10.5 Power and privilege

Power and privilege shape organizational dynamics, influencing who has influence and access to opportunities. Understanding these forces is crucial for navigating workplace politics and creating more equitable environments.

This topic explores sources of power, dimensions of privilege, and their impacts on individuals and organizational culture. It also examines strategies for challenging the status quo and fostering inclusion in professional settings.

Sources of power

• Power in organizations is derived from various sources that enable individuals to influence others and shape outcomes
• The ability to wield power effectively is a key determinant of success in organizational politics and leadership roles

Formal authority

Top images from around the web for Formal authority

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Understanding the Business Environment | OpenStax Intro to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Understanding the Business Environment | OpenStax Intro to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Formal authority

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Understanding the Business Environment | OpenStax Intro to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Understanding the Business Environment | OpenStax Intro to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Formal authority stems from an individual's official position or rank within the organizational hierarchy (manager, director)
• Individuals with formal authority have the legitimacy to make decisions, allocate resources, and enforce compliance
• Formal authority is often accompanied by symbols of status (corner office, executive parking spot) that reinforce power differentials
• The scope and impact of formal authority depend on the specific responsibilities and span of control associated with the position

Control over resources

• Control over resources, such as budgets, equipment, or personnel, confers power by creating dependency relationships
• Individuals who can grant or withhold access to critical resources have leverage over others who need those resources
• Resource control can be used to reward compliance, punish defiance, or negotiate favorable terms in transactions
• Examples of resources that provide power include financial assets (funding, investments), information (data, knowledge), and social capital (connections, endorsements)

Network centrality

• Network centrality refers to an individual's position within the web of relationships and interactions in an organization
• Central actors have more direct ties and shorter paths to other members of the network, granting them greater access and influence
• Centrality can be based on formal reporting structures (organizational chart) or informal social connections (friendship, advice-seeking)
• Brokers who bridge disconnected subgroups or span organizational boundaries (departments, divisions) often have high centrality and the ability to control information flows

Access to information

• Access to information, especially exclusive or privileged information, is a source of power in organizations
• Individuals with inside knowledge about strategic plans, market intelligence, or decision-making processes have an advantage over others
• Controlling the dissemination of information allows individuals to shape narratives, frame issues, and influence perceptions
• Examples of valuable information include financial data (budgets, projections), customer insights (preferences, complaints), and political intelligence (alliances, rivalries)

Interpersonal influence

• Interpersonal influence refers to the ability to shape others' attitudes, behaviors, and choices through personal qualities and social skills
• Charismatic individuals with strong communication abilities, emotional intelligence, and persuasion skills can rally support and inspire followership
• Influence can be based on expertise (subject matter knowledge, technical skills), relationships (trust, liking), or reciprocity (favors, obligations)
• Tactics of interpersonal influence include rational persuasion (logical arguments), inspirational appeals (shared vision), and consultation (seeking input)

Dimensions of privilege

• Privilege refers to the unearned advantages and benefits that accrue to members of dominant social groups based on their identities
• Privilege operates in multiple dimensions, shaping individuals' experiences, opportunities, and outcomes in organizations and society

Social identities

• Social identities are the various group memberships and categories that individuals belong to, such as race, gender, class, and sexuality
• These identities are socially constructed and carry different levels of power, status, and privilege in a given context
• Examples of privileged identities include being white (race), male (gender), upper-class (socioeconomic status), and heterosexual (sexual orientation)
• Marginalized identities, such as being a person of color, female, low-income, or LGBTQ+, face systemic barriers and discrimination

Dominant vs marginalized groups

• Dominant groups are those that hold disproportionate power, resources, and representation in a society or organization
• Marginalized groups are those that are systematically excluded, oppressed, or disadvantaged based on their social identities
• The dominant group is often seen as the default or norm, while marginalized groups are viewed as deviations or exceptions
• Examples of dominant groups include men in leadership positions, white employees in predominantly white organizations, and native English speakers in U.S. workplaces

