7.1 Model-based control

Model-based control is a powerful approach for soft robotics, using mathematical models to design and implement precise control strategies. It enables optimization of soft robot behavior by leveraging knowledge of system dynamics and properties, crucial for advanced applications like manipulators and surgical robots.

This approach involves kinematic and dynamic modeling, constitutive modeling of soft materials, and finite element analysis. Control strategies include open-loop and closed-loop methods, with challenges like nonlinear dynamics and infinite degrees of freedom. Optimization techniques and simulation tools play key roles in developing effective control systems.

Model-based control overview

• Model-based control relies on mathematical models of the system to design and implement control strategies for soft robots
• Enables precise control and optimization of soft robot behavior by leveraging the knowledge of the system's dynamics and properties
• Plays a crucial role in the development of advanced soft robotic systems for various applications (manipulators, wearables, surgical robots)

Modeling of soft robots

Kinematic modeling

Top images from around the web for Kinematic modeling

• 

  Frontiers | Integrating Soft Robotics with the Robot Operating System: A Hybrid Pick and Place ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Creating Better Collision-Free Trajectory for Robot Motion Planning by Linearly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | An Integrated Kinematic Modeling and Experimental Approach for an Active Endoscope ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Integrating Soft Robotics with the Robot Operating System: A Hybrid Pick and Place ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Creating Better Collision-Free Trajectory for Robot Motion Planning by Linearly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Kinematic modeling

• 

  Frontiers | Integrating Soft Robotics with the Robot Operating System: A Hybrid Pick and Place ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Creating Better Collision-Free Trajectory for Robot Motion Planning by Linearly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | An Integrated Kinematic Modeling and Experimental Approach for an Active Endoscope ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Integrating Soft Robotics with the Robot Operating System: A Hybrid Pick and Place ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Creating Better Collision-Free Trajectory for Robot Motion Planning by Linearly ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Describes the motion of soft robots without considering the forces causing the motion
• Involves the study of the geometry and the relationships between the robot's configuration and its end-effector position and orientation
• Essential for tasks such as trajectory planning and workspace analysis
• Techniques include constant curvature models and piecewise constant curvature models

Dynamic modeling

• Captures the relationship between the forces acting on the soft robot and its resulting motion
• Incorporates the effects of inertia, damping, and external forces on the robot's behavior
• Necessary for accurate control and simulation of soft robots
• Approaches include lumped-parameter models, continuum mechanics-based models, and energy-based methods

Constitutive modeling of soft materials

• Describes the mechanical behavior of soft materials under various loading conditions
• Captures the nonlinear, viscoelastic, and hyperelastic properties of soft materials (silicone rubber, hydrogels)
• Essential for accurate prediction of the robot's deformation and stress distribution
• Models include Neo-Hookean, Mooney-Rivlin, and Ogden hyperelastic models

Finite element modeling

• Numerical technique for solving complex continuum mechanics problems in soft robots
• Discretizes the soft robot into small elements and solves the governing equations for each element
• Enables accurate prediction of the robot's deformation, stress distribution, and contact interactions
• Commonly used software packages include ABAQUS, ANSYS, and COMSOL

Control strategies for soft robots

Open-loop control

• Control strategy that does not use feedback from the system to correct for errors or disturbances
• Relies on accurate modeling and calibration of the soft robot to achieve the desired performance
• Suitable for simple tasks or when the system is well-characterized and the environment is predictable
• Examples include feedforward control and model-based open-loop control

Closed-loop control

• Control strategy that uses feedback from the system to correct for errors and disturbances
• Compares the actual output of the system with the desired output and adjusts the control inputs accordingly
• Enables more accurate and robust control of soft robots in the presence of uncertainties and external disturbances
• Examples include feedback control, adaptive control, and robust control

Feedback control

• Closed-loop control strategy that uses measurements of the system's output to correct for errors
• Compares the measured output with the desired output and generates a control signal to minimize the error
• Commonly used feedback control techniques include PID control, state feedback control, and output feedback control
• Requires accurate sensing of the soft robot's state (position, velocity, force)

