3.4 Price Ceilings and Price Floors

Price controls, like ceilings and floors, are government-set limits on prices. They can cause shortages or surpluses, impacting supply and demand. These policies often lead to unintended consequences, affecting product quality, availability, and market dynamics.

Price controls have wide-ranging effects on various stakeholders. Consumers may benefit from lower prices but face shortages, while producers might struggle with reduced profits or unsold goods. Governments often grapple with the challenges of implementing and maintaining these policies effectively.

Price Controls and Their Effects

Effects of price controls on markets

Top images from around the web for Effects of price controls on markets

• 

  Reading: Price Ceilings | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Price Ceilings and Price Floors | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Inefficiency of Price Floors and Price Ceilings | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Price Ceilings | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Price Ceilings and Price Floors | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Effects of price controls on markets

• 

  Reading: Price Ceilings | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Price Ceilings and Price Floors | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Inefficiency of Price Floors and Price Ceilings | Macroeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Price Ceilings | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Price Ceilings and Price Floors | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Price ceilings
  • Legal maximum price set below the market equilibrium price
  • Create a shortage where quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied
  • Reduce quantity supplied as producers are less willing to supply at the lower price (gasoline)
  • Increase quantity demanded as consumers are willing to buy more at the lower price (rent-controlled apartments)
  • Impact on market depends on the elasticity of supply and demand
• Price floors
  • Legal minimum price set above the market equilibrium price
  • Create a surplus where quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded
  • Increase quantity supplied as producers are more willing to supply at the higher price (agricultural products)
  • Reduce quantity demanded as consumers are less willing to buy at the higher price (minimum wage labor)

Unintended consequences of price controls

• Price ceilings
  • Quality reduction
    • Producers may cut costs by lowering the quality of their products or services (lower-quality ingredients in price-controlled food)
    • Maintenance and upgrades may be deferred, leading to deterioration of quality over time (poorly maintained rent-controlled buildings)
  • Quantity reduction
    • Producers may reduce the quantity supplied to minimize losses (fewer gasoline stations in areas with price controls)
    • Some producers may exit the market, further reducing the quantity available (landlords converting rent-controlled apartments to condos)
  • Non-price rationing
    • Shortages lead to alternative allocation methods, such as waiting lines, discrimination, or favoritism (long lines at gas stations during shortages)
• Price floors
  • Quality changes
    • Producers may increase quality to justify the higher price (higher-quality agricultural products)
    • Higher prices may attract new producers with higher-quality products (skilled workers entering a market with high minimum wages)
  • Quantity changes
    • Surplus may lead to overproduction and waste (unsold agricultural products)
    • Some producers may exit the market if they cannot sell their surplus, reducing overall quantity (small businesses closing due to high minimum wages)
  • Government intervention
    • Governments may need to purchase the surplus to maintain the price floor (government buying excess agricultural products)
    • Storage costs and disposal of surplus may become a burden on the government (government-owned grain silos)

Stakeholder impacts of price ceilings vs floors

• Consumers
  • Price ceilings
    • Some consumers benefit from lower prices if they can access the goods or services (lucky few who find rent-controlled apartments)
    • Many consumers face shortages and may not be able to access the goods or services at all (people unable to find affordable housing)
  • Price floors
    • Consumers face higher prices and may reduce their consumption (people buying less labor-intensive goods and services)
    • Some consumers may be priced out of the market entirely (low-skilled workers unable to find jobs at high minimum wages)
• Producers
  • Price ceilings
    • Producers receive lower prices and may face reduced profits or losses (gasoline stations operating at a loss)
    • Some producers may exit the market due to the inability to cover costs (landlords abandoning rent-controlled properties)
  • Price floors
    • Producers receive higher prices and may experience increased profits (farmers benefiting from price supports)
    • Some producers may face difficulty selling their surplus and may exit the market (small businesses unable to afford high minimum wages)
• Governments
  • Price ceilings
    • May need to intervene to address shortages and ensure access to essential goods or services (government-provided housing)
    • May face political pressure from consumers and producers affected by the price ceiling (protests by landlords and tenants)
  • Price floors
    • May need to purchase and store surplus to maintain the price floor (government buying and storing excess agricultural products)
    • May face budgetary strain due to the costs associated with maintaining the price floor (taxpayer-funded agricultural subsidies)

Economic Efficiency and Market Distortions

• Price controls can lead to market distortions, affecting the balance of supply and demand
• These distortions can result in deadweight loss, reducing overall economic efficiency
• Welfare economics analyzes the impact of price controls on social welfare and resource allocation