5.2 Subverting genre tropes

Genre tropes are familiar elements that define storytelling conventions. Writers can subvert these tropes to create fresh, engaging narratives. Techniques like inverting expectations, blending genres, and deconstructing archetypes challenge audience assumptions and inject new life into well-worn genres.

Subverting tropes offers benefits like originality, audience engagement, and challenging stereotypes. However, it also carries risks of alienating fans or confusing viewers. Successful subversion requires careful balance, maintaining core genre promises while innovating secondary elements. Skillful execution can revitalize stale genres and create memorable storytelling experiences.

Defining genre tropes

• Genre tropes are recurring themes, characters, or plot devices that are commonly associated with specific genres
• Tropes serve as familiar elements that audiences expect and recognize within a particular genre
• Tropes can help establish the conventions and expectations of a genre, providing a framework for storytelling

Common tropes in popular genres

Top images from around the web for Common tropes in popular genres

• 

  Science Fiction Genre Poster | The second in a series. Once … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Publication: A Pictorial History of Science Fiction Films View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Science Fiction Genre Poster | The second in a series. Once … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Publication: A Pictorial History of Science Fiction Films View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Common tropes in popular genres

• 

  Science Fiction Genre Poster | The second in a series. Once … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Publication: A Pictorial History of Science Fiction Films View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Science Fiction Genre Poster | The second in a series. Once … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Publication: A Pictorial History of Science Fiction Films View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Action films often feature a lone hero facing impossible odds, high-stakes chase scenes, and explosive climaxes
• Romantic comedies typically include meet-cutes, misunderstandings that keep the couple apart, and grand gestures of love
• Horror movies frequently employ jump scares, isolated settings, and a seemingly unstoppable antagonist
• Science fiction stories commonly explore advanced technology, alien encounters, and dystopian futures

Purpose of tropes in storytelling

• Tropes provide a shorthand for quickly establishing genre and setting audience expectations
• They offer a familiar foundation that allows writers to build upon and subvert expectations
• Tropes can create a sense of comfort and nostalgia for audiences, tapping into shared cultural experiences
• They serve as a starting point for exploring deeper themes and ideas within a genre

Tropes vs clichés

• While tropes are recurring elements, clichés are overused and predictable tropes that have become tired and unoriginal
• Clichés lack the freshness and impact of well-executed tropes, often eliciting eye-rolls from audiences
• The line between tropes and clichés can be subjective, depending on the context and execution
• Skillful writers can breathe new life into tropes, preventing them from becoming clichés

Techniques for subverting tropes

• Subverting tropes involves taking familiar genre elements and twisting them in unexpected ways
• By challenging audience expectations, subversion can create fresh and engaging storytelling experiences
• Subversion requires a deep understanding of genre conventions and a willingness to take creative risks

Inverting expectations

• Inverting expectations involves taking a common trope and presenting its opposite or a surprising variation
• For example, instead of the typical "damsel in distress," a story might feature a capable female hero rescuing a male character
• Inverted expectations can challenge gender roles, power dynamics, or other societal norms
• This technique can make familiar stories feel new and thought-provoking

Blending genres

• Blending genres involves combining elements from different genres to create a unique and unexpected mix
• A romantic comedy might incorporate elements of science fiction, or a horror film might include a coming-of-age story
• Genre blending can lead to fresh perspectives and new storytelling possibilities
• Successful genre blends require a careful balance to avoid feeling disjointed or gimmicky

Deconstructing archetypes

• Deconstructing archetypes involves examining and subverting the typical roles and characteristics of genre characters
• A story might explore the darker aspects of a traditionally heroic archetype or humanize a villainous character
• Deconstruction can add depth and complexity to characters, challenging simplistic good-vs-evil narratives
• This technique can encourage audiences to question their assumptions about character types

Satirizing conventions

• Satirizing conventions involves poking fun at or critiquing the common tropes and clichés of a genre
• Satire can expose the absurdity or shallowness of certain genre elements, often through exaggeration or irony
• This technique can serve as a commentary on the genre itself or on broader societal issues
• Effective satire requires a delicate touch to avoid becoming mean-spirited or alienating audiences

Benefits of subverting tropes

• Subverting tropes can inject new life into well-worn genres, keeping storytelling fresh and engaging
• By challenging expectations, subversion can create memorable and impactful narrative experiences
• Subversion allows writers to explore deeper themes and ideas that might be limited by strict adherence to genre conventions

Originality and innovation

• Subverting tropes can lead to highly original and innovative stories that stand out in a crowded media landscape
• By breaking free from formulaic storytelling, writers can create unique and compelling narratives
• Originality can attract audiences seeking new and exciting experiences beyond the familiar
• Innovative approaches can inspire other creators and push the boundaries of what's possible within a genre

Audience engagement and surprise

• Subverting tropes can keep audiences actively engaged by constantly challenging their expectations
• Surprising twists and turns can create a sense of excitement and unpredictability, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats
• Subversion can encourage audiences to think more deeply about the story and its themes
• Engaging storytelling can lead to increased audience investment and loyalty

Challenging stereotypes and norms

• Subverting tropes can be a powerful tool for challenging harmful stereotypes and societal norms
• By presenting diverse and complex characters, stories can combat one-dimensional representations of marginalized groups
• Subversion can expose and critique the limitations of traditional gender roles, racial stereotypes, or other biases
• Challenging norms through storytelling can contribute to broader social conversations and progress

