8.1 Compliant grippers

Compliant grippers are a game-changer in soft robotics. They use flexible materials and clever designs to gently grasp objects of all shapes and sizes. This adaptive approach simplifies control and expands the range of items robots can handle.

From food processing to surgery, compliant grippers are making waves across industries. They're safer for human interaction and can handle delicate objects with ease. As designs improve, these versatile tools are set to revolutionize how robots interact with the world.

Compliant gripper designs

• Compliant grippers are a key component in soft robotics that enable adaptive and gentle grasping of delicate or irregularly shaped objects
• Designs leverage the inherent compliance of soft materials and underactuated mechanisms to conform to object geometries without complex control strategies
• Can be classified based on the level of actuation and the source of compliance in the gripper structure

Underactuated vs fully-actuated grippers

Top images from around the web for Underactuated vs fully-actuated grippers

• 

  Frontiers | On Alternative Uses of Structural Compliance for the Development of Adaptive Robot ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | On Alternative Uses of Structural Compliance for the Development of Adaptive Robot ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Underactuated vs fully-actuated grippers

• 

  Frontiers | On Alternative Uses of Structural Compliance for the Development of Adaptive Robot ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | On Alternative Uses of Structural Compliance for the Development of Adaptive Robot ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | SIMBA: Tendon-Driven Modular Continuum Arm with Soft Reconfigurable Gripper View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Underactuated grippers have fewer actuators than degrees of freedom, relying on passive compliance to adapt to object shapes (tendon-driven hands)
• Fully-actuated grippers have independent control over each degree of freedom, allowing for more precise manipulation at the cost of increased complexity
• Underactuation simplifies control and reduces the number of required actuators, making grippers more compact and lightweight

Passive compliance in grippers

• Passive compliance arises from the inherent flexibility of soft materials like elastomers or springs in the gripper structure
• Allows grippers to conform to object shapes without active control, simplifying grasping of irregular or unknown objects
• Can be tuned by selecting materials with appropriate stiffness and designing compliant joints or flexures

Active compliance for adaptive grasping

• Active compliance involves controlling the stiffness or position of gripper elements in real-time based on sensor feedback
• Enables grippers to adapt to changing object properties or environmental conditions during grasping
• Can be achieved through variable stiffness actuators (pneumatic muscles with controllable air pressure) or antagonistic actuation (opposing tendons or pneumatic chambers)

Materials for compliant grippers

• Material selection is crucial for achieving desired compliance, durability, and functionality in soft grippers
• Common materials include elastomeric polymers, flexible fabrics, and composite materials with tunable properties
• Choice of materials depends on application requirements such as operating environment, force output, and biocompatibility

Elastomeric polymers

• Elastomers like silicone rubber and polyurethanes are widely used for their high stretchability, durability, and ease of fabrication
• Can be molded into complex geometries using casting or 3D printing techniques
• Silicone elastomers (Ecoflex, Dragon Skin) are commonly used for their biocompatibility and resistance to tearing

Flexible fabrics and textiles

• Woven or knitted fabrics like nylon, polyester, or Kevlar offer high strength-to-weight ratios and flexibility
• Can be integrated with elastomeric materials to create composite structures with anisotropic properties
• Conductive textiles (silver-coated nylon) enable the integration of sensing capabilities directly into the gripper material

Composite materials with tunable stiffness

• Composite materials combine two or more constituent materials to achieve desired properties like variable stiffness
• Particle-filled elastomers (silicone with ferromagnetic particles) can change stiffness when exposed to magnetic fields
• Laminated structures with alternating soft and rigid layers can create anisotropic bending behavior for adaptive grasping

Actuation methods

• Actuation methods for compliant grippers convert energy into mechanical work to generate grasping forces and motions
• Pneumatic, hydraulic, and tendon-driven actuation are common in soft robotics due to their compatibility with flexible materials
• Choice of actuation depends on factors like force output, speed, precision, and system integration considerations

Pneumatic actuation

• Pneumatic actuators use compressed air to inflate flexible chambers or bellows, causing them to expand and generate motion
• Enables high force output and rapid actuation with simple control via solenoid valves
• Pneumatic networks (PneuNets) can be embedded in elastomeric materials to create complex deformations and grasping behaviors

Hydraulic actuation

• Hydraulic actuators use pressurized fluids like water or oil to drive motion in flexible cylinders or artificial muscles
• Offers high force output and stiffness control but requires careful sealing and fluid management
• Used in applications where high forces are required, such as industrial grippers or underwater manipulation

Tendon-driven actuation

• Tendon-driven actuators use cables or strings routed through the gripper structure to transmit forces and generate motion
• Allows for remote actuation and compact gripper designs, as actuators can be located away from the gripper itself
• Underactuated tendon-driven grippers (SDM hand) use a single actuator to drive multiple fingers, relying on compliant joints for adaptive grasping

Shape memory alloy actuation

• Shape memory alloys (SMAs) like Nitinol can generate large strains and forces when heated, enabling compact and lightweight actuators
• SMA wires can be embedded in elastomeric materials or textiles to create flexible, self-contained actuators
• Challenges include low energy efficiency, slow cooling times, and hysteresis effects that complicate control

Sensing in compliant grippers

• Sensing is essential for enabling compliant grippers to adapt to object properties, detect contact, and control grasping forces
• Tactile, proprioceptive, and vision-based sensing modalities are commonly used in soft grippers
• Integration of sensors in soft structures requires careful design to avoid interfering with compliance and durability

Tactile sensing for grasping feedback

• Tactile sensors measure contact forces, pressure distribution, or object properties like hardness and texture
• Resistive, capacitive, or optical sensing principles can be used to create flexible and stretchable tactile sensors
• Tactile arrays (TakkTile) can be integrated into gripper fingertips or palms to provide spatially resolved contact information

