2.2 Terahertz detectors

Terahertz detectors are crucial for converting terahertz radiation into measurable electrical signals in imaging systems. They come in two main types: thermal detectors, which absorb radiation as heat, and photonic detectors, which rely on direct photon-carrier interactions.

The choice between thermal and photonic detectors depends on factors like sensitivity, speed, and operating temperature. Thermal detectors are slower but more broadband, while photonic detectors offer higher speed and sensitivity but are limited to specific spectral ranges.

Types of terahertz detectors

• Terahertz detectors are a critical component in terahertz imaging systems, converting the incident terahertz radiation into measurable electrical signals
• Two main categories of terahertz detectors are thermal detectors and photonic detectors, each with distinct operating principles and characteristics
• The choice of detector type depends on factors such as the desired sensitivity, speed, spectral range, and operating temperature of the terahertz imaging system

Thermal vs photonic detectors

Top images from around the web for Thermal vs photonic detectors

• 

  Frontiers | Localized Electromagnetic Resonance Enabled THz Photothermoelectric Detection in ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Localized Electromagnetic Resonance Enabled THz Photothermoelectric Detection in ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Thermal vs photonic detectors

• 

  Frontiers | Localized Electromagnetic Resonance Enabled THz Photothermoelectric Detection in ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Localized Electromagnetic Resonance Enabled THz Photothermoelectric Detection in ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Thermal detectors absorb terahertz radiation and convert it into heat, causing a change in a temperature-dependent property (resistance, voltage, or pressure) that is measured
• Photonic detectors rely on the direct interaction between terahertz photons and charge carriers in a semiconductor or superconductor material, generating an electrical signal
• Thermal detectors are generally slower but more broadband, while photonic detectors offer higher speed and sensitivity but are limited to specific spectral ranges

Bolometers for thermal detection

• Bolometers are thermal detectors that measure the change in resistance of a temperature-sensitive material (thermistor) when exposed to terahertz radiation
• The thermistor is thermally isolated from the surrounding environment to maximize sensitivity and is typically made of materials with a high temperature coefficient of resistance (vanadium oxide, silicon germanium)
• Bolometers require cooling to minimize background thermal noise and achieve high detectivity, often using cryogenic temperatures (liquid helium or closed-cycle refrigerators)

Pyroelectric detectors

• Pyroelectric detectors exploit the pyroelectric effect in certain crystalline materials (lithium tantalate, triglycine sulfate) that generate a temporary voltage when their temperature changes due to absorbed terahertz radiation
• These detectors are typically operated at room temperature and offer broadband response, but require modulated terahertz signals to measure the time-varying pyroelectric voltage
• Pyroelectric detectors are often used in compact, low-cost terahertz imaging systems for applications such as security screening and non-destructive testing

Golay cells

• Golay cells are optoacoustic detectors that consist of a sealed chamber filled with a gas (xenon) and a flexible membrane with a reflective coating
• Absorbed terahertz radiation heats the gas, causing it to expand and deflect the membrane, which is measured optically using a laser and photodetector
• Golay cells offer high sensitivity and broad spectral response but are relatively slow and fragile, limiting their use in high-speed or rugged terahertz imaging applications

Photoconductors for photonic detection

• Photoconductors are semiconductor devices that change their electrical conductivity when illuminated with terahertz radiation, generating a measurable photocurrent
• The photoconductor material is chosen to have a bandgap energy slightly lower than the terahertz photon energy, allowing for efficient photon absorption and carrier generation
• Common photoconductor materials for terahertz detection include low-temperature-grown gallium arsenide (LT-GaAs), indium gallium arsenide (InGaAs), and graphene

Schottky diodes

• Schottky diodes are metal-semiconductor junctions that exhibit nonlinear current-voltage characteristics, allowing them to rectify and detect terahertz signals
• The high-frequency performance of Schottky diodes is determined by the junction capacitance and series resistance, which can be optimized through device geometry and material choice (GaAs, InGaAs)
• Schottky diodes are often used as heterodyne mixers in terahertz imaging systems, downconverting the terahertz signal to a lower intermediate frequency for easier processing and detection

