3.3 André Breton's manifestos

André Breton's manifestos defined Surrealism's principles and practices in the aftermath of World War I. They emerged as a response to societal trauma and the limitations of Dada, seeking to establish a distinct movement with clear objectives.

The manifestos emphasized the unconscious mind, automatic writing, and dream interpretation. They rejected rationalism, aligned with communist ideals, and explored occult influences, shaping Surrealism's artistic and political direction for decades to come.

Origins of Breton's manifestos

• Emerged during the aftermath of World War I, reflecting the disillusionment and cultural upheaval of the early 20th century
• Developed as a response to the limitations of Dada, seeking a more constructive approach to artistic and social revolution
• Aimed to establish Surrealism as a distinct movement with clear principles and objectives

Historical context

Top images from around the web for Historical context

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  hannah hoch collage | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  hannah hoch collage | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Historical context

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  hannah hoch collage | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud and the Psychodynamic Perspective | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  hannah hoch collage | Flickr - Photo Sharing! View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Post-World War I era characterized by societal trauma and questioning of established norms
• Influence of Freudian psychoanalysis gaining prominence in intellectual circles
• Rise of avant-garde movements challenging traditional artistic and literary conventions
• Growing interest in exploring the unconscious mind and its creative potential

Influences on Breton

• Sigmund Freud's theories on dreams and the unconscious shaped Breton's approach to artistic creation
• Guillaume Apollinaire's concept of "surrealism" in theater inspired Breton's adoption of the term
• Dadaist techniques of chance and spontaneity influenced Breton's ideas on automatic writing
• Arthur Rimbaud's visionary poetry and concept of the "derangement of the senses" impacted Breton's poetic sensibilities

Purpose of manifestos

• Defined and articulated the principles and goals of the Surrealist movement
• Established Surrealism as a distinct artistic and philosophical approach
• Provided a framework for Surrealist practices and techniques
• Challenged conventional thinking and promoted revolutionary ideas in art and society

First Surrealist Manifesto

• Published in 1924, marking the official birth of the Surrealist movement
• Outlined the fundamental principles and practices of Surrealism
• Emphasized the importance of the unconscious mind in artistic creation

Key principles

• Rejection of rational thought and logic in favor of the irrational and unconscious
• Belief in the superiority of dreams and the imagination over waking reality
• Emphasis on the revolutionary potential of art to transform society
• Promotion of "psychic automatism" as a means of accessing the unconscious

Automatic writing

• Technique developed to bypass conscious control and access the unconscious mind
• Involves writing without conscious thought or editing, allowing free association of ideas
• Believed to reveal hidden truths and unexpected connections
• Practiced in group settings to explore collective unconscious (exquisite corpse)

Dream interpretation

• Viewed dreams as a direct link to the unconscious mind
• Encouraged recording and analysis of dreams for artistic inspiration
• Rejected Freudian symbolic interpretation in favor of literal dream imagery
• Used dream-like juxtapositions and imagery in Surrealist artworks and literature

Critique of rationalism

• Challenged the dominance of reason and logic in Western thought
• Argued that rationalism limited human potential and creativity
• Promoted the exploration of the irrational and the marvelous in everyday life
• Sought to reconcile the realms of dream and reality into an "absolute reality" (surreality)

Second Surrealist Manifesto

• Published in 1929, reflecting Breton's evolving vision for Surrealism
• Addressed internal conflicts within the movement and clarified its goals
• Emphasized the political dimension of Surrealism and its revolutionary aspirations

Shift in focus

• Moved from purely artistic concerns to a more explicitly political stance
• Emphasized the need for social and political revolution alongside artistic innovation
• Called for a deeper engagement with dialectical materialism and Marxist thought
• Expanded the scope of Surrealism to encompass all aspects of human experience

Political alignment

• Aligned Surrealism with communist ideals and revolutionary politics
• Criticized bourgeois society and capitalist values
• Called for the overthrow of existing social and political structures
• Explored the relationship between individual liberation and collective revolution

Exclusion of members

• Breton expelled several prominent Surrealists for ideological or personal reasons
• Criticized those who prioritized commercial success over revolutionary ideals
• Sought to maintain the purity and integrity of the Surrealist movement
• Created tensions and divisions within the Surrealist community

Occult influences

• Introduced esoteric and occult elements into Surrealist thought
• Explored alchemical symbolism and hermetic traditions
• Emphasized the transformative power of language and symbols
• Sought to reconcile materialist philosophy with mystical insights

Impact on Surrealist movement

• Breton's manifestos shaped the direction and practices of Surrealism for decades
• Established a theoretical framework for Surrealist art and literature
• Influenced the development of new artistic techniques and approaches
• Sparked debates and controversies within the art world and beyond

Artistic practices

• Encouraged experimentation with automatic drawing and painting techniques
• Promoted the use of collage and assemblage to create unexpected juxtapositions
• Inspired the creation of Surrealist objects with symbolic or psychological significance
• Led to the development of new forms of Surrealist cinema and photography

Literary techniques

• Popularized automatic writing as a method of literary creation
• Influenced the development of stream-of-consciousness narrative techniques
• Encouraged the use of dream-like imagery and non-linear storytelling
• Inspired experiments with language and syntax to create surreal effects

Group dynamics

• Established Breton as the central figure and leader of the Surrealist movement
• Created a hierarchical structure within the group, with Breton at the top
• Led to periodic purges and exclusions of members deemed insufficiently committed
• Fostered a sense of collective identity and shared purpose among Surrealists

