2.4 Motivation and persuasion

Motivation plays a crucial role in persuasion, influencing how people process and respond to messages. The Elaboration Likelihood Model explains how motivation levels determine whether central or peripheral processing occurs, affecting the effectiveness of persuasive attempts.

Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations impact persuasion differently. Understanding various needs and motivational theories helps craft more effective appeals. By tailoring messages to individual differences and psychological functions, persuaders can increase their chances of success.

Motivation in Persuasion

Role of Motivation in Persuasion Process

Top images from around the web for Role of Motivation in Persuasion Process

• 

  Motivation | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attitudes and Persuasion – Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Oil Drum | Resource Depletion, Persuasion, and the Ongoing World Meme View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Motivation | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attitudes and Persuasion – Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Role of Motivation in Persuasion Process

• 

  Motivation | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attitudes and Persuasion – Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Oil Drum | Resource Depletion, Persuasion, and the Ongoing World Meme View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Motivation | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attitudes and Persuasion – Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Motivation drives persuasion process by influencing how individuals process and respond to persuasive messages
• Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM) posits motivation affects route of persuasion
  • Determines whether central or peripheral processing occurs
• High motivation leads to thorough processing of persuasive arguments
  • Increases likelihood of attitude change through central route
• Low motivation results in reliance on peripheral cues
  • Source attractiveness or message length rather than content
• Motivation level influenced by factors
  • Personal relevance
  • Need for cognition
  • Situational variables (time constraints, distractions)
• Motivation interacts with ability and opportunity
  • Determines extent of message elaboration
  • Affects persuasion effectiveness

Factors Influencing Motivation in Persuasion

• Personal involvement enhances motivation to process message
  • Example: Health message more motivating if relevant to individual's condition
• Need for cognition affects motivation to engage with complex arguments
  • High NFC individuals more motivated by detailed, logical appeals
• Time pressure can decrease motivation for thorough processing
  • Example: Quick decisions rely more on peripheral cues
• Mood states impact motivation to scrutinize persuasive messages
  • Positive mood may decrease motivation for effortful processing
• Prior knowledge on topic influences motivation to engage with new information
  • Experts may be more motivated to critically evaluate claims in their field

Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation

Types of Motivational Factors

• Intrinsic motivation stems from internal factors driving behavior
  • Personal interest
  • Enjoyment
  • Alignment with values
• Extrinsic motivation involves external rewards or punishments influencing behavior
  • Monetary incentives
  • Social approval
  • Grades or performance evaluations
• Self-Determination Theory (SDT) explains intrinsic and extrinsic motivations on continuum
  • Affects persuasion differently based on internalization level

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Factors in Persuasion

• Intrinsic motivational factors in persuasion include
  • Curiosity about new information or perspectives
  • Desire for self-improvement or personal growth
  • Personal relevance of topic to individual's goals
• Extrinsic motivational factors in persuasion encompass
  • Social pressure from peers or authority figures
  • Fear of missing out (FOMO) on opportunities or experiences
  • Tangible rewards (discounts, prizes) or punishments (fines, penalties)
• Effectiveness varies depending on target audience and nature of persuasive message
  • Example: Health campaign appealing to intrinsic desire for wellness vs. extrinsic fear of illness
• Overreliance on extrinsic motivators can undermine intrinsic motivation
  • Overjustification effect occurs when external rewards decrease internal drive
  • Example: Paying children for reading may reduce their inherent enjoyment of books

Needs and Persuasive Appeals

Frameworks for Understanding Needs in Persuasion

• Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs provides framework for targeting different need levels in appeals
  • Example: Safety needs addressed in insurance advertisements
  • Self-actualization needs targeted in personal development courses
• Functional Approach to Attitudes suggests attitudes serve specific psychological functions
  • Can be leveraged in persuasive appeals
  • Example: Value-expressive function targeted in cause-related marketing
• Need for cognition (NFC) influences preference for complex or simple persuasive messages
  • Affects effectiveness of different appeal types
  • High NFC individuals prefer detailed, logical arguments
  • Low NFC individuals more persuaded by simple cues or emotional appeals
• Regulatory Focus Theory distinguishes between promotion-focused and prevention-focused individuals
  • Affects receptiveness to gain-framed or loss-framed appeals
  • Example: Health message framed as gaining benefits vs. avoiding risks

Matching Needs to Persuasive Strategies

• Need for uniqueness exploited in appeals emphasizing exclusivity or individuality
  • Example: Limited edition products or VIP memberships
• Self-actualization needs addressed through messages appealing to
  • Personal growth
  • Self-expression
  • Fulfillment of potential
• Functional matching enhances effectiveness of persuasion attempts
  • Aligning appeal with specific psychological function served by attitude
  • Example: Social-adjustive function targeted in peer influence campaigns
• Tailoring messages to individual differences in needs improves persuasion outcomes
  • Personalized marketing based on consumer preferences and behaviors
  • Segmentation of audience based on psychographic profiles

Motivational Theories for Persuasion

Applying Expectancy and Goal Theories

• Expectancy-Value Theory used to design messages highlighting
  • Likelihood of success in achieving desired outcome
  • Value or importance of outcome to individual
  • Example: Weight loss program emphasizing ease of following diet and health benefits
• Goal-Setting Theory principles incorporated into persuasive strategies by emphasizing
  • Specific goals (lose 10 pounds in 2 months)
  • Challenging yet attainable objectives
  • Feedback mechanisms to track progress
• Self-Efficacy Theory suggests boosting audience's confidence in ability to perform desired behavior
  • Providing step-by-step instructions or demonstrations
  • Highlighting success stories of similar individuals
  • Example: Smoking cessation campaign showcasing testimonials from ex-smokers

Behavioral Change and Social Influence Theories

• Transtheoretical Model of Change guides tailoring of messages to different stages of readiness
  • Precontemplation stage requires awareness-raising messages
  • Action stage needs practical support and reinforcement
• Social Cognitive Theory informs strategies by leveraging
  • Observational learning through role models
  • Modeling of desired behaviors in media campaigns
  • Example: Anti-bullying program featuring peer educators
• Theory of Planned Behavior applied to address
  • Attitudes towards behavior
  • Subjective norms or social expectations
  • Perceived behavioral control or self-efficacy
  • Example: Environmental campaign targeting beliefs, social pressure, and ease of recycling
• Cognitive Dissonance Theory utilized to create strategies highlighting inconsistencies
  • Between attitudes and behaviors
  • Motivating change to reduce psychological discomfort
  • Example: Campaign pointing out discrepancy between stated environmental values and wasteful habits