal Indian policy shifts

• Accelerated move away from termination policy towards self-determination for tribes
• Led to passage of key legislation like the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975
• Increased recognition of tribal sovereignty in government-to-government relations

Legacy in indigenous rights movement

• Served as model for future protests and occupations (Wounded Knee occupation in 1973)
• Contributed to development of international indigenous rights frameworks
• Continues to inspire contemporary Native American activism and advocacy efforts

Key figures and leaders

• Trail of Broken Treaties brought together diverse group of Native American activists and leaders
• Protest highlighted emergence of new generation of indigenous advocates
• Leadership dynamics reflected complex relationships within Native American activist community

Dennis Banks

• Co-founder of American Indian Movement (AIM) and key organizer of the protest
• Played crucial role in negotiations with government officials during BIA occupation
• Continued activism in subsequent years, focusing on Native American rights and environmental issues

Russell Means

• Prominent AIM leader and spokesperson during the Trail of Broken Treaties
• Known for charismatic public speaking and media engagement during the protest
• Later career included acting, writing, and continued advocacy for indigenous causes

Other prominent participants

• Clyde Bellecourt, AIM co-founder and strategist for the protest
• Vernon Bellecourt, AIM leader who focused on international indigenous rights
• Grace Thorpe, daughter of Jim Thorpe, who provided logistical support and media liaison

Historical context

• Trail of Broken Treaties occurred against backdrop of changing federal Indian policies
• Protest reflected cumulative impact of decades of harmful government actions towards Native Americans
• Demonstrated ongoing effects of historical trauma and dispossession on indigenous communities

Termination policy

• Federal policy from 1940s to 1960s aimed at ending government recognition of tribes
• Resulted in loss of tribal status and land for many Native communities
• Created economic hardship and cultural disruption, fueling discontent among Native Americans

Relocation programs

• Government initiatives encouraged Native Americans to move from reservations to urban areas
• Promised job opportunities and better living conditions often failed to materialize
• Led to isolation and loss of cultural connections for many relocated individuals

Alcatraz occupation influence

• 19-month occupation of Alcatraz Island by Native activists from 1969 to 1971
• Demonstrated effectiveness of prolonged protest actions in gaining national attention
• Provided organizational experience and networks utilized in planning Trail of Broken Treaties

Cultural significance

• Trail of Broken Treaties represented resurgence of Native American cultural pride and identity
• Protest emphasized importance of traditional values and practices in contemporary context
• Challenged dominant narratives about indigenous peoples in American society

Symbolism of broken treaties

• Name of protest highlighted long history of treaty violations by U.S. government
• Emphasized ongoing nature of injustices faced by Native American communities
• Connected contemporary struggles to historical experiences of indigenous peoples

Revitalization of Native identity

• Protest encouraged renewed interest in traditional languages, customs, and spirituality
• Fostered sense of pan-Indian unity while respecting diversity of tribal cultures
• Inspired Native Americans, especially youth, to reconnect with their heritage

Artistic and literary representations

• Protest inspired Native American artists to create works reflecting themes of resistance and cultural revival
• Literature, music, and visual arts incorporated elements of Trail of Broken Treaties experience
• Contributed to growth of Native American studies programs in universities

Contemporary relevance

• Issues raised by Trail of Broken Treaties continue to resonate in present-day Native American activism
• Protest serves as historical reference point for ongoing struggles for indigenous rights
• Lessons from 1972 inform current strategies for addressing Native American concerns

Ongoing treaty disputes

• Many tribes continue to seek enforcement of historical treaty obligations
• Land rights, resource management, and jurisdictional issues remain contentious
• Legal battles over treaty interpretations persist in federal courts

Modern Native American protests

• Recent actions like Standing Rock Sioux protest against Dakota Access Pipeline draw parallels to Trail of Broken Treaties
• Social media and digital technologies provide new platforms for organizing and raising awareness
• Increased collaboration between Native and non-Native allies in contemporary protest movements

Comparisons with recent movements

• Trail of Broken Treaties tactics and messaging compared to Black Lives Matter and other social justice movements
• Similarities in demands for systemic change and recognition of historical injustices
• Differences in specific cultural contexts and relationships with federal government