Public perception

• Generated controversy and public interest in Surrealist ideas and artworks
• Challenged conventional notions of art and literature
• Attracted both passionate supporters and fierce critics
• Contributed to the mystique and enduring fascination with Surrealism

Critical reception

• Breton's manifestos elicited diverse reactions from artists, critics, and intellectuals
• Sparked debates about the nature of art, creativity, and social change
• Influenced subsequent art movements and critical theories
• Continue to be studied and analyzed in academic and artistic contexts

Contemporary responses

• Enthusiastic embrace by artists and writers seeking new forms of expression
• Skepticism from traditional art critics and conservative cultural figures
• Criticism from rival avant-garde movements (Dada, Futurism)
• Mixed reactions from political activists and Marxist thinkers

Later interpretations

• Reassessment of Breton's ideas in light of postmodern and poststructuralist theories
• Exploration of Surrealism's influence on popular culture and advertising
• Feminist critiques of Surrealism's male-dominated perspective
• Examination of Surrealism's relationship to colonialism and non-Western cultures

Academic analysis

• Study of Breton's manifestos in the context of avant-garde literary theory
• Analysis of the philosophical underpinnings of Surrealist thought
• Investigation of the political dimensions of Surrealism
• Exploration of the psychological and psychoanalytic aspects of Breton's ideas

Legacy of Breton's manifestos

• Continued influence on artistic and literary practices long after Surrealism's heyday
• Enduring impact on conceptions of creativity and the role of the unconscious
• Ongoing debates about the relationship between art and politics
• Lasting contribution to the theory and practice of avant-garde movements

Influence on later art movements

• Inspired aspects of Abstract Expressionism and Action Painting
• Contributed to the development of Pop Art and Neo-Dada
• Influenced conceptual art and performance art practices
• Shaped the emergence of magical realism in literature

Relevance in modern context

• Continued exploration of unconscious processes in contemporary art and literature
• Influence on digital art and new media practices
• Application of Surrealist techniques in advertising and popular culture
• Ongoing interest in the intersection of art, psychology, and social change

Critiques and controversies

• Debates over Breton's authoritarian leadership style and exclusionary practices
• Criticism of Surrealism's treatment of women and non-Western cultures
• Questions about the effectiveness of art as a tool for social and political change
• Discussions about the commodification and institutionalization of Surrealism

Comparison with other manifestos

• Breton's manifestos shared similarities and differences with other avant-garde declarations
• Reflected broader trends in modernist art and literature
• Contributed to the tradition of artistic manifestos as a form of cultural intervention
• Influenced subsequent manifestos in various artistic and political movements

Dada vs Surrealist manifestos

• Dada manifestos more anarchic and nihilistic in tone
• Surrealist manifestos more structured and programmatic
• Both challenged conventional art and society, but Surrealism offered a more constructive vision
• Dada focused on destruction of meaning, while Surrealism sought to reveal hidden meanings

Futurist vs Surrealist manifestos

• Futurist manifestos celebrated technology, speed, and modernity
• Surrealist manifestos emphasized the inner world and the unconscious
• Both sought to revolutionize art and society, but with different focuses
• Futurism aligned with fascism, while Surrealism aligned with communism

Political vs artistic manifestos

• Surrealist manifestos blended artistic and political concerns
• Compared to purely political manifestos, Breton's texts more poetic and open-ended
• Artistic manifestos generally more focused on aesthetic principles than social change
• Surrealist manifestos sought to bridge the gap between artistic and political revolution

Breton's writing style

• Characterized by a blend of poetic language and theoretical exposition
• Employed rhetorical techniques to persuade and inspire readers
• Reflected Breton's background as a poet and his interest in psychoanalysis
• Aimed to embody Surrealist principles in the very form of the manifestos

Poetic elements

• Use of vivid and unexpected imagery
• Incorporation of dream-like sequences and associations
• Emphasis on the sound and rhythm of language
• Integration of quotations from Surrealist poetry and prose

Rhetorical devices

• Employment of manifestos as a form of public declaration and call to action
• Use of repetition and anaphora for emphasis
• Incorporation of rhetorical questions to engage the reader
• Deployment of paradox and contradiction to challenge conventional thinking

Tone and voice

• Alternation between passionate enthusiasm and cool analysis
• Combination of personal anecdotes with theoretical arguments
• Use of humor and irony to critique societal norms
• Adoption of a prophetic or visionary stance at times

Key concepts and themes

• Breton's manifestos introduced and developed several core ideas that defined Surrealism
• These concepts shaped Surrealist theory and practice for decades
• Many of these themes continue to resonate in contemporary art and culture
• Understanding these key concepts is essential for grasping the full impact of Breton's manifestos

Unconscious mind

• Central importance of accessing and exploring the unconscious
• Belief in the creative potential of the unconscious mind
• Techniques developed to tap into unconscious processes (automatic writing, dream analysis)
• Challenge to rational, conscious control in artistic creation

Revolutionary potential of art

• Art as a means of transforming consciousness and society
• Rejection of "art for art's sake" in favor of art as a revolutionary tool
• Belief in the power of imagination to change reality
• Fusion of artistic and political revolution

Rejection of bourgeois values

• Critique of rationalism, materialism, and utilitarianism
• Challenge to conventional morality and social norms
• Embrace of the irrational, the marvelous, and the taboo
• Desire to liberate human desire and imagination from societal constraints

Synthesis of opposites

• Attempt to reconcile contradictions (dream/reality, conscious/unconscious)
• Concept of "convulsive beauty" embracing attraction and repulsion
• Exploration of coincidence and objective chance
• Belief in the unity of all things beneath surface appearances