Feedforward control

• Open-loop control strategy that uses a model of the system to predict the required control inputs
• Computes the control inputs based on the desired trajectory or task, without using feedback from the system
• Can improve the performance of closed-loop control by compensating for known disturbances and system dynamics
• Requires accurate modeling of the soft robot and its environment

Challenges in soft robot control

Nonlinear dynamics

• Soft robots exhibit highly nonlinear behavior due to the complex interactions between the soft materials, actuators, and environment
• Nonlinearities arise from material properties (hyperelasticity, viscoelasticity), large deformations, and contact interactions
• Pose challenges in modeling, identification, and control design for soft robots
• Require the use of advanced nonlinear control techniques (feedback linearization, sliding mode control)

Infinite degrees of freedom

• Soft robots have a continuum structure with infinite degrees of freedom, unlike rigid robots with discrete joints
• Infinite degrees of freedom make the modeling and control of soft robots more challenging
• Require the use of reduced-order models or discretization techniques to make the control problem tractable
• Examples include modal analysis, finite element methods, and lumped-parameter models

Modeling uncertainties

• Soft robots are subject to various modeling uncertainties due to the complex nature of soft materials and their interactions with the environment
• Uncertainties arise from material properties, fabrication processes, and external disturbances
• Pose challenges in achieving accurate and robust control of soft robots
• Require the use of adaptive and robust control techniques to compensate for modeling uncertainties

Sensing limitations

• Soft robots lack the precise and high-bandwidth sensing capabilities of rigid robots due to the difficulty in integrating sensors into soft structures
• Limited sensing capabilities make it challenging to obtain accurate and real-time feedback of the robot's state
• Affect the performance and robustness of closed-loop control strategies
• Require the development of novel sensing technologies (soft sensors, vision-based sensing) and estimation techniques (observers, filters)

Model-based control approaches

Inverse kinematics control

• Control approach that computes the required joint positions or actuator inputs to achieve a desired end-effector position and orientation
• Relies on the kinematic model of the soft robot to solve the inverse kinematics problem
• Suitable for tasks that require precise positioning of the end-effector (grasping, manipulation)
• Challenges include the nonlinear and redundant nature of soft robot kinematics

Impedance control

• Control approach that regulates the dynamic relationship between the motion of the robot and the forces it exerts on the environment
• Enables the soft robot to interact with the environment with a desired stiffness, damping, and inertia
• Suitable for tasks that involve contact with the environment (manipulation, locomotion)
• Requires accurate modeling of the soft robot's dynamics and the environment

Adaptive control

• Control approach that adapts the control parameters or structure based on the observed behavior of the system
• Enables the soft robot to cope with modeling uncertainties, parameter variations, and external disturbances
• Commonly used adaptive control techniques include model reference adaptive control, self-tuning control, and gain scheduling
• Requires online estimation of the system parameters or the use of learning algorithms

Robust control

• Control approach that ensures the stability and performance of the system in the presence of modeling uncertainties and external disturbances
• Designs the controller to be insensitive to uncertainties within a specified range
• Commonly used robust control techniques include H-infinity control, sliding mode control, and robust PID control
• Requires the characterization of the uncertainties and the definition of performance specifications

Optimization in model-based control

Optimal control theory

• Mathematical framework for determining the control inputs that optimize a given performance criterion while satisfying system constraints
• Formulates the control problem as an optimization problem, with the performance criterion as the objective function and the system dynamics as constraints
• Commonly used optimal control techniques include linear quadratic regulator (LQR), model predictive control (MPC), and dynamic programming
• Enables the computation of optimal trajectories and control policies for soft robots

Trajectory optimization

• Optimization approach that computes the optimal trajectory for a soft robot to achieve a desired task while minimizing a cost function
• Takes into account the system dynamics, constraints, and performance objectives
• Commonly used trajectory optimization methods include direct collocation, shooting methods, and inverse optimal control
• Enables the generation of energy-efficient, smooth, and safe trajectories for soft robots

Reinforcement learning

• Machine learning approach that enables a soft robot to learn an optimal control policy through interaction with its environment
• Formulates the control problem as a Markov decision process, where the robot learns to map states to actions to maximize a cumulative reward signal
• Commonly used reinforcement learning algorithms include Q-learning, policy gradients, and actor-critic methods
• Enables the learning of complex control policies for soft robots without explicit modeling of the system dynamics