Proprioceptive sensing of gripper configuration

• Proprioceptive sensors measure the position, orientation, or deformation of the gripper structure
• Enables closed-loop control of grasping forces and detection of object slip or loss of contact
• Stretch sensors (liquid metal-filled elastomer channels) or flexible potentiometers can be embedded in gripper joints or links

Vision-based sensing for object recognition

• Cameras or depth sensors can be used to perceive object shapes, sizes, and poses for grasp planning and control
• Depth cameras (Intel RealSense) provide 3D point clouds for estimating object geometries and locating grasp points
• Machine learning techniques like convolutional neural networks (CNNs) can be used for object recognition and classification

Grasping strategies with compliant grippers

• Grasping strategies define how a gripper interacts with objects to achieve stable and reliable grasps
• Compliant grippers enable a variety of grasping modes that can adapt to object shapes and properties
• The choice of grasping strategy depends on the object characteristics, task requirements, and gripper capabilities

Enveloping grasps

• Enveloping grasps involve wrapping the gripper fingers or palm around an object to maximize contact area and stability
• Particularly effective for grasping irregular or soft objects that can deform to the shape of the gripper
• Compliant materials and underactuated designs facilitate enveloping grasps by passively conforming to object geometries

Pinching and precision grasps

• Pinching grasps involve applying opposing forces to an object with two or more finger contacts
• Precision grasps are a subset of pinching grasps that use the fingertips for fine manipulation of small objects
• Compliant grippers can achieve pinching and precision grasps through active stiffness control or by incorporating rigid elements like fingernails

Underactuated grasping for unknown objects

• Underactuated grippers can adapt to a wide range of object shapes and sizes without precise knowledge of their properties
• By coupling the motion of multiple fingers through compliant mechanisms, underactuated grippers can passively conform to objects
• Examples include tendon-driven grippers (SDM hand) and grippers with adaptive transmissions (Velo gripper)

In-hand manipulation techniques

• In-hand manipulation involves repositioning or reorienting an object within the gripper without releasing it
• Enables more dexterous interaction with objects and expands the range of achievable grasps
• Compliant grippers can perform in-hand manipulation through coordinated finger motions, exploiting contact dynamics, or using external surfaces

Applications of compliant grippers

• Compliant grippers have diverse applications in fields like agriculture, manufacturing, and healthcare
• The adaptability and safety of soft grippers make them well-suited for handling delicate or variable objects
• Application-specific design considerations include the operating environment, force and precision requirements, and integration with existing systems

Food handling and processing

• Soft grippers can gently handle delicate food items like fruits, vegetables, and baked goods without damaging them
• Compliant materials are often food-safe and can be easily cleaned or replaced to maintain hygiene standards
• Examples include the Soft Robotics mGrip system for handling produce and the SWITL gripper for handling sticky dough

E-commerce and logistics

• Compliant grippers can grasp a wide variety of products in e-commerce warehouses and distribution centers
• Underactuated designs and adaptive grasping strategies enable handling of items with varying shapes, sizes, and packaging materials
• Soft Robotics has developed a range of soft grippers for pick-and-place tasks in e-commerce fulfillment centers

Assistive and collaborative robotics

• Soft grippers are inherently safer for human-robot interaction due to their compliance and ability to absorb impacts
• Can be used in assistive devices like prosthetic hands or in collaborative robots working alongside humans
• Examples include the SoftHand Pro, a soft prosthetic hand with adaptive grasping capabilities, and the Pisa/IIT SoftHand for robotic manipulation

Minimally invasive surgery

• Compliant grippers can navigate through confined spaces and gently manipulate delicate tissues during minimally invasive surgical procedures
• Miniaturized soft grippers can be integrated into endoscopic tools or catheters for tissue retraction or biopsy sampling
• Researchers have developed origami-inspired soft grippers for minimally invasive heart surgery and a soft robotic endoscope with a compliant gripper for tissue manipulation

Design considerations for compliant grippers

• Designing compliant grippers involves balancing trade-offs between performance, manufacturability, and application-specific requirements
• Key design considerations include scalability, durability, energy efficiency, and integration with existing robotic systems
• Simulation tools like finite element analysis (FEA) and multiphysics modeling can aid in the design and optimization of soft gripper components

Scalability and miniaturization

• Compliant grippers can be scaled up or down to accommodate different object sizes and payloads
• Miniaturization of soft grippers enables applications in fields like micromanipulation or minimally invasive surgery
• Challenges in scaling include maintaining material properties, fabrication resolution, and actuator performance at different scales

Durability and wear resistance

• Soft materials used in compliant grippers are often susceptible to wear, fatigue, or damage from repeated use or exposure to harsh environments
• Strategies for improving durability include material selection, reinforcement with high-strength fibers, or incorporating self-healing properties
• Designing for easy replacement or repair of worn components can also extend the lifespan of soft grippers

Energy efficiency and power consumption

• Soft actuators like pneumatic or hydraulic systems can be energy-intensive due to the need for pressurized fluids and valves
• Improving energy efficiency involves optimizing actuator designs, minimizing leaks and pressure losses, and implementing energy recovery methods
• Low-power alternatives like shape memory alloys or dielectric elastomer actuators can be used in applications with lower force requirements

Integration with robotic arms and platforms

• Compliant grippers must be compatible with the mechanical, electrical, and software interfaces of the robotic systems they are integrated with
• Considerations include the gripper's weight, size, and mounting options, as well as its communication and control requirements
• Modular designs and standardized interfaces (ROS, URDF) can facilitate integration with a variety of robotic platforms and enable rapid prototyping and testing of new gripper designs