Field effect transistors

• Field effect transistors (FETs) can be used as terahertz detectors by exploiting the nonlinear characteristics of the transistor channel under terahertz irradiation
• Terahertz radiation coupled to the FET gate or channel can modulate the device's conductance, allowing for sensitive detection of terahertz signals
• High-electron-mobility transistors (HEMTs) based on III-V semiconductors (GaAs, InP) are particularly well-suited for terahertz detection due to their high carrier mobility and low noise characteristics

Figures of merit

• To evaluate and compare the performance of different terahertz detectors, several key figures of merit are used
• These metrics quantify the detector's sensitivity, noise, speed, and overall efficiency in converting terahertz radiation into measurable electrical signals
• Understanding these figures of merit is essential for selecting the appropriate detector for a given terahertz imaging application and optimizing the system's performance

Responsivity of detectors

• Responsivity is a measure of the detector's output signal (voltage or current) per unit input terahertz power, expressed in units of V/W or A/W
• A higher responsivity indicates a more sensitive detector, capable of generating larger output signals for a given terahertz input
• Responsivity can be frequency-dependent, so it is important to specify the operating frequency or spectral range when comparing detector responsivities

Noise equivalent power

• Noise equivalent power (NEP) is the minimum input terahertz power that produces an output signal equal to the detector's noise level, expressed in units of W/√Hz
• A lower NEP indicates a more sensitive detector, capable of detecting weaker terahertz signals in the presence of noise
• NEP takes into account both the detector's responsivity and its noise characteristics, providing a comprehensive measure of the detector's sensitivity

Specific detectivity

• Specific detectivity (D*) is a figure of merit that normalizes the detector's sensitivity with respect to its active area and bandwidth, allowing for comparison between detectors of different sizes and operating frequencies
• D* is defined as the square root of the detector area divided by the NEP, expressed in units of cm√Hz/W (or Jones)
• A higher D* indicates a more sensitive detector, capable of detecting weaker terahertz signals in a given area and bandwidth

Response time and bandwidth

• Response time is a measure of how quickly the detector can respond to changes in the input terahertz signal, typically defined as the time required for the output signal to rise from 10% to 90% of its final value
• Bandwidth is the range of frequencies over which the detector can operate efficiently, determined by factors such as the detector's response time, parasitic capacitances, and coupling structures
• Faster response times and wider bandwidths are desirable for high-speed terahertz imaging applications, such as real-time non-destructive testing or high-throughput security screening

Thermal detector characteristics

• Thermal detectors rely on the conversion of absorbed terahertz radiation into heat, which then causes a measurable change in a temperature-dependent property of the detector material
• The performance of thermal detectors is governed by several key characteristics, including thermal isolation, heat capacity, thermal time constants, and the temperature coefficient of resistance
• Optimizing these characteristics is crucial for achieving high sensitivity, fast response times, and low noise in thermal terahertz detectors

Thermal isolation for sensitivity

• Thermal isolation is essential for maximizing the sensitivity of thermal detectors, as it ensures that the absorbed terahertz energy is efficiently converted into a measurable temperature change
• This is typically achieved by suspending the detector element on thin, thermally insulating support structures (silicon nitride membranes, silicon beams) that minimize heat loss to the surrounding environment
• Higher thermal isolation leads to larger temperature changes for a given terahertz input power, improving the detector's responsivity and NEP

Heat capacity considerations

• The heat capacity of the detector element determines the amount of energy required to change its temperature by a given amount, directly impacting the detector's sensitivity and response time
• A lower heat capacity allows for larger temperature changes and faster response times for a given terahertz input power
• Heat capacity can be minimized by using thin, low-mass detector materials and optimizing the geometry of the detector element (microbolometers, nanowires)

Thermal time constants

• The thermal time constant is a measure of how quickly the detector element can heat up and cool down in response to changes in the input terahertz power
• It is determined by the ratio of the detector's heat capacity to its thermal conductance to the surrounding environment
• Shorter thermal time constants enable faster detector response times and higher operating frequencies, which are important for real-time terahertz imaging applications

