4.2 André Breton and the Surrealist Manifesto

André Breton, the father of Surrealism, shaped a revolutionary art movement that challenged conventional thinking. His Surrealist Manifesto, published in 1924, laid out the core principles of accessing the unconscious mind through art and writing.

Breton's work blended psychoanalysis, automatism, and dream interpretation to create a new artistic language. His ideas on automatic writing and the exploration of the subconscious continue to influence artists and writers today, cementing Surrealism's lasting impact on culture.

Background of André Breton

• Breton's life and work laid the foundation for Surrealism, a revolutionary art movement that emerged from Dada in the early 20th century
• His background in medicine and psychology profoundly influenced the development of Surrealist theories and practices
• Breton's journey from Dada to Surrealism reflects the broader artistic and intellectual shifts of the interwar period

Early life and influences

Top images from around the web for Early life and influences

• 

  Freud's psychoanalytic theories - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud's psychoanalytic theories - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Early life and influences

• 

  Freud's psychoanalytic theories - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Freud's psychoanalytic theories - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Born in 1896 in Tinchebray, France, Breton grew up in a middle-class family
• Studied medicine and worked in psychiatric wards during World War I, exposing him to Freudian psychoanalysis
• Developed a fascination with the unconscious mind and its potential for artistic expression
• Early literary influences included symbolist poets (Arthur Rimbaud, Stéphane Mallarmé)
• Encountered works of Guillaume Apollinaire, which sparked his interest in avant-garde literature

Involvement in Dada movement

• Joined the Dada movement in Paris in 1919, attracted by its anti-establishment and anti-war stance
• Collaborated with key Dadaists (Tristan Tzara, Francis Picabia) on publications and performances
• Organized Dada events and exhibitions, challenging traditional artistic conventions
• Began experimenting with automatic writing techniques during this period
• Grew dissatisfied with Dada's nihilism and lack of constructive goals by the early 1920s

Transition to Surrealism

• Gradually moved away from Dada, seeking a more positive and structured artistic philosophy
• Organized a group of like-minded artists and writers to explore new creative possibilities
• Conducted experiments in automatic writing and dream analysis with fellow poets (Louis Aragon, Philippe Soupault)
• Published "Les Champs magnétiques" in 1920, considered the first Surrealist text
• Formally launched Surrealism with the publication of the First Surrealist Manifesto in 1924

The Surrealist Manifesto

• Served as the foundational document of the Surrealist movement, outlining its core principles and goals
• Positioned Surrealism as a revolutionary approach to art and life, emphasizing the power of the unconscious
• Established Breton as the leading theorist and spokesman for Surrealism, shaping its direction for decades

Historical context

• Published in 1924, during the interwar period marked by disillusionment and social upheaval
• Responded to the perceived failures of rationalism and traditional artistic expression
• Influenced by recent developments in psychology, particularly Freudian psychoanalysis
• Emerged from the ashes of Dada, seeking to channel its rebellious spirit into a more constructive movement
• Reflected broader cultural trends, including interest in dreams, the occult, and non-Western art

Key principles and ideas

• Defined Surrealism as "pure psychic automatism" aimed at expressing the true functioning of thought
• Emphasized the importance of the unconscious mind in artistic creation
• Advocated for the liberation of imagination from the constraints of reason and morality
• Proposed techniques for accessing the unconscious (automatic writing, dream analysis)
• Called for the reconciliation of dream and reality into an "absolute reality" or "surreality"
• Rejected traditional artistic values in favor of spontaneity, irrationality, and the marvelous

Writing process and publication

• Drafted by Breton over several months, incorporating ideas developed through group experiments
• Circulated among close associates for feedback and revision before publication
• Published as a book-length essay by Éditions du Sagittaire in Paris
• Included examples of Surrealist texts and a list of Surrealist practitioners
• Received mixed reactions from the artistic community, ranging from enthusiasm to skepticism
• Followed by a Second Manifesto in 1929, which further refined Surrealist principles and addressed internal conflicts

Automatic writing

• Represented a cornerstone of Surrealist practice, aiming to bypass conscious control and access the unconscious
• Played a crucial role in Breton's development of Surrealist theory and literature
• Influenced various art forms beyond writing, including visual arts and performance

