7.2 Civic nationalism

Civic nationalism defines national identity through shared political values and citizenship, not ethnicity or culture. It emphasizes loyalty to institutions, equal rights, and common civic ideals to unite diverse populations under one national banner.

This approach contrasts with ethnic nationalism, which bases belonging on ancestry or heritage. Civic nationalism aims to foster unity in multicultural societies by focusing on shared principles rather than cultural homogeneity.

Definition of civic nationalism

• Civic nationalism is a form of nationalism that emphasizes shared political values, institutions, and citizenship as the basis for national identity and belonging
• Contrasts with ethnic nationalism, which defines national identity based on common ancestry, language, or cultural heritage
• Civic nationalism aims to create a sense of unity and loyalty among citizens regardless of their ethnic, religious, or cultural background

Key principles of civic nationalism

Shared values and ideals

Top images from around the web for Shared values and ideals

• 

  Elements of Democracy | "According to political scientist La… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  America’s Most Important Values – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Securing Basic Freedoms | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Elements of Democracy | "According to political scientist La… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  America’s Most Important Values – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Shared values and ideals

• 

  Elements of Democracy | "According to political scientist La… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  America’s Most Important Values – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Securing Basic Freedoms | American National Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Elements of Democracy | "According to political scientist La… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  America’s Most Important Values – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Civic nationalism is built upon a set of shared political values and ideals that form the foundation of national identity
• These values often include principles such as democracy, individual rights, rule of law, and equality before the law
• By emphasizing shared values, civic nationalism seeks to create a sense of common purpose and belonging among citizens

Loyalty to political institutions

• Civic nationalism places a strong emphasis on loyalty to the political institutions of the nation, such as the constitution, government, and legal system
• Citizens are expected to demonstrate their commitment to the nation by participating in the political process and respecting the authority of state institutions
• This loyalty to institutions is seen as a key factor in maintaining national stability and unity

Importance of citizenship

• In civic nationalism, citizenship is the primary marker of national identity and belonging
• Citizenship is typically based on birth within the nation's territory or through a process of naturalization that requires adherence to the nation's values and laws
• The rights and responsibilities of citizenship, such as voting, paying taxes, and serving in the military, are central to the civic nationalist conception of national identity

Civic vs ethnic nationalism

Differences in membership criteria

• Civic nationalism defines national membership based on shared political values and citizenship, while ethnic nationalism emphasizes common ancestry, language, or cultural heritage as the basis for belonging
• In civic nationalism, individuals can become members of the nation through a process of integration and adoption of shared values, while ethnic nationalism often sees national identity as fixed and inherited
• Civic nationalism is generally more inclusive and open to diversity, while ethnic nationalism tends to be more exclusive and homogenizing

Contrasting views on diversity

• Civic nationalism sees diversity as compatible with national unity, as long as all citizens share a commitment to the nation's political values and institutions
• Ethnic nationalism, on the other hand, often views diversity as a threat to national identity and seeks to maintain cultural and ethnic homogeneity
• Civic nationalism may promote policies of multiculturalism and minority rights, while ethnic nationalism may favor assimilation or exclusion of minority groups

Historical examples of civic nationalism

French Revolution and republicanism

• The French Revolution of 1789 marked a significant development in civic nationalism, as it sought to create a new national identity based on the principles of liberty, equality, and fraternity
• French republicanism emphasized the importance of citizenship and participation in the political process, regardless of social class or background
• The revolutionary slogan "liberté, égalité, fraternité" (liberty, equality, fraternity) encapsulated the civic nationalist ideal of a nation united by shared values and institutions

American founding principles

• The United States is often cited as an example of civic nationalism, with its founding principles of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" and its emphasis on "government of the people, by the people, for the people"
• The U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights enshrine civic nationalist values such as individual rights, rule of law, and representative government
• The American "melting pot" ideal, which envisions a nation where diverse immigrants can integrate into a shared national culture, reflects a civic nationalist approach to diversity

Civic nationalism in contemporary politics

Role in multicultural societies

• Civic nationalism is often seen as a way to manage diversity and promote unity in multicultural societies
• By emphasizing shared political values and institutions, civic nationalism can provide a common framework for citizens of different ethnic, religious, or cultural backgrounds to coexist and cooperate
• However, the success of civic nationalism in multicultural contexts depends on the ability to define and maintain a set of shared values that are inclusive and acceptable to all groups

Debates over assimilation vs pluralism

• Within civic nationalist frameworks, there are often debates over the extent to which minority groups should assimilate into the majority culture or maintain their distinct identities
• Some argue that civic nationalism requires a degree of cultural assimilation to ensure social cohesion and a shared sense of national identity
• Others advocate for a more pluralistic approach, in which different groups can maintain their cultural identities while still participating in the shared political life of the nation
• These debates reflect the ongoing challenges of balancing unity and diversity within civic nationalist societies

Critiques of civic nationalism

Accusations of hidden ethnocentrism

• Some critics argue that civic nationalism, despite its claims to inclusivity, often has an implicit ethnocentric bias
• They point out that the "shared values" of civic nationalism are often derived from the majority culture and may not be truly representative of all groups within the nation
• This can lead to a form of cultural hegemony, in which minority groups are expected to conform to the norms and values of the dominant group

Challenges in defining shared values

• Another critique of civic nationalism is the difficulty in defining and agreeing upon a set of shared values that can form the basis of national identity
• In diverse societies, there may be significant disagreements over what values should be considered fundamental to the nation
• This can lead to conflicts and tensions between different groups, particularly if some feel that their values or interests are not being adequately represented or protected

Civic nationalism and globalization

Impact of transnational identities

• Globalization has led to the rise of transnational identities and allegiances that can challenge traditional notions of national identity and belonging
• As people become more mobile and connected across borders, they may develop a sense of identity that is not primarily tied to a single nation-state
• This can complicate the civic nationalist project of building a shared sense of national identity and loyalty among citizens

Civic nationalism in supranational organizations

• The development of supranational organizations, such as the European Union, has also posed challenges to traditional civic nationalist frameworks
• These organizations often seek to promote a sense of shared identity and values among their member states, which can sometimes conflict with national-level identities and loyalties
• However, supranational organizations can also be seen as an extension of civic nationalist principles, as they seek to create a shared political community based on common values and institutions

Future of civic nationalism

Adapting to changing demographics

• As societies become more diverse due to immigration, changing birth rates, and other demographic shifts, civic nationalism will need to adapt to maintain its relevance and effectiveness
• This may require a re-evaluation of what values and institutions are considered fundamental to national identity, and how to ensure that these are inclusive and representative of all groups within the nation
• It may also require new approaches to integration and accommodation of diversity, such as policies that promote intercultural dialogue and understanding

Balancing unity and diversity

• The future success of civic nationalism will depend on its ability to strike a balance between promoting national unity and respecting cultural diversity
• This will require ongoing negotiation and compromise among different groups within the nation, as well as a willingness to adapt and evolve in response to changing social and political realities
• Ultimately, the goal of civic nationalism should be to create a sense of shared belonging and purpose among citizens, while also recognizing and valuing the unique contributions and identities of different groups within the nation