Temperature coefficient of resistance

• The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) is a measure of how strongly the detector material's electrical resistance changes with temperature
• A high TCR is desirable for thermal detectors, as it translates small temperature changes into large, measurable resistance changes
• Common materials with high TCRs include vanadium oxide (VOx), amorphous silicon (a-Si), and yttrium barium copper oxide (YBCO) superconductors

Photonic detector characteristics

• Photonic detectors operate by directly converting incident terahertz photons into electrical signals through interactions with charge carriers in semiconductor or superconductor materials
• The performance of photonic detectors is influenced by several key characteristics, including semiconductor band gaps, photoconductive gain, carrier lifetime and mobility, and impedance matching
• Understanding and optimizing these characteristics is essential for developing high-performance photonic terahertz detectors for various imaging applications

Semiconductor band gaps

• The band gap of a semiconductor material determines the minimum photon energy required to excite an electron from the valence band to the conduction band, creating a free charge carrier
• For efficient terahertz detection, the semiconductor band gap should be slightly smaller than the energy of the targeted terahertz photons (4.1 meV for 1 THz)
• Common semiconductor materials for terahertz photonic detectors include gallium arsenide (GaAs), indium gallium arsenide (InGaAs), and indium antimonide (InSb)

Photoconductive gain

• Photoconductive gain is a measure of the number of charge carriers collected by the detector electrodes for each absorbed terahertz photon
• A high photoconductive gain enables more sensitive detection, as it amplifies the photocurrent generated by the incident terahertz radiation
• Photoconductive gain can be enhanced by optimizing the detector geometry, applying a bias voltage, or using materials with long carrier lifetimes (low-temperature-grown GaAs)

Carrier lifetime and mobility

• Carrier lifetime is the average time that a photogenerated charge carrier remains free before recombining with an opposite charge carrier or being trapped by a defect state
• Carrier mobility is a measure of how easily charge carriers can move through the semiconductor material under the influence of an electric field
• Longer carrier lifetimes and higher mobilities enable faster detector response times and higher operating frequencies, which are important for high-speed terahertz imaging applications

Impedance matching for coupling

• Impedance matching is crucial for efficient coupling of the incident terahertz radiation into the photonic detector material
• Mismatches between the free-space impedance (377 Ω) and the detector impedance can lead to reflections and reduced sensitivity
• Impedance matching can be achieved through the use of antireflection coatings, plasmonic structures, or resonant cavities that optimize the terahertz field concentration in the detector material

Detector materials

• The choice of detector material is a critical factor in determining the performance and suitability of a terahertz detector for a given imaging application
• Different materials offer unique properties and advantages for thermal and photonic detection, such as high temperature coefficients of resistance, suitable band gaps, or strong pyroelectric effects
• Advances in material science and nanotechnology continue to drive the development of novel detector materials with improved terahertz sensing capabilities

Semiconductors for photoconductors

• Semiconductors are the primary materials used in photonic terahertz detectors, particularly photoconductors
• The most common semiconductor materials for terahertz photoconductors are III-V compounds, such as gallium arsenide (GaAs), indium gallium arsenide (InGaAs), and indium antimonide (InSb)
• These materials offer suitable band gaps, high carrier mobilities, and the ability to be engineered through doping and epitaxial growth techniques to optimize their terahertz detection properties

Superconductors for bolometers

• Superconducting materials are widely used in thermal terahertz detectors, particularly bolometers, due to their high temperature coefficients of resistance and low noise characteristics
• Transition-edge sensors (TES) based on superconducting materials (niobium, aluminum) operate at the edge of their superconducting transition, offering extremely high sensitivity and fast response times
• High-temperature superconductors, such as yttrium barium copper oxide (YBCO), enable the development of terahertz bolometers that can operate at liquid nitrogen temperatures (77 K) rather than requiring more expensive liquid helium cooling

