2.1 Great Man Theory and Trait Theories

Leadership theories have evolved over time, starting with the Great Man Theory. This early approach believed leaders were born, not made, possessing innate qualities that destined them for greatness. It portrayed leaders as heroic figures who emerged in times of need.

Trait theories built on this foundation, identifying specific characteristics of effective leaders. These include cognitive abilities like intelligence, personality traits such as self-confidence, and interpersonal skills like sociability. While pioneering, these approaches have limitations in fully explaining leadership.

Great Man Theory Assumptions

Innate Leadership Qualities

Top images from around the web for Innate Leadership Qualities

• 

  Leadership styles: Which ones define you? - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Eight Leadership Essentials View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What Makes an Effective Leader? | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Leadership styles: Which ones define you? - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Eight Leadership Essentials View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Innate Leadership Qualities

• 

  Leadership styles: Which ones define you? - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Eight Leadership Essentials View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  What Makes an Effective Leader? | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Leadership styles: Which ones define you? - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Eight Leadership Essentials View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The Great Man Theory assumes that great leaders are born, not made
• Their innate qualities and characteristics destine them for leadership roles
• It proposes that leadership qualities are intrinsic - that great leaders are born with a set of specific traits and natural abilities that make them effective leaders
• The theory suggests that when there is a great need, a great leader will arise to meet that need
• Great leaders emerge when confronted with the appropriate situation (times of crisis, major challenges)

Heroic and Mythic Portrayals

• The Great Man Theory portrays great leaders as heroic, mythic, and uniquely destined to rise to leadership when needed
• The theory was influenced by the study of influential figures in history (Julius Caesar, Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma Gandhi)
• It implies that leadership is primarily a male quality, as the original theory was based on studies of primarily male leaders
• This reflects cultural views of the 19th century when the theory emerged, which assumed men were naturally suited for leadership roles
• The theory tends to romanticize and mythologize great leaders, presenting them as larger-than-life figures with almost supernatural abilities

Traits of Effective Leadership

Cognitive Abilities

• Intelligence: Effective leaders tend to have above average intelligence and strong verbal, perceptual, and reasoning abilities compared to non-leaders
• Knowledgeable: Leaders are often experts in their fields with in-depth understanding of the tasks and challenges faced by their organizations
• Insightful: The ability to analyze problems, interpret complex information, and make sound decisions is associated with leadership effectiveness

Personality and Temperament

• Self-confidence: Leaders are often self-assured, confident in their abilities, and believe that they can make a difference
• Self-confidence allows leaders to be assertive and decisive, even in the face of uncertainty or opposition
• Determination: Effective leaders are determined and persistent in pursuit of goals
• They show initiative, are proactive, and have the capacity to persevere in the face of obstacles (setbacks, resistance to change)
• Integrity: Leadership requires honesty, high ethical standards, and the ability to inspire trust
• Leaders with integrity take responsibility for their actions and are reliable and consistent in their behavior

Interpersonal Skills

• Sociability: Strong interpersonal and communication skills enable leaders to establish cooperative relationships
• Effective leaders tend to be friendly, outgoing, tactful, and diplomatic in their interactions with others
• Empathy: The ability to understand and relate to followers' perspectives, needs and feelings contributes to leadership effectiveness
• Emotional intelligence: Leaders skilled at perceiving, understanding and managing emotions in themselves and others tend to be more successful

Great Man vs Trait Theories

Pioneering Leadership Studies

• The Great Man and Trait theories were pioneering attempts to systematically study leadership
• They aimed to identify what characteristics differentiate leaders from non-leaders
• Trait theories have identified several traits (intelligence, self-confidence, determination) that appear to be consistently associated with leadership emergence and effectiveness across many contexts
• The theories can be applied to improve leader selection by using personality assessments and other tools to identify individuals with leadership potential based on key traits

Limitations and Critiques

• The theories fail to fully explain the wide range of observed leadership behaviors
• They do not account for how leadership may vary across different situations and contexts (military vs business settings)
• Traits alone are insufficient to fully explain effective leadership
• There is limited empirical support for the Great Man Theory's assumption that leadership is an innate, unchanging quality determined at birth
• Many recognized leaders developed their skills over time through experience and learning
• The trait approach has been criticized for undervaluing the importance of followers, situational factors, and the interactions between leaders and group members in shaping leadership processes
• The original Great Man Theory reflects a gender-biased, historically-bounded view of leadership
• It fails to recognize the significant contributions and capabilities of women as leaders