Intersectionality of identities

• Intersectionality refers to the complex ways in which multiple social identities intersect and shape individuals' lived experiences
• People hold multiple identities simultaneously, and the combination of these identities creates unique forms of privilege or marginalization
• For example, a white woman may experience privilege based on her race but marginalization based on her gender, while a Black woman faces the compounded effects of both racism and sexism
• Intersectionality highlights the importance of considering the interplay of identities rather than treating them as separate or additive

Visible vs invisible privilege

• Privilege can be visible or invisible, depending on how easily it is recognized or acknowledged by others
• Visible forms of privilege, such as race or physical ability, are readily apparent and often carry overt advantages or disadvantages
• Invisible forms of privilege, such as class, sexuality, or mental health status, are less obvious but still shape individuals' experiences and opportunities
• Examples of invisible privilege include having a college-educated family background, being cisgender, or having no disabilities
• Invisible privilege can be harder to recognize and address because it is often taken for granted or normalized

Dynamics of power and privilege

• The interplay of power and privilege creates complex dynamics in organizations that shape interactions, decision-making, and outcomes
• These dynamics often reinforce existing inequalities and create barriers to inclusion and advancement for marginalized groups

Power imbalances in organizations

• Organizations are characterized by power imbalances, where some individuals or groups have greater influence and control than others
• Power imbalances can be based on formal hierarchies (executive vs entry-level), resource control (budget authority), or social identities (dominant vs marginalized groups)
• Imbalances create disparities in access to opportunities, rewards, and support, favoring those with more power
• Examples of power imbalances include pay gaps between men and women, underrepresentation of people of color in leadership, and limited accommodations for employees with disabilities

In-group favoritism

• In-group favoritism refers to the tendency for people to prefer and prioritize members of their own social groups over others
• This bias can lead to preferential treatment, allocation of resources, and evaluation of performance based on group membership rather than merit
• In-group favoritism reinforces power and privilege by creating advantages for dominant groups and exclusion of marginalized groups
• Examples include managers promoting employees who share their background, teams gravitating toward members with similar identities, and social cliques formed around common interests or experiences

Stereotyping and bias

• Stereotyping involves generalizing characteristics or behaviors to an entire social group, often based on limited or inaccurate information
• Bias refers to the prejudice or discrimination in favor of or against certain groups based on stereotypes or implicit associations
• Stereotyping and bias can lead to flawed decision-making, unfair treatment, and reduced opportunities for marginalized groups
• Examples include assuming women are less competent in technical roles, judging job candidates based on racial stereotypes, or excluding older workers from development opportunities

Microaggressions in the workplace

• Microaggressions are subtle, often unintentional slights or insults that communicate hostile or derogatory messages to members of marginalized groups
• These everyday indignities can take the form of comments, questions, or actions that invalidate or demean individuals based on their identities
• Microaggressions create a hostile or unwelcoming environment for marginalized employees, impacting their well-being, engagement, and retention
• Examples include asking a person of color where they are "really from," commenting on a woman's appearance in a professional setting, or expressing surprise at someone's language skills based on their accent

Systemic discrimination

• Systemic discrimination refers to the embedded, institutionalized practices and policies that create disadvantages for marginalized groups
• These barriers are woven into the fabric of organizations and society, reproducing inequalities and limiting access to resources and opportunities
• Systemic discrimination is often invisible or taken for granted because it is normalized and perpetuated through everyday actions and decisions
• Examples include biased hiring processes that favor dominant groups, lack of diversity in leadership pipelines, or workplace cultures that value conformity over inclusion

Maintaining the status quo

• Despite the harmful effects of power imbalances and privilege, the status quo often persists in organizations due to various factors that resist change
• These dynamics create a self-reinforcing cycle that perpetuates inequalities and marginalizes non-dominant groups

Normalization of inequality

• Inequality becomes normalized when disparities in power, resources, and representation are seen as natural or inevitable rather than as the result of systemic barriers
• This normalization is reinforced through socialization, media representations, and dominant cultural narratives that justify the status quo
• When inequality is taken for granted, it becomes harder to recognize and challenge, as it is seen as the default or accepted state of affairs
• Examples include the belief that men are naturally better suited for leadership roles, that certain groups are less qualified or motivated, or that diversity is a nice-to-have rather than a business imperative