Concept and technique

• Involved writing rapidly without conscious control or premeditation
• Aimed to capture the "true functioning of thought" unfiltered by reason or moral concerns
• Often performed in a trance-like state or immediately upon waking from sleep
• Could be done individually or collaboratively, sometimes as a game or experiment
• Emphasized speed and spontaneity over coherence or literary quality
• Sought to reveal hidden associations, desires, and fears within the psyche

Influence on Surrealist literature

• Produced texts characterized by unexpected juxtapositions, non-linear narratives, and vivid imagery
• Led to the creation of new literary forms and styles unique to Surrealism
• Inspired poets to explore the limits of language and meaning
• Challenged traditional notions of authorship and artistic intention
• Influenced later experimental writing techniques (cut-up method, stream of consciousness)
• Contributed to the development of Surrealist novels and poetry collections

Examples in Breton's work

• "Les Champs magnétiques" (1920), co-written with Philippe Soupault, considered the first Surrealist book
• "Poisson soluble" (1924), a collection of automatic texts included with the First Surrealist Manifesto
• Sections of "Nadja" (1928) incorporate automatic writing techniques
• "L'Immaculée Conception" (1930), co-written with Paul Éluard, explores various states of mental illness through automatic writing
• "The Automatic Message" (1933), an essay discussing the theory and practice of automatism

Dream interpretation

• Formed a central component of Surrealist practice, bridging art and psychoanalysis
• Allowed Surrealists to explore the unconscious mind and its symbolic language
• Influenced the content and style of Surrealist art and literature

Freudian influences

• Drew heavily on Sigmund Freud's theories of dream analysis and the unconscious
• Adopted Freud's idea that dreams represent wish fulfillment and repressed desires
• Utilized free association techniques to uncover hidden meanings in dream imagery
• Embraced the concept of the "manifest content" (surface narrative) and "latent content" (underlying meaning) of dreams
• Diverged from Freud in emphasizing the poetic and revolutionary potential of dreams
• Expanded dream interpretation beyond individual psychology to collective cultural significance

Role in Surrealist practice

• Encouraged Surrealists to record and analyze their dreams regularly
• Used dream imagery as a source of inspiration for artworks and writings
• Incorporated dream-like qualities into Surrealist paintings and films
• Developed techniques to induce dream-like states while awake (hypnosis, sleep deprivation)
• Organized group sessions for sharing and interpreting dreams
• Published dream accounts in Surrealist journals and anthologies

Breton's personal dream analyses

• Recorded his own dreams extensively, often incorporating them into his writings
• Analyzed the dream of the "sunflower" in "Les Vases communicants" (1932)
• Explored the relationship between dreams and waking life in "Communicating Vessels" (1932)
• Discussed the role of dreams in creativity in "The Automatic Message" (1933)
• Used dream material in the composition of "L'Amour fou" (1937)
• Continued to emphasize the importance of dreams throughout his career, influencing later Surrealist generations

Breton's literary works

• Represented the practical application of Surrealist principles in literature
• Blended autobiography, fiction, and philosophical reflection
• Explored themes of love, chance, and the marvelous in everyday life
• Influenced generations of writers and artists beyond the Surrealist movement

Nadja

• Published in 1928, considered one of Breton's most important works
• Semi-autobiographical novel recounting Breton's relationship with a mentally unstable woman
• Incorporated photographs and drawings, challenging traditional narrative structures
• Explored themes of madness, love, and the boundaries between reality and imagination
• Utilized automatic writing techniques and dream-like sequences
• Exemplified the Surrealist concept of "objective chance" and the pursuit of the marvelous

L'Amour fou

• Published in 1937, further developed Breton's ideas on love and chance
• Blended personal anecdotes, philosophical reflections, and poetic prose
• Explored the concept of "convulsive beauty" and its manifestation in everyday life
• Included accounts of Breton's travels and encounters with art and nature
• Incorporated photographs by Man Ray and Brassaï
• Presented love as a revolutionary force capable of transforming perception and society

Arcane 17

• Written during Breton's exile in North America, published in 1945
• Inspired by Breton's relationship with Elisa Claro and his experiences in Québec
• Incorporated elements of alchemy, tarot symbolism, and Celtic mythology
• Reflected on themes of war, love, and rebirth in the context of World War II
• Explored the feminine principle as a source of renewal and transformation
• Combined personal narrative with political and philosophical reflections
• Represented a mature expression of Breton's Surrealist vision and poetic style