Simulation tools for model-based control

Soft robot simulation environments

• Software tools that enable the modeling, simulation, and visualization of soft robots and their interactions with the environment
• Provide a platform for testing and validating control strategies before implementation on physical robots
• Examples include SOFA (Simulation Open Framework Architecture), ChainQueen, and Elastica
• Incorporate physics engines (FEniCS, CUDA) and rendering engines (OpenGL) to simulate the deformation and motion of soft robots

Integration with control algorithms

• Simulation environments provide interfaces and libraries for integrating control algorithms with the simulated soft robot
• Enable the testing and optimization of control strategies in a simulated environment
• Commonly used interfaces include ROS (Robot Operating System), MATLAB, and Python
• Allow the seamless transfer of control algorithms from simulation to physical robots

Validation of control strategies

• Simulation tools enable the validation of control strategies by comparing the simulated behavior with the desired behavior
• Provide quantitative metrics for evaluating the performance of control strategies (tracking error, energy consumption)
• Enable the identification of potential issues and limitations of control strategies before implementation on physical robots
• Require the validation of the simulation model against experimental data to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the results

Real-world applications of model-based control

Soft robotic manipulators

• Model-based control enables precise and dexterous manipulation with soft robotic grippers and arms
• Applications include grasping delicate objects (fruits, vegetables), handling fragile components (electronics), and performing complex assembly tasks
• Control strategies such as impedance control and adaptive control enable safe and robust interaction with the environment

Soft wearable robots

• Model-based control enables the design and control of soft exosuits and orthoses for assistance and rehabilitation
• Applications include assisted walking for individuals with mobility impairments, tremor suppression for Parkinson's disease, and post-stroke rehabilitation
• Control strategies such as admittance control and adaptive oscillators enable synchronization with the user's movements and adaptation to different gait patterns

Soft surgical robots

• Model-based control enables precise and minimally invasive surgical procedures with soft robotic devices
• Applications include endoscopic surgery, catheter-based interventions, and microsurgery
• Control strategies such as inverse kinematics control and hybrid force/position control enable accurate positioning and force control of surgical tools

Autonomous soft robots

• Model-based control enables the development of autonomous soft robots for exploration, monitoring, and intervention in unstructured environments
• Applications include search and rescue operations, environmental monitoring, and marine exploration
• Control strategies such as model predictive control and reinforcement learning enable the autonomous navigation and decision-making of soft robots

Future directions in model-based control

Learning-based control

• Integration of machine learning techniques with model-based control to enable the learning of complex control policies from data
• Approaches include learning-based model predictive control, reinforcement learning with learned models, and neural network-based control
• Enables the adaptation of control strategies to changing environments and tasks without explicit modeling of the system dynamics

Hybrid model-based and learning-based approaches

• Combination of model-based control with learning-based techniques to leverage the strengths of both approaches
• Model-based control provides a structured framework for control design, while learning-based techniques enable adaptation and optimization
• Examples include model-based reinforcement learning, adaptive model predictive control, and learning-based robust control
• Enables the development of control strategies that are both robust and adaptable to uncertainties and variations in the system and environment

Scalability and computational efficiency

• Development of computationally efficient algorithms for model-based control of large-scale soft robotic systems
• Approaches include model reduction techniques, distributed control architectures, and hardware acceleration (GPUs, FPGAs)
• Enables the real-time implementation of model-based control strategies on resource-constrained platforms (embedded systems, microcontrollers)
• Facilitates the deployment of model-based control in real-world applications with strict computational and memory constraints

Integration with sensing and actuation technologies

• Integration of model-based control with advanced sensing and actuation technologies to enable more precise and responsive control of soft robots
• Sensing technologies include soft sensors (resistive, capacitive), embedded sensors (IMUs, strain gauges), and vision-based sensing (cameras, depth sensors)
• Actuation technologies include pneumatic actuators, shape memory alloys, dielectric elastomer actuators, and cable-driven actuators
• Enables the development of closed-loop control strategies that leverage the rich sensory information and diverse actuation capabilities of soft robots