Internalized dominance and oppression

• Internalized dominance refers to the unconscious beliefs and behaviors of privileged groups that reinforce their own superiority and entitlement
• Internalized oppression involves the acceptance and internalization of negative stereotypes and limitations by marginalized groups about their own abilities and worth
• These internalized beliefs shape individuals' self-perceptions, aspirations, and interactions with others, perpetuating power imbalances
• Examples include men feeling entitled to interrupt or talk over women, white employees not recognizing their own biases, or members of marginalized groups doubting their own competence or potential

Resistance to change

• Efforts to challenge the status quo and create more equitable organizations often face resistance from those who benefit from existing power structures
• This resistance can take the form of denial (minimizing the problem), defensiveness (justifying the status quo), or backlash (actively opposing change efforts)
• Resistance to change is often driven by fear of loss (power, status, resources), discomfort with uncertainty, or lack of understanding about the need for change
• Examples include managers dismissing diversity initiatives as unnecessary, employees complaining about "reverse discrimination," or leadership failing to allocate resources for inclusion efforts

Backlash against diversity initiatives

• Backlash refers to the negative reactions or counterefforts that arise in response to initiatives aimed at promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion
• This backlash can come from dominant group members who feel threatened by the redistribution of power and resources or the challenge to their privileged status
• Backlash can also come from marginalized group members who are skeptical of the sincerity or effectiveness of diversity efforts based on past experiences of tokenism or lip service
• Examples include employees claiming that diversity hiring lowers standards, managers resisting bias training as a waste of time, or leadership cutting diversity budgets during economic downturns

Consequences for individuals

• The dynamics of power and privilege in organizations have significant consequences for individuals, particularly those from marginalized groups
• These consequences can impact individuals' psychological well-being, career advancement, and overall experience in the workplace

Imposter syndrome

• Imposter syndrome refers to the persistent feeling of self-doubt and inadequacy despite evidence of competence and success
• This phenomenon is more common among members of marginalized groups who may internalize stereotypes about their abilities or feel pressure to prove their worth
• Imposter syndrome can lead to anxiety, self-sabotage, and reluctance to take on new challenges or opportunities for growth
• Examples include a woman in a male-dominated field doubting her expertise, a first-generation college graduate feeling out of place in a professional setting, or a person of color questioning their qualifications for a promotion

Stereotype threat

• Stereotype threat is the fear of confirming negative stereotypes about one's social group through one's actions or performance
• This threat can create additional stress and pressure for marginalized individuals, leading to underperformance or disengagement
• Stereotype threat is triggered by situations that make stereotypes salient, such as being the only member of one's group in a setting or facing tasks that are associated with stereotypical weaknesses
• Examples include a Black student worrying about confirming stereotypes about intelligence on a test, a woman in a leadership role fearing backlash for being assertive, or an older employee concerned about being seen as technologically inept

Emotional labor of minorities

• Emotional labor refers to the effort and skill involved in managing one's own emotions and the emotions of others as part of one's job
• Marginalized individuals often face greater emotional labor demands, as they navigate stereotypes, microaggressions, and the pressure to represent their entire group
• This additional labor can lead to stress, burnout, and reduced job satisfaction, as individuals must constantly monitor and adjust their behavior to fit in or avoid offense
• Examples include a gay employee deciding whether to come out at work, a Muslim woman facing questions about her hijab, or a person with a disability managing others' discomfort or pity

Barriers to advancement

• Power and privilege dynamics create barriers to advancement for marginalized groups, limiting their access to opportunities, resources, and support
• These barriers can be formal (biased policies or practices) or informal (exclusion from social networks or mentorship), and they accumulate over time to create disparities in representation and leadership
• Marginalized individuals may face higher performance standards, greater scrutiny, or assumptions of incompetence that hinder their career progression
• Examples include women being passed over for high-profile assignments, people of color lacking senior role models, or LGBTQ+ employees being excluded from client-facing roles