Revitalizing stale genres

• Subverting tropes can breathe new life into genres that have become predictable or stagnant
• By introducing fresh perspectives and unexpected elements, subversion can reignite interest in a genre
• Revitalized genres can attract new audiences and inspire a wave of innovative storytelling
• Successful subversion can demonstrate the ongoing relevance and potential of even the most well-established genres

Risks of subverting tropes

• While subverting tropes can lead to exciting and original storytelling, it also comes with potential risks and challenges
• Writers must carefully consider the impact of subversion on audience expectations and reception
• Unsuccessful attempts at subversion can alienate viewers and undermine the effectiveness of the story

Alienating genre fans

• Subverting tropes too drastically or without proper setup can alienate dedicated genre fans
• Fans who are deeply invested in the conventions and traditions of a genre may resist or reject extreme subversion
• Alienating a core audience can lead to backlash, negative reviews, and reduced support for a film or franchise
• Writers must find a balance between subversion and satisfying genre expectations to maintain fan engagement

Confusing unfamiliar audiences

• Subverting tropes can be confusing for audiences who are less familiar with the genre or its conventions
• Without a clear understanding of what's being subverted, viewers may struggle to appreciate the impact of the subversion
• Confusion can lead to disengagement, frustration, or a lack of investment in the story
• Writers must ensure that the subversion is accessible and understandable to a broad audience

Unsuccessful execution

• Subverting tropes requires skill, nuance, and careful execution to be effective
• Poorly executed subversion can come across as gimmicky, forced, or self-indulgent
• Unsuccessful attempts may fail to resonate with audiences or undermine the integrity of the story
• Writers must have a clear purpose and vision for their subversion, ensuring that it serves the narrative and themes

Subversion for subversion's sake

• Subverting tropes simply for the sake of being different or edgy can backfire
• Without a meaningful connection to the story or characters, subversion can feel gratuitous or disconnected
• Subversion should serve a narrative purpose, enhancing the themes or emotional impact of the film
• Writers must avoid falling into the trap of subverting tropes merely for shock value or novelty

Examples of subverted tropes in film

• Examining successful examples of subverted tropes in film can provide inspiration and guidance for writers
• These examples demonstrate the potential impact and effectiveness of well-executed subversion
• By studying how other films have approached subversion, writers can learn valuable techniques and strategies

Unconventional protagonists

• "Mad Max: Fury Road" (2015) subverts the typical male action hero trope by featuring a strong female lead in Furiosa
• "Psycho" (1960) famously subverts the protagonist trope by (spoiler alert) killing off the apparent main character early in the film
• "Memento" (2000) features a protagonist with anterograde amnesia, subverting the trope of the reliable narrator

Unexpected plot twists

• "The Sixth Sense" (1999) subverts the ghost story trope with its famous twist ending, revealing that (spoiler alert) the protagonist has been dead all along
• "Knives Out" (2019) subverts the classic whodunit formula by revealing the culprit early on and focusing on the aftermath
• "Parasite" (2019) constantly subverts audience expectations with its shifts in tone, genre, and character dynamics

Genre hybrids and mashups

• "Shaun of the Dead" (2004) blends the zombie horror genre with romantic comedy elements, subverting expectations of both genres
• "The Cabin in the Woods" (2011) combines horror with science fiction and meta-commentary, deconstructing horror tropes and archetypes
• "Get Out" (2017) merges horror with social satire, using genre tropes to explore deeper themes of racism and oppression

Meta-commentary on genre

• "Scream" (1996) subverts slasher film tropes through self-aware meta-commentary, with characters discussing the rules of horror movies
• "Blazing Saddles" (1974) satirizes Western genre conventions and racial stereotypes, breaking the fourth wall and highlighting the absurdity of tropes
• "Adaptation." (2002) blurs the lines between reality and fiction, subverting biopic and adaptation tropes while exploring the creative process

Balancing subversion and satisfaction

• While subverting tropes can lead to innovative storytelling, it's important to balance subversion with audience satisfaction
• Audiences still crave the emotional catharsis and narrative resolution that genres typically provide
• Striking the right balance ensures that subversion enhances rather than detracts from the viewing experience

Meeting core genre promises

• Despite subverting certain tropes, successful films still deliver on the core promises and emotional experiences of their genres
• A subversive romance should still provide a satisfying love story, even if it challenges traditional relationship dynamics
• A subversive action film should still deliver thrilling set pieces and high stakes, even if it subverts the lone hero archetype
• Meeting core genre promises helps maintain audience engagement and investment in the story

Subverting secondary elements

• One approach to balancing subversion and satisfaction is to subvert secondary or peripheral elements while maintaining the core genre experience
• For example, a mystery film might subvert the detective archetype but still provide a satisfying puzzle and resolution
• Subverting secondary elements allows for innovation and surprise without fundamentally altering the genre's appeal
• This approach can be less risky than attempting to subvert the central pillars of a genre

Foreshadowing and setup

• Effective subversion often relies on careful foreshadowing and setup to avoid feeling abrupt or unearned
• Planting subtle hints or clues throughout the story can prepare audiences for unexpected twists or reversals
• Foreshadowing helps subversion feel organic and integrated into the narrative, rather than coming out of nowhere
• Skillful setup can make even the most surprising subversions feel satisfying and inevitable in retrospect

Payoff and resolution

• Ultimately, subversion should lead to a meaningful payoff and resolution that justifies the departure from genre norms
• The subversion should contribute to a satisfying emotional or thematic conclusion, even if it defies expectations
• A well-executed payoff can leave audiences feeling both surprised and fulfilled, appreciating the subversion's impact
• Ensuring a strong resolution helps mitigate the risks of alienating or confusing viewers through subversion