6.3 Tribal Sovereign Immunity

Tribal sovereign immunity shields Native American tribes from lawsuits without their consent. This powerful legal doctrine extends to off-reservation activities and commercial ventures, allowing tribes to protect their interests and foster economic development.

Congress can limit tribal sovereignty through legislation, while tribes may voluntarily waive immunity for specific purposes. The "arm of the tribe" doctrine determines which entities share in a tribe's immunity, balancing tribal autonomy with practical considerations.

Sovereign Immunity and Tribal Sovereignty

The Foundations of Tribal Sovereignty

Top images from around the web for The Foundations of Tribal Sovereignty

• 

  What's tribal sovereignty and what does it mean for Native Americans? View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty in the United States - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty (Vereinigte Staaten) – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What's tribal sovereignty and what does it mean for Native Americans? View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty in the United States - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for The Foundations of Tribal Sovereignty

• 

  What's tribal sovereignty and what does it mean for Native Americans? View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty in the United States - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty (Vereinigte Staaten) – Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What's tribal sovereignty and what does it mean for Native Americans? View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tribal sovereignty in the United States - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Sovereign immunity is a legal doctrine that prevents a sovereign entity from being sued without its consent, protecting it from legal actions brought by individuals or other entities
• Tribal sovereignty refers to the inherent authority of indigenous tribes to govern themselves and manage their internal affairs (self-determination) as independent political communities
• Plenary power is the complete and absolute power of Congress to legislate on matters affecting Indian tribes, which can limit or modify tribal sovereignty through federal legislation
• Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez (1978) upheld tribal sovereign immunity, ruling that tribes cannot be sued in federal court without congressional authorization or a clear waiver by the tribe itself
• Kiowa Tribe of Oklahoma v. Manufacturing Technologies (1998) reaffirmed that tribal sovereign immunity extends to off-reservation commercial activities, protecting tribes from lawsuits arising from business transactions

The Scope and Limits of Tribal Authority

• Tribal sovereignty and immunity generally extend to off-reservation activities, allowing tribes to engage in commercial ventures and maintain governmental functions beyond the boundaries of their reservations
• Commercial activities undertaken by tribes, such as operating businesses (casinos) or entering into contracts, are typically protected by sovereign immunity unless expressly waived
• Governmental functions performed by tribal governments, including providing services (healthcare) and enforcing laws, are shielded from legal challenges due to the tribe's inherent sovereignty
• The arm of the tribe doctrine determines whether an entity is sufficiently connected to the tribe to share in its sovereign immunity, considering factors like the entity's creation, purpose, and control by the tribal government

Scope of Tribal Sovereign Immunity

Off-Reservation and Commercial Activities

• Tribal sovereign immunity extends to off-reservation activities, protecting tribes from lawsuits related to their conduct or transactions outside the boundaries of their reservations
• Commercial activities undertaken by tribes, such as operating businesses (casinos, hotels) or entering into contracts with non-tribal entities, are generally shielded by sovereign immunity
• Tribes can engage in a wide range of economic ventures off-reservation while maintaining their immunity from suit, fostering economic development and self-sufficiency
• However, tribes may choose to waive their immunity for specific off-reservation commercial activities to facilitate business transactions and partnerships

Governmental Functions and the Arm of the Tribe Doctrine

• Tribal sovereign immunity applies to governmental functions performed by tribal governments, such as providing essential services (healthcare, education) and enforcing tribal laws and regulations
• These governmental activities are protected from legal challenges, allowing tribes to exercise their inherent sovereignty and maintain control over their internal affairs
• The arm of the tribe doctrine is used to determine whether an entity is sufficiently connected to the tribe to share in its sovereign immunity, based on factors like the entity's creation, purpose, and control by the tribal government
• Entities that are closely tied to the tribe and serve a governmental purpose (housing authorities, tribal colleges) are more likely to be considered arms of the tribe and benefit from sovereign immunity

Limitations and Waivers

Congressional Authority and Tribal Consent

• Congress has the power to waive tribal sovereign immunity through legislation, subjecting tribes to lawsuits in specific circumstances or for particular activities
• Tribes may also voluntarily waive their own immunity, either broadly or for specific purposes (contracts, business agreements), to facilitate economic development or resolve disputes
• Waivers of tribal immunity must be clear and unequivocal, expressly stating the tribe's intent to allow lawsuits against it in a particular context
• The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (1975) allows tribes to enter into contracts with the federal government to assume control over programs and services, while maintaining their sovereign immunity

Tribal Court Jurisdiction and Official Immunity

• Tribal courts have jurisdiction over civil and criminal matters arising on tribal lands, providing a forum for resolving disputes and enforcing tribal laws
• However, tribal court jurisdiction is limited by federal law (Indian Civil Rights Act) and may not extend to certain cases involving non-members or off-reservation conduct
• Tribal officials, like council members or employees, may be entitled to official immunity when acting within the scope of their duties, protecting them from personal liability for their actions
• In some cases, tribal officials may be sued in their individual capacities for violations of federal law (civil rights claims) or when they act outside the scope of their authority