Tokenism and isolation

• Tokenism refers to the practice of including a small number of marginalized individuals in a group or organization to create the appearance of diversity without substantive change
• Tokenized individuals often face heightened visibility, pressure to represent their entire group, and isolation from peers who share their identities
• Tokenism can lead to feelings of loneliness, alienation, and the burden of being the sole voice for diversity in a homogeneous environment
• Examples include the only woman on an executive team, the only person of color in a department, or the only openly LGBTQ+ employee in a company

Impact on organizational culture

• The dynamics of power and privilege shape organizational cultures in ways that can perpetuate inequalities and limit the potential for diversity and inclusion
• These cultural impacts have far-reaching consequences for employee engagement, innovation, and overall organizational effectiveness

Exclusionary norms and practices

• Organizational norms and practices that reflect the preferences and experiences of dominant groups can create exclusionary environments for marginalized individuals
• These norms may be explicit (dress codes, language expectations) or implicit (communication styles, social activities), signaling who belongs and who does not
• Exclusionary practices can lead to reduced participation, engagement, and retention of marginalized employees who do not feel valued or included
• Examples include networking events centered around alcohol or sports, informal mentoring based on shared identities, or assumptions about "cultural fit" in hiring

Lack of psychological safety

• Psychological safety refers to the belief that one can express oneself authentically without fear of negative consequences to self-image, status, or career
• Power and privilege dynamics can undermine psychological safety for marginalized individuals, who may feel pressure to conform, conceal their identities, or avoid challenging the status quo
• Lack of psychological safety inhibits learning, risk-taking, and speaking up about problems or opportunities for improvement
• Examples include employees staying silent about microaggressions, avoiding discussions of diversity issues, or hesitating to propose innovative ideas that challenge established norms

Suppression of diverse perspectives

• Homogeneous cultures that value conformity over diversity tend to suppress or marginalize perspectives that deviate from the dominant view
• This suppression can lead to missed opportunities for learning, problem-solving, and innovation, as alternative ideas and experiences are not fully leveraged
• Marginalized individuals may self-censor or disengage when they feel their perspectives are not valued or heard, leading to a loss of diverse talent and insights
• Examples include meetings dominated by a few vocal individuals, decisions made without input from diverse stakeholders, or ideas from marginalized employees being dismissed or appropriated

Groupthink and conformity

• Groupthink refers to the tendency for groups to seek consensus and avoid dissent, leading to flawed decision-making and reduced creativity
• Privilege and power imbalances can exacerbate groupthink, as dominant group members' views are given more weight and alternative perspectives are suppressed
• Conformity pressure can lead individuals to go along with the majority opinion, even when they have doubts or disagree, in order to maintain group harmony or avoid negative consequences
• Examples include teams making decisions based on incomplete information, failing to consider alternative scenarios, or ignoring warning signs of potential problems

Retention challenges

• Organizational cultures that are not inclusive or equitable can lead to retention challenges, particularly for marginalized individuals who may feel undervalued, unsupported, or unable to advance
• These challenges can result in higher turnover rates, loss of diverse talent, and difficulty attracting new employees from underrepresented groups
• Retention issues can be costly for organizations in terms of lost productivity, knowledge, and relationships, as well as damage to reputation and employer brand
• Examples include women leaving tech companies at higher rates than men, people of color being underrepresented in senior leadership, or LGBTQ+ employees reporting lower job satisfaction and engagement

Strategies for change

• To create more equitable and inclusive organizations, it is necessary to actively challenge the dynamics of power and privilege and implement strategies for change
• These strategies involve individual actions, leadership commitments, and systemic interventions to transform cultures and practices

Allyship and advocacy

• Allyship refers to the active support and solidarity that members of dominant groups show for marginalized groups in the pursuit of equity and inclusion
• Advocacy involves using one's power and influence to champion the interests and needs of underrepresented individuals and communities
• Allies and advocates play a crucial role in challenging the status quo, amplifying marginalized voices, and creating space for change
• Examples include men speaking out against gender bias, white employees educating themselves about racism, or senior leaders sponsoring diverse talent for opportunities

Inclusive leadership

• Inclusive leadership involves modeling and promoting behaviors that create a sense of belonging, psychological safety, and respect for diversity
• Inclusive leaders actively seek out and value diverse perspectives, ensure equitable access to resources