6.1 Automatic writing

Automatic writing emerged as a revolutionary technique in early 20th-century Surrealism. It aimed to tap into the unconscious mind, challenging traditional literary conventions and exploring the irrational and dream-like aspects of human thought.

Rooted in spiritualism and influenced by Freudian psychology, automatic writing became a tool for artistic liberation. Surrealists like André Breton and Philippe Soupault pioneered its use, emphasizing spontaneity and speed to bypass conscious interference and reveal hidden truths.

Origins of automatic writing

• Emerged as a revolutionary technique in the early 20th century, challenging traditional literary conventions
• Sought to tap into the unconscious mind, aligning with Surrealist goals of exploring the irrational and dream-like
• Represented a radical departure from structured, deliberate writing processes

Precursors in spiritualism

Top images from around the web for Precursors in spiritualism

• 

  Automatic writing - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealist automatism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Mediumship - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Automatic writing - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealist automatism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Precursors in spiritualism

• 

  Automatic writing - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealist automatism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Mediumship - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Automatic writing - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surrealist automatism - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rooted in 19th-century spiritualist practices, used to communicate with the dead
• Mediums claimed to channel spirits through writing, often in trance-like states
• Influenced by the planchette, a heart-shaped board used in séances
• Spiritualist automatic writing often produced cryptic or nonsensical messages, later reinterpreted by Surrealists

Influence of Freudian psychology

• Drew heavily from Freud's theories of the unconscious mind
• Utilized free association techniques to bypass conscious thought
• Aimed to reveal hidden desires, fears, and repressed memories
• Surrealists saw automatic writing as a way to access the "true thought" beneath social conditioning

Surrealist adoption and adaptation

• André Breton and Philippe Soupault pioneered surrealist automatic writing in 1919
• Viewed as a tool for artistic and personal liberation from societal constraints
• Emphasized speed and spontaneity to prevent conscious interference
• Resulted in unexpected juxtapositions and dream-like imagery in texts

Techniques and methods

• Automatic writing challenged traditional notions of authorship and creative control
• Surrealists developed various approaches to achieve a state of "pure psychic automatism"
• These methods aimed to bypass rational thought and tap directly into the subconscious

Stream of consciousness

• Involves writing continuously without stopping to edit or censor thoughts
• Practitioners aim to capture the natural flow of ideas and associations
• Often results in non-linear, fragmented texts that mirror the mind's workings
• James Joyce's "Ulysses" incorporates elements of this technique, though not strictly automatic

Trance-like states

• Writers induce altered states of consciousness to facilitate automatic writing
• Methods include meditation, sleep deprivation, or use of mind-altering substances
• Robert Desnos famously entered trance states during Surrealist séances
• Trance writing often produced more abstract and disconnected texts than other methods

Collaborative automatic writing

• Multiple writers contribute to a single text without prior planning
• Each participant adds to the work without seeing previous contributions
• Creates unexpected narrative shifts and surreal juxtapositions
• "The Magnetic Fields" by Breton and Soupault exemplifies this approach

Key practitioners

• Surrealist automatic writing was pioneered and developed by several influential figures
• Each practitioner brought unique approaches and interpretations to the technique
• Their work significantly shaped the development of Surrealism and modern literature

André Breton's experiments

• Considered the founder of Surrealism and a key proponent of automatic writing
• Co-authored "The Magnetic Fields" with Philippe Soupault in 1919
• Developed the concept of "pure psychic automatism" in the Surrealist Manifesto
• Breton's automatic texts often explored themes of love, revolution, and the marvelous

Philippe Soupault's contributions

• Collaborated with Breton on early automatic writing experiments
• Focused on the poetic potential of automatic writing
• Produced solo works like "The Wesleyan Grove" using automatic techniques
• Soupault's style tended to be more lyrical and less overtly political than Breton's

Robert Desnos vs Louis Aragon

• Desnos known for entering deep trance states during Surrealist séances
  • Produced rapid-fire automatic poetry and drawings
  • His work often featured dark, erotic imagery
• Aragon initially embraced automatic writing but later rejected it
  • Moved towards more politically engaged, conscious writing
  • Criticized automatic writing as potentially trivial or self-indulgent

Literary applications

• Automatic writing profoundly influenced various forms of literature
• Surrealists applied the technique to challenge conventional literary structures
• The method's impact extended beyond Surrealism, influencing later literary movements

Surrealist poetry

• Automatic writing produced poems with unexpected imagery and associations
• Often lacked traditional rhyme schemes or metrical structures
• Emphasized sound and rhythm over literal meaning
• Paul Éluard's "The Earth is Blue Like an Orange" exemplifies surrealist automatic poetry

Prose experiments

• Resulted in stream-of-consciousness narratives and fragmented storylines
• Challenged linear plot structures and character development
• André Breton's "Nadja" incorporates elements of automatic writing in its narrative
• Often blurred the lines between fiction, autobiography, and dream accounts

Automatic writing in manifestos

• Used to articulate Surrealist principles and goals
• The first Surrealist Manifesto (1924) includes passages of automatic writing
• Manifestos often combined theoretical statements with poetic, automatic sections
• Demonstrated the revolutionary potential of automatic writing in political discourse

