15.4 Ethical considerations in physiological psychology research

Ethical considerations in physiological psychology research are crucial for protecting participants and ensuring scientific integrity. Researchers must balance the pursuit of knowledge with the well-being of subjects, adhering to principles like respect, beneficence, and justice outlined in the Belmont Report.

Key ethical issues include informed consent, participant rights, and the role of Institutional Review Boards. Animal research requires special consideration, guided by the 3Rs principle: replacement, reduction, and refinement. Transparency and responsible practices are essential for maintaining public trust in physiological psychology research.

Ethical Principles in Physiological Psychology

Fundamental Ethical Guidelines

Top images from around the web for Fundamental Ethical Guidelines

• 

  The three moral codes of behaviour | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Principles of Ethics in Psychology by Frederatic on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The three moral codes of behaviour | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Principles of Ethics in Psychology by Frederatic on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Fundamental Ethical Guidelines

• 

  The three moral codes of behaviour | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Principles of Ethics in Psychology by Frederatic on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The three moral codes of behaviour | Clamor World View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  4 Principles of Ethics in Psychology by Frederatic on DeviantArt View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• The Belmont Report outlines three fundamental ethical principles guiding physiological psychology research
  • Respect for persons upholds individual autonomy and protects those with diminished autonomy
  • Beneficence maximizes benefits and minimizes harm to research participants
  • Justice ensures fair distribution of research benefits and burdens across populations
• Non-maleficence requires researchers to avoid causing harm to participants in physiological psychology studies
  • Includes physical harm (tissue damage), psychological harm (emotional distress), and social harm (stigmatization)
  • Researchers must carefully weigh potential risks against expected benefits
• Confidentiality and privacy protect participants' personal information and data throughout the research process
  • Involves secure data storage, limited access to identifiable information, and anonymization of published results
  • Particularly crucial in studies involving sensitive physiological or behavioral data (genetic information, brain imaging)

Integrity and Responsibility in Research

• Scientific integrity emphasizes honest reporting and proper data management in physiological psychology studies
  • Avoiding fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism of research data
  • Maintaining detailed records of experimental procedures and raw data
  • Reporting all relevant results, including those that do not support the hypothesis
• Ethical guidelines address issues specific to physiological psychology research
  • Invasive procedures (electrode implantation, tissue sampling)
  • Brain stimulation techniques (transcranial magnetic stimulation, deep brain stimulation)
  • Use of psychoactive substances (effects on cognition, behavior, or brain function)
• Social responsibility encourages researchers to consider broader implications of their studies
  • Potential misuse of research findings (neuroenhancement, behavior manipulation)
  • Impact on public perception of neuroscience and psychology
  • Addressing societal issues through research (mental health, neurological disorders)

Informed Consent and Participant Rights

Elements of Informed Consent

• Informed consent provides potential participants with comprehensive study information
  • Detailed explanation of research purpose, procedures, and duration
  • Full disclosure of potential risks and benefits
  • Information on compensation and available alternatives to participation
• Valid informed consent requires four key elements
  • Voluntariness ensures participation is free from coercion or undue influence
  • Capacity refers to the participant's ability to understand and make decisions
  • Disclosure of information must be complete and in language accessible to participants
  • Comprehension requires participants to demonstrate understanding of provided information
• Participants have the right to withdraw from a study at any time without penalty
  • Must be clearly communicated during the informed consent process
  • Researchers should explain the procedure for withdrawing and any potential consequences

Special Considerations in Informed Consent

• Vulnerable populations require additional protections in physiological psychology research
  • Children may need parental consent and age-appropriate assent procedures
  • Cognitively impaired individuals may require consent from legally authorized representatives
  • Prisoners may need safeguards against coercion or undue influence
• Therapeutic misconception must be addressed in informed consent
  • Clearly distinguishing between research procedures and clinical care
  • Explaining that participation may not provide direct medical benefits
  • Particularly important in studies involving experimental treatments or interventions
• Ongoing consent is crucial in longitudinal physiological psychology studies
  • Periodically reaffirming participants' willingness to continue
  • Providing updates on any new findings or changes to the research protocol
  • Allowing participants to reassess their involvement as the study progresses

Role of Institutional Review Boards

IRB Structure and Functions

• Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) review and approve research proposals to ensure ethical standards
  • Protect human subjects from potential harm or exploitation
  • Ensure compliance with federal regulations and institutional policies
  • Provide guidance to researchers on ethical issues in study design and implementation
• IRB composition includes diverse perspectives on ethical considerations
  • Scientists with relevant expertise in the field of study
  • Non-scientists to represent broader ethical and societal concerns
  • Community members to provide input from potential participant perspectives
• IRBs assess the risk-benefit ratio of proposed physiological psychology studies
  • Evaluating potential benefits to participants (improved treatment options)
  • Considering societal benefits (advancement of scientific knowledge)
  • Weighing these against risks to participants (physical discomfort, psychological stress)

IRB Review Process and Authority

• IRB review process evaluates multiple aspects of research protocols
  • Study design and scientific validity of the proposed research
  • Adequacy of informed consent procedures and materials
  • Plans for protecting participant privacy and data confidentiality
  • Measures to minimize risks and ensure participant safety
• IRBs have authority to oversee and modify research protocols
  • Requiring changes to study procedures or consent forms
  • Monitoring ongoing studies for compliance with approved protocols
  • Suspending or terminating research that violates ethical standards
• Expedited review and exempt status streamline approval for minimal risk studies
  • Expedited review for research involving non-invasive procedures (EEG, behavioral tasks)
  • Exempt status for studies using existing data or anonymous surveys
• IRBs address ethical challenges specific to physiological psychology
  • Use of deception in experimental paradigms
  • Ethical considerations in neuroimaging studies (incidental findings)
  • Genetic testing and handling of genetic information

Ethical Considerations in Animal Research

Guiding Principles for Animal Research

• The 3Rs principle guides ethical animal research in physiological psychology
  • Replacement seeks alternatives to animal models when possible (cell cultures, computer simulations)
  • Reduction minimizes the number of animals used through improved experimental design
  • Refinement enhances animal welfare and minimizes suffering during experiments
• Ethical justification requires demonstrating benefits outweigh costs to animals
  • Potential advancements in understanding brain function and behavior
  • Improvements in treating neurological or psychiatric disorders
  • Contributions to animal health and welfare
• Species selection considers phylogenetic proximity in physiological psychology research
  • Using the lowest possible species that can appropriately model the process under investigation
  • Balancing scientific validity with ethical concerns about using more complex organisms

Animal Welfare and Research Practices

• Proper animal care and housing conditions are essential ethical considerations
  • Providing appropriate nutrition, temperature, and lighting
  • Ensuring adequate space and opportunities for species-typical behaviors
  • Implementing environmental enrichment (toys, social housing) to promote well-being
• Pain management and humane endpoints minimize animal suffering
  • Using appropriate anesthesia and analgesia during invasive procedures
  • Establishing clear criteria for study termination based on animal welfare indicators
  • Regularly monitoring animals for signs of distress or discomfort
• Cumulative severity addresses the total impact of research on animal well-being
  • Considering the combined effects of multiple procedures or long-term studies
  • Implementing strategies to mitigate cumulative stress or discomfort
  • Balancing scientific goals with the overall quality of life for research animals
• Transparency and public engagement foster trust in animal research
  • Providing clear explanations of the necessity and benefits of animal studies
  • Engaging in open dialogue about ethical considerations and animal welfare practices
  • Demonstrating commitment to responsible and humane animal research in physiological psychology