Pyroelectric crystal properties

• Pyroelectric crystals, such as lithium tantalate (LiTaO3) and triglycine sulfate (TGS), are used in thermal terahertz detectors that exploit the pyroelectric effect
• These materials exhibit a spontaneous electric polarization that changes with temperature, generating a measurable voltage when exposed to terahertz radiation
• Pyroelectric detectors offer broadband terahertz response, room-temperature operation, and relatively low cost, making them attractive for certain imaging applications

Plasmonic nanostructures

• Plasmonic nanostructures, such as metallic nanoantennas and metamaterials, can be integrated with terahertz detectors to enhance their performance
• These structures can concentrate the incident terahertz field into subwavelength volumes, increasing the local field intensity and improving the detector's sensitivity
• Plasmonic nanostructures can also be designed to provide frequency selectivity, polarization control, or impedance matching for more efficient terahertz coupling to the detector material

Cooling requirements

• Many terahertz detectors require cooling to minimize background thermal noise and achieve optimal performance
• The choice of cooling method depends on the desired operating temperature, detector type, and practical considerations such as cost, size, and power consumption
• Cooling requirements can range from room temperature operation for some thermal detectors to cryogenic temperatures near absolute zero for the most sensitive photonic detectors

Uncooled thermal detectors

• Some thermal terahertz detectors, such as pyroelectric detectors and certain microbolometers, can operate at room temperature without the need for active cooling
• These uncooled detectors offer advantages in terms of simplicity, compactness, and low power consumption, making them suitable for portable or low-cost terahertz imaging applications
• However, uncooled detectors typically have lower sensitivity and slower response times compared to cooled detectors

Thermoelectric cooling

• Thermoelectric coolers (TECs), also known as Peltier coolers, are solid-state devices that can be used to cool terahertz detectors to temperatures around 200-250 K
• TECs operate based on the Peltier effect, where a current flowing through a junction between two dissimilar conductors causes heat to be absorbed or released depending on the current direction
• Thermoelectric cooling is relatively simple and compact but has limited cooling capacity and efficiency, making it suitable for moderate cooling requirements

Stirling cycle coolers

• Stirling cycle coolers are mechanical refrigeration systems that can cool terahertz detectors to temperatures around 60-80 K
• They operate by cyclically compressing and expanding a working gas (helium) to remove heat from the detector and transfer it to a heat sink
• Stirling coolers offer higher cooling capacities and efficiencies than TECs but are more complex, expensive, and prone to vibrations that can affect detector performance

Liquid helium cryostats

• Liquid helium cryostats are used to cool terahertz detectors to temperatures near 4.2 K, which is the boiling point of liquid helium at atmospheric pressure
• These cryostats consist of insulated dewars that maintain a bath of liquid helium, into which the detector is immersed or thermally coupled
• Liquid helium cooling offers the lowest achievable temperatures and the highest detector sensitivities but is expensive, complex, and requires regular replenishment of the helium supply

Terahertz detector arrays

• Terahertz detector arrays are essential for many imaging applications, as they enable the simultaneous acquisition of spatial and spectral information about the target scene
• These arrays consist of multiple individual detector elements arranged in a one-dimensional (linear) or two-dimensional (focal plane) configuration
• The development of high-performance terahertz detector arrays involves several key considerations, including array architecture, readout circuitry, and pixel scaling challenges

Microbolometer arrays

• Microbolometer arrays are the most common type of uncooled terahertz detector array, consisting of a grid of individual microbolometer pixels
• Each pixel typically comprises a thin absorber layer (vanadium oxide, amorphous silicon) suspended on a thermally isolating structure (silicon nitride membrane) and connected to a readout circuit
• Microbolometer arrays offer the advantages of room-temperature operation, relatively low cost, and mature manufacturing processes adapted from infrared imaging technology

Focal plane array architectures

• Focal plane arrays (FPAs) are two-dimensional detector arrays that are placed at the focal plane of an imaging system's optics
• Terahertz FPAs can be based on various detector technologies, such as microbolometers, pyroelectric detectors, or photoconductors
• The choice of FPA architecture depends on factors such as the desired spectral range, sensitivity, speed, and operating temperature, as well as the availability of suitable readout integrated circuits (RO