Visual arts connection

• Automatic writing techniques inspired and influenced visual artists
• Surrealists sought to apply similar principles of spontaneity to visual mediums
• These practices led to new forms of artistic expression and collaboration

Automatic drawing

• Artists created images without conscious control or planning
• André Masson pioneered automatic drawing techniques in the 1920s
• Often resulted in abstract, biomorphic forms and tangled lines
• Salvador Dalí's "paranoiac-critical method" incorporated elements of automatism

Exquisite corpse technique

• Collaborative drawing game based on automatic writing principles
• Each artist contributes to a section of a drawing without seeing others' work
• Results in surreal, composite figures with unexpected juxtapositions
• Popularized by André Breton, Yves Tanguy, and Jacques Prévert

Influence on abstract expressionism

• Automatic techniques inspired post-war American artists
• Jackson Pollock's "action painting" drew from surrealist automatism
• Emphasized spontaneous gesture and subconscious expression
• Led to the development of new painting techniques (drip painting)

Philosophical implications

• Automatic writing challenged fundamental assumptions about creativity and consciousness
• Raised questions about the nature of authorship and artistic intention
• Influenced philosophical debates on free will, determinism, and the self

Unconscious vs conscious mind

• Posited the unconscious as a source of creativity and truth
• Challenged the primacy of rational thought in artistic creation
• Explored the tension between conscious control and unconscious expression
• Raised questions about the reliability of conscious perception and memory

Rejection of rational thought

• Automatic writing sought to bypass logical thinking and social conditioning
• Valued irrationality and nonsense as paths to deeper truths
• Challenged Western philosophical traditions emphasizing reason and logic
• Aligned with Dadaist rejection of bourgeois values and conventional wisdom

Exploration of chance and spontaneity

• Embraced randomness as a creative force
• Questioned the role of intention in art and literature
• Anticipated later philosophical interest in chaos theory and emergent systems
• Influenced the development of aleatory music and chance-based art (John Cage)

Critical reception

• Automatic writing elicited diverse reactions from critics, artists, and the public
• Opinions varied widely, from enthusiastic embrace to skepticism and dismissal
• The technique's reception evolved over time, reflecting changing cultural attitudes

Contemporary reactions

• Initially met with shock and controversy in literary circles
• Some critics dismissed automatic texts as nonsensical or meaningless
• Avant-garde artists and writers embraced the technique as revolutionary
• Public reactions ranged from fascination to ridicule

Later scholarly analysis

• Academic interest in automatic writing grew in the mid-20th century
• Psychoanalytic critics explored its relationship to Freudian theory
• Literary scholars debated its impact on narrative structure and poetics
• Cultural historians examined its role in avant-garde movements

Influence on postmodern literature

• Automatic writing techniques informed postmodern approaches to text
• Influenced the development of cut-up technique (William S. Burroughs)
• Contributed to the breakdown of traditional narrative structures
• Inspired experimental forms like hypertext and interactive fiction

Legacy and modern applications

• Automatic writing's influence extends beyond its Surrealist origins
• The technique has been adapted and reinterpreted in various contexts
• Contemporary applications range from artistic practices to therapeutic tools

Beat generation influence

• Beat writers like Jack Kerouac adopted elements of automatic writing
• Kerouac's "spontaneous prose" method drew from surrealist automatism
• Allen Ginsberg's "first thought, best thought" approach echoed automatic principles
• Beat poetry often incorporated stream-of-consciousness and spontaneous elements

Digital age adaptations

• Computer programs simulate automatic writing processes
• Online collaborative writing platforms enable digital exquisite corpse experiments
• Social media platforms (Twitter) encourage rapid, unfiltered text production
• AI language models (GPT-3) raise new questions about authorship and automatism

Therapeutic uses

• Automatic writing adapted for psychological and spiritual practices
• Used in art therapy to access subconscious thoughts and emotions
• Some New Age practices employ automatic writing for self-discovery
• Mindfulness and meditation techniques incorporate elements of automatism

Limitations and criticisms

• Despite its influence, automatic writing faced significant challenges and critiques
• Debates about its validity and value continue in artistic and academic circles
• Critics raised concerns about the technique's limitations and potential drawbacks

Authenticity debates

• Questions arose about the truly "automatic" nature of the writing
• Critics argued that conscious control always plays some role in the process
• Some practitioners admitted to editing or selecting from automatic texts
• Debates over the role of skill and intention in producing meaningful automatic writing

Artistic merit controversies

• Some critics dismissed automatic texts as lacking coherence or depth
• Questions about the value of texts produced without conscious craft or intention
• Debates over whether automatic writing could produce "true" art or literature
• Concerns that the technique might lead to self-indulgence or artistic stagnation

Scientific skepticism

• Lack of empirical evidence for claims about accessing the unconscious
• Psychological studies questioned the reliability of automatic writing
• Neuroscientific research challenges some assumptions about consciousness and creativity
• Debates over the relationship between automatic writing and genuine insight or self-knowledge