Impact on visual arts

• Surrealism profoundly influenced painting, sculpture, photography, and film
• Breton's theories and writings provided a framework for visual artists to explore the unconscious
• Surrealist visual art challenged traditional notions of representation and reality

Collaboration with artists

• Worked closely with painters (Max Ernst, Salvador Dalí, Joan Miró) to develop Surrealist techniques
• Wrote critical essays and monographs on Surrealist artists, helping to define their place in the movement
• Collaborated on exquisite corpse drawings and other collective artistic experiments
• Encouraged interdisciplinary projects combining visual art, poetry, and performance
• Organized group exhibitions and publications featuring both literary and visual works
• Fostered connections between Surrealist writers and artists, leading to numerous collaborations

Surrealist exhibitions

• Organized the first Surrealist exhibition in 1925 at the Galerie Pierre in Paris
• Curated the International Surrealist Exhibition in London in 1936, introducing Surrealism to a wider audience
• Designed innovative exhibition spaces that immersed viewers in Surrealist environments
• Included unconventional elements in exhibitions (live performances, found objects, natural specimens)
• Collaborated with artists to create Surrealist objects and installations for exhibitions
• Continued to organize Surrealist exhibitions throughout his life, even after leaving France

Influence on painting techniques

• Promoted automatism in visual art, encouraging spontaneous and unplanned creation
• Advocated for the use of chance and accident in the creative process
• Encouraged the exploration of dream imagery and the juxtaposition of unrelated objects
• Supported the development of new techniques (frottage, grattage, decalcomania)
• Emphasized the importance of the unconscious in generating visual ideas
• Influenced the development of Abstract Expressionism and other post-war art movements

Political engagement

• Breton viewed Surrealism as inherently political, aiming to transform society and human consciousness
• His political stance evolved over time, from anarchism to Marxism and later Trotskyism
• Surrealism's political engagement often led to conflicts within the movement and with other leftist groups

Marxism and Surrealism

• Embraced Marxism in the late 1920s, seeing it as compatible with Surrealist goals of liberation
• Attempted to reconcile Freudian psychoanalysis with Marxist historical materialism
• Joined the French Communist Party in 1927 but was expelled in 1933 due to ideological differences
• Wrote "Legitimate Defense" (1926) and "Second Manifesto of Surrealism" (1929), articulating Surrealism's political position
• Organized the Surrealist group "Contre-Attaque" in 1935 to combat fascism and bourgeois culture
• Continued to advocate for a revolution that would transform both social structures and human consciousness

Trotsky connection

• Met Leon Trotsky in Mexico in 1938, forming a significant intellectual and political alliance
• Co-authored the manifesto "For an Independent Revolutionary Art" with Trotsky and Diego Rivera
• Established the International Federation of Independent Revolutionary Art (FIARI) to promote artistic freedom
• Defended Trotsky against Stalinist attacks and promoted his ideas within Surrealist circles
• Maintained correspondence with Trotsky until the latter's assassination in 1940
• Continued to support Trotskyist ideas and organizations throughout his life

Anti-fascist stance

• Took a strong stance against fascism and Nazism from the early 1930s onward
• Organized anti-fascist demonstrations and publications with other Surrealists
• Collaborated with anti-fascist artists and writers in exile during World War II
• Wrote "Fata Morgana" (1940), a long poem critiquing fascism and the Vichy regime
• Supported the Spanish Republic during the Spanish Civil War
• Continued to speak out against authoritarianism and totalitarianism in post-war years

Legacy and influence

• Breton's work and ideas continue to impact art, literature, and cultural theory long after his death
• Surrealism's influence extends far beyond its original context, shaping various aspects of modern and contemporary culture
• Breton's writings and theories remain subjects of scholarly study and artistic inspiration

Surrealism's global spread

• Surrealist groups formed in numerous countries, adapting Breton's ideas to local contexts
• Surrealism influenced art movements in Latin America, Japan, and Eastern Europe
• Breton's travels and exile during World War II helped disseminate Surrealist ideas globally
• International Surrealist exhibitions introduced the movement to new audiences worldwide
• Surrealist techniques and concepts were adopted by filmmakers, advertisers, and popular culture
• The Surrealist emphasis on the unconscious and dreams influenced the development of psychedelic art and culture

Impact on later art movements

• Abstract Expressionism drew on Surrealist automatism and emphasis on the unconscious
• Pop Art incorporated Surrealist juxtapositions and interest in everyday objects
• Conceptual Art was influenced by Surrealism's challenge to traditional artistic conventions
• Feminist artists reinterpreted Surrealist themes and techniques from a gender-conscious perspective
• Magical Realism in literature incorporated elements of Surrealist storytelling and imagery
• Performance art and Happenings drew on Surrealist ideas of chance and audience participation

Breton's lasting contributions

• Established automatic writing as a literary technique, influencing experimental writing
• Developed theories of the "marvelous" and "convulsive beauty" that continue to inspire artists
• Promoted interdisciplinary collaboration between writers, artists, and thinkers
• Advocated for the integration of art and life, influencing later avant-garde movements
• Contributed to the reevaluation of "outsider art" and non-Western artistic traditions
• His extensive art collection and archives continue to be studied and exhibited

Criticism and controversies

• Breton's leadership of the Surrealist movement was often contentious and marked by conflicts
• Debates over Surrealism's political engagement and artistic practices led to numerous schisms
• Breton's personal style and decisions were sometimes criticized as authoritarian or dogmatic

Conflicts within Surrealist group

• Disagreements over political alignment led to expulsions and departures from the movement
• Tensions arose between those favoring a more political approach and those focused on artistic experimentation
• Debates over the role of automatism versus more controlled techniques in Surrealist art
• Conflicts emerged over the inclusion or exclusion of certain artists and writers from the movement
• Disagreements about the relationship between Surrealism and other avant-garde movements (Dada, Cubism)
• Personal rivalries and romantic entanglements often complicated group dynamics

Expulsions and power struggles

• Breton expelled several prominent members (Antonin Artaud, Robert Desnos) for perceived ideological deviations
• Salvador Dalí was "excommunicated" from the movement in 1939 due to political disagreements
• Louis Aragon's departure in 1932 to join the Communist Party caused a significant rift
• Georges Bataille's rival group "Documents" challenged Breton's vision of Surrealism
• Power struggles between Breton and other leading figures (Paul Éluard, Tristan Tzara) led to factional splits
• Breton's attempts to maintain control over the movement's direction were sometimes seen as autocratic

Debates on Surrealism's relevance

• Critics argued that Surrealism became formulaic and lost its revolutionary potential over time
• Questions arose about the movement's ability to effect real social and political change
• Some viewed Surrealism's emphasis on the unconscious as escapist or apolitical
• Debates emerged over whether Surrealism could adapt to changing cultural and political contexts
• Feminist critics challenged Surrealism's often male-centric and objectifying portrayal of women
• Post-war artists and critics questioned the continued relevance of Surrealist techniques and ideas

Breton vs other Surrealists

• Breton's role as the primary theorist and leader of Surrealism often put him at odds with other members
• Differences in artistic approach, political ideology, and personal temperament led to various conflicts
• These tensions shaped the evolution of Surrealism and influenced its various offshoots

Philosophical differences

• Disagreements with Georges Bataille over the role of base materialism and transgression in art
• Conflicts with Louis Aragon over the compatibility of Surrealism with orthodox Communism
• Debates with Salvador Dalí regarding the "paranoiac-critical method" and political engagement
• Disagreements with André Masson over the balance between automatism and conscious control in art
• Tensions with Benjamin Péret over the role of humor and irreverence in Surrealist practice
• Disputes with Antonin Artaud concerning the nature of madness and its relation to creativity

Artistic approach comparisons

• Breton favored literary Surrealism, while others (Max Ernst, Man Ray) focused more on visual arts
• Differences in the use of automatism: Breton emphasized pure psychic automatism, while others incorporated more controlled techniques
• Varying approaches to dream imagery: Breton's more analytical style versus the more intuitive approach of painters like Dalí
• Debates over the role of politics in art: Breton's insistence on political engagement versus those who preferred a more apolitical stance
• Different interpretations of the "marvelous": Breton's emphasis on everyday encounters versus more fantastical or mythological approaches
• Varying degrees of engagement with traditional artistic skills and techniques

Personal rivalries

• Tension with Tristan Tzara dating back to their Dada days, culminating in physical altercations
• Competitive relationship with Paul Éluard, both personally and professionally
• Falling out with Salvador Dalí over political views and Dalí's increasing commercialism
• Conflicts with André Masson over leadership and direction of the Surrealist group
• Rivalry with Georges Bataille for intellectual and cultural influence in Paris
• Strained relationships with former close collaborators like Louis Aragon and Philippe Soupault after their departures from the movement