5.3 Contemporary Issues in Federal-State Relations

Federal-state relations remain complex, with ongoing debates over funding, mandates, and policy implementation. States navigate federal grants, Medicaid expansion, and preemption laws, balancing national priorities with local needs and autonomy.

Tensions arise in areas like immigration, environment, and healthcare. Some states resist federal policies through sanctuary cities or lawsuits, while others embrace federal initiatives, showcasing the dynamic nature of American federalism.

Federal Funding to States

Types of Federal Grants and Mandates

Top images from around the web for Types of Federal Grants and Mandates

• 

  Everything you need to know about block grants - NC Health News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intergovernmental Relationships | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Everything you need to know about block grants - NC Health News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intergovernmental Relationships | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Types of Federal Grants and Mandates

• 

  Everything you need to know about block grants - NC Health News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intergovernmental Relationships | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Everything you need to know about block grants - NC Health News View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intergovernmental Relationships | American Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Unfunded mandates require states to implement federal policies without providing financial support
  • Places financial burden on state and local governments
  • Can lead to tension between federal and state governments
  • Includes requirements like Americans with Disabilities Act compliance
• Block grants provide flexible funding for broad policy areas
  • Allow states more discretion in how to use funds
  • Often used for community development or social services
  • Typically have fewer restrictions than categorical grants (Housing and Urban Development grants)
• Categorical grants allocate funds for specific, narrowly defined purposes
  • Require states to meet federal guidelines to receive funding
  • Often used to address national priorities at the state level
  • Can be formula grants based on population or need (highway funding)
  • Can be project grants awarded through competitive processes (research grants)

Medicaid Expansion and Its Impact

• Medicaid expansion extends healthcare coverage to more low-income individuals
  • Part of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) implementation
  • Initially mandatory for states, later ruled optional by Supreme Court
• States choosing to expand receive increased federal funding
  • Federal government covers 90% of expansion costs
  • Leads to reduced uninsured rates and improved health outcomes
• States refusing expansion cite concerns over long-term costs
  • Creates disparities in healthcare access between expanding and non-expanding states
  • Impacts state budgets and healthcare systems differently across the country

Federal Preemption of State Laws

Understanding Federal Preemption

• Preemption derives from the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution
  • Establishes federal law as the "supreme law of the land"
  • Allows federal government to supersede state laws in certain areas
• Can be express preemption explicitly stated in federal statute
  • Clearly indicates Congress's intent to override state laws
  • Leaves little room for interpretation (Employee Retirement Income Security Act)
• Can be implied preemption when federal law conflicts with state law
  • Occurs when compliance with both federal and state law is impossible
  • Happens when state law obstructs the full purpose of federal law

Environmental and Education Policy Preemption

• Environmental regulations often involve federal preemption
  • Clean Air Act sets national standards for air quality
  • States can implement stricter standards but not weaker ones
  • Creates a baseline for environmental protection across the country
• Education policy shows complex interplay between federal and state authority
  • No Child Left Behind Act increased federal role in education
  • Every Student Succeeds Act returned some control to states
  • Demonstrates evolving nature of federal-state relations in education

State Resistance to Federal Policies

Sanctuary Cities and Immigration Policy

• Sanctuary cities limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement
  • Refuse to use local resources for federal immigration law enforcement
  • Often prohibit asking about immigration status or sharing information
  • Creates tension between local, state, and federal authorities
• Federal government attempts to withhold funding from sanctuary jurisdictions
  • Leads to legal battles over federal power to compel state cooperation
  • Raises questions about limits of federal authority in immigration enforcement

State-Level Environmental and Healthcare Policies

• Some states implement stricter environmental regulations than federal standards
  • California sets higher fuel efficiency standards for vehicles
  • Creates conflict with federal attempts to roll back regulations
  • Demonstrates states' ability to lead in environmental protection
• Medicaid expansion decisions vary by state
  • Some states reject expansion despite federal incentives
  • Creates disparities in healthcare access across state lines
  • Highlights ongoing debate over federalism in healthcare policy
• States challenge federal environmental policies through lawsuits
  • Sue over changes to Clean Power Plan or endangered species protections
  • Illustrates states' role in shaping national environmental policy
  • Demonstrates use of legal system in federal-state conflicts