5.1 Ecumenical councils

Ecumenical councils were pivotal gatherings of church leaders that shaped Christian doctrine and practice. These councils addressed theological controversies, defined orthodox beliefs, and established church policies that continue to influence Christianity today.

From the Council of Jerusalem in 50 AD to Vatican II in the 1960s, these assemblies tackled issues ranging from Christ's divinity to church reform. Their decisions formed the foundation of Christian theology and guided the church's response to changing times and challenges.

Early church councils

• Early church councils were gatherings of bishops in the first centuries of Christianity to address theological controversies and establish orthodox doctrine
• These councils played a crucial role in defining the core beliefs of the Christian faith and shaping the early church's identity

Council of Jerusalem

Top images from around the web for Council of Jerusalem

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Council of Jerusalem

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Council of Jerusalem - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Held around 50 AD to address the issue of whether Gentile converts needed to follow Jewish law and be circumcised
• Decided that Gentile Christians did not need to follow Jewish customs, establishing a distinction between Christianity and Judaism (Acts 15)
• Set a precedent for future councils to address doctrinal disputes and make binding decisions for the church

First Council of Nicaea

• Convened in 325 AD by Emperor Constantine to address the Arian controversy over the nature of Christ's divinity
• Affirmed the doctrine of Christ's full divinity and consubstantiality with the Father, rejecting Arianism
• Produced the Nicene Creed, a statement of faith that became a cornerstone of Christian orthodoxy
• Established the date of Easter and other liturgical practices

First Council of Constantinople

• Held in 381 AD to reaffirm and expand upon the Nicene Creed
• Condemned the heresy of Apollinarianism, which denied Christ's full humanity
• Affirmed the divinity of the Holy Spirit, completing the doctrine of the Trinity
• Elevated the status of Constantinople as the "New Rome" and second in honor after Rome

Council of Ephesus

• Convened in 431 AD to address the Nestorian controversy over the relationship between Christ's human and divine natures
• Affirmed the unity of Christ's person and the title "Theotokos" (God-bearer) for the Virgin Mary, rejecting Nestorianism
• Emphasized the importance of Christ's incarnation for human salvation

Council of Chalcedon

• Held in 451 AD to resolve the Monophysite controversy over the relationship between Christ's human and divine natures
• Defined the doctrine of Christ's two natures, fully divine and fully human, united in one person without confusion or division
• Became a defining moment in Christology and a source of division between Eastern and Western churches
• Laid the foundation for the development of Byzantine theology and the Oriental Orthodox churches

Medieval councils

• Medieval councils addressed a range of theological, disciplinary, and political issues facing the church in the Middle Ages
• These councils reflected the growing power and centralization of the papacy and the church's role in medieval society

Second Council of Constantinople

• Convened in 553 AD to address the Three Chapters controversy and the lingering influence of Nestorianism
• Condemned the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa as tainted by Nestorianism
• Reaffirmed the Christological formula of Chalcedon and the authority of the first four ecumenical councils

Third Council of Constantinople

• Held in 680-681 AD to address the Monothelite controversy over whether Christ had one or two wills
• Affirmed the doctrine of Christ's two wills, divine and human, united in one person
• Completed the Christological definitions of the early church and ended the last major Christological controversy

Second Council of Nicaea

• Convened in 787 AD to address the iconoclast controversy over the use of religious images (icons) in worship
• Affirmed the veneration (not worship) of icons as a means of honoring Christ, the Virgin Mary, and the saints
• Distinguished between the proper use of images and idolatry, setting guidelines for religious art

Fourth Council of Constantinople

• Held in 869-870 AD to address the Photian schism between the Eastern and Western churches
• Deposed Photius as patriarch of Constantinople and reaffirmed the primacy of the pope
• Revealed growing tensions between Eastern and Western Christianity over issues of authority and jurisdiction

First Lateran Council

• Convened in 1123 to address the Investiture Controversy over the appointment of bishops and abbots
• Affirmed the independence of the church from secular authority in spiritual matters
• Prohibited simony (buying or selling church offices) and clerical marriage

Second Lateran Council

• Held in 1139 to address the papal schism of 1130-1138 and reform the clergy
• Reaffirmed clerical celibacy and condemned the teachings of Arnold of Brescia
• Sought to strengthen papal authority and centralize church governance

Third Lateran Council

• Convened in 1179 to address the papal election process and combat heresy
• Established the two-thirds majority rule for papal elections, reducing the influence of secular powers
• Condemned the Cathar and Waldensian heresies and authorized the use of force against heretics

Fourth Lateran Council

• Held in 1215 under Pope Innocent III, one of the most significant medieval councils
• Defined the doctrine of transubstantiation, affirming Christ's real presence in the Eucharist
• Required annual confession and Easter communion for all Catholics
• Mandated the wearing of distinctive dress for Jews and Muslims to prevent intermarriage
• Launched the Fifth Crusade and condemned the Albigensian heresy

Councils addressing Reformation issues

• The councils of the late Middle Ages and early modern period sought to address the challenges posed by the Protestant Reformation and reform the Catholic Church from within
• These councils reflected the church's efforts to respond to criticism, clarify doctrine, and implement institutional reforms

Council of Constance

• Convened in 1414-1418 to resolve the Western Schism, which saw three rival claimants to the papacy
• Asserted the supremacy of ecumenical councils over the pope in matters of faith and ending schisms
• Condemned the teachings of John Wycliffe and Jan Hus, who criticized church corruption and advocated reform
• Unsuccessfully sought to implement institutional reforms and end the schism

Council of Basel-Ferrara-Florence

• Held in 1431-1449, initially to address church reform and negotiate with the Hussites
• Moved from Basel to Ferrara and then Florence due to conflicts with Pope Eugene IV
• Sought to reunite the Eastern and Western churches, reaching a temporary union with the Greek Orthodox Church
• Ultimately failed to achieve lasting reform or unity due to political and theological differences

Fifth Lateran Council

• Convened in 1512-1517 by Pope Julius II to address church reform and the threat of conciliarism
• Reaffirmed papal supremacy and condemned the Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges, which limited papal authority in France
• Implemented some modest reforms but failed to address the deeper issues that led to the Protestant Reformation

Council of Trent

• Held in three sessions from 1545-1563 in response to the Protestant Reformation
• Clarified and reaffirmed key Catholic doctrines on salvation, the sacraments, and the biblical canon
• Implemented significant reforms in church discipline, education, and the training of clergy
• Established a clear distinction between Catholicism and Protestantism, shaping Catholic identity for centuries
• Laid the foundation for the Counter-Reformation and the renewal of the Catholic Church

Vatican councils

• The Vatican councils of the 19th and 20th centuries addressed the challenges of modernity and sought to renew the church's mission in a changing world
• These councils reflected the church's efforts to engage with contemporary issues and adapt to new social and cultural realities

First Vatican Council

• Convened in 1869-1870 by Pope Pius IX to address the challenges of modernity and secularization
• Defined the doctrine of papal infallibility, affirming the pope's supreme authority in matters of faith and morals
• Sought to counter the influence of liberalism, rationalism, and nationalism on the church
• Interrupted by the outbreak of the Franco-Prussian War and the annexation of the Papal States

Second Vatican Council

• Held in 1962-1965 under Popes John XXIII and Paul VI, the most significant council of the modern era
• Sought to renew the church's mission and engage with the modern world through a process of aggiornamento (updating)
• Emphasized the church as the People of God, the collegiality of bishops, and the role of the laity
• Promoted liturgical reform, ecumenical dialogue, and religious freedom
• Produced major documents on the church, revelation, the liturgy, and the church's relationship with the modern world
• Transformed the Catholic Church and its relationship with other Christian traditions and non-Christian religions

Purpose of ecumenical councils

• Ecumenical councils serve as the highest authority in the church for addressing theological disputes, defining doctrine, and promoting unity
• These councils reflect the church's efforts to maintain continuity with apostolic tradition while responding to new challenges and contexts

Resolving theological disputes

• Councils provide a forum for bishops to debate and resolve theological controversies that threaten the unity of the church
• By defining orthodox doctrine and condemning heresies, councils seek to maintain the integrity of the Christian faith
• Examples include the Christological debates of the early church (Nicaea, Ephesus, Chalcedon) and the Protestant Reformation (Trent)

Defining church doctrine

• Councils have the authority to define and clarify church doctrine on key issues of faith and morals
• These doctrinal definitions become part of the church's magisterial teaching and shape the development of theology
• Examples include the Nicene Creed, the canon of Scripture, and the doctrines of the sacraments and papal infallibility

Addressing heresies and schisms

• Councils seek to identify and condemn theological errors and divisions that threaten the unity of the church
• By anathematizing heretics and schismatics, councils aim to preserve the purity of the faith and the unity of the church
• Examples include the condemnation of Arianism, Nestorianism, and the teachings of Luther and Calvin

Authority of ecumenical councils

• The authority of ecumenical councils is a central question in ecclesiology, reflecting different understandings of the nature and structure of the church
• The relationship between conciliar and papal authority has been a source of tension and debate throughout church history

Infallibility vs fallibility

• Catholic tradition holds that ecumenical councils, when approved by the pope, are infallible in their doctrinal definitions
• This infallibility is based on the belief that the Holy Spirit guides the church in its discernment of truth
• Some theologians argue that councils are fallible and subject to error, emphasizing the human limitations of their participants

Relationship to papal authority

• The relationship between the authority of councils and the authority of the pope has been a source of tension and debate
• The First Vatican Council defined the doctrine of papal infallibility, affirming the pope's supreme authority in matters of faith and morals
• Some argue for the superiority of councils over popes (conciliarism), while others emphasize the need for harmony between the two

Reception by Eastern Orthodox churches

• The Eastern Orthodox churches recognize the authority of the first seven ecumenical councils but reject the later councils of the Catholic Church
• The Orthodox view councils as expressions of the consensus of the church, guided by the Holy Spirit, but not as infallible in themselves
• The different understandings of conciliar authority reflect the ecclesiological differences between Eastern and Western Christianity

Legacy of ecumenical councils

• The ecumenical councils have had a profound impact on the development of Christian theology, the shaping of church history, and the pursuit of Christian unity
• The legacy of these councils continues to be felt in contemporary theological debates and ecumenical dialogues

Impact on Christian theology

• The doctrinal definitions of the ecumenical councils have become the foundation for Christian theology across traditions
• Councils have shaped the church's understanding of the Trinity, Christology, soteriology, ecclesiology, and sacramental theology
• The creeds and canons of the councils serve as authoritative expressions of the Christian faith

Role in shaping church history

• The ecumenical councils have played a crucial role in shaping the institutional, cultural, and political history of the church
• Councils have defined the boundaries of orthodoxy and heresy, established liturgical and disciplinary norms, and regulated the church's relationship with secular authorities
• The divisions and controversies surrounding councils have also contributed to the fragmentation of Christianity into different traditions and denominations

Relevance for modern ecumenical dialogue

• The legacy of the ecumenical councils is central to contemporary efforts toward Christian unity and dialogue
• Ecumenical dialogues often seek to overcome the divisions and misunderstandings rooted in the historical conflicts addressed by councils
• The joint study and reception of the councils' teachings can provide a basis for theological convergence and reconciliation among Christian traditions
• The model of conciliar decision-making and consensus-building remains relevant for addressing contemporary